DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   Who was the perfect director for a film they made? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/650134-who-perfect-director-film-they-made.html)

OldBoy 03-24-20 07:48 PM

Who was the perfect director for a film they made?
 
I guess what Iím asking is, who could only direct a certain movie you either love or hated.

I look at MCU films and the ones the Russo Broís. directed are among the best in series, especially last 2 Avengers. I donít think anyone else could do those so well. I know many more fit the bill, but they have a style that makes their particular films better and imo highly rewatchable. And they really werenít anyone till Winter Soldier.

I know Spielberg films will be up there, but who else could have only made certain films?

Hazel Motes 03-24-20 07:51 PM

Re: Who was the perfect director for a film they made?
 
Every film David Lynch and Werner Herzog ever made.

andicus 03-24-20 08:38 PM

Re: Who was the perfect director for a film they made?
 
Guy Ritchie for Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels, as well as Snatch.

dex14 03-24-20 08:41 PM

Re: Who was the perfect director for a film they made?
 

Originally Posted by andicus (Post 13711396)
Guy Ritchie for Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels, as well as Snatch.

Basically any writer/director.

E Unit 03-24-20 08:45 PM

Re: Who was the perfect director for a film they made?
 
No, Ritchie built his own style with those movies. I can't see a lot of director's being able to put the touches Ritchie did.

Wes Anderson movies are solely his. No other director does that style.

andicus 03-24-20 08:56 PM

Re: Who was the perfect director for a film they made?
 

Originally Posted by E Unit (Post 13711402)
No, Ritchie built his own style with those movies. I can't see a lot of director's being able to put the touches Ritchie did.

Wes Anderson movies are solely his. No other director does that style.

Agreed. Ridiculous to state otherwise, especially considering that he also wrote them.

*edit* and re-reading it, I think we both misunderstood what Dex was saying.

I believe he's stating that anyone that writes and directs a film could fall under this category.

E Unit 03-24-20 09:00 PM

Re: Who was the perfect director for a film they made?
 
Ah, misread as well. So I guess the opposite of this thread would be "who was the wrong director for material he/she wrote and directed?" I'll go with Stephen King and Maximum Overdrive.

dex14 03-24-20 09:03 PM

Re: Who was the perfect director for a film they made?
 

Originally Posted by andicus (Post 13711415)
Agreed. Ridiculous to state otherwise, especially considering that he also wrote them.

*edit* and re-reading it, I think we both misunderstood what Dex was saying.

I believe he's stating that anyone that writes and directs a film could fall under this category.

Correct.
Tarantino
PTA
Coens
etc.

Crocker Jarmen 03-24-20 09:04 PM

Re: Who was the perfect director for a film they made?
 
A lot of documentaries come to mind. Like Terry Zwigoff's long friendship with Robert Crumb meant that only he could have been able to make Crumb.

EddieMoney 03-24-20 09:47 PM

Re: Who was the perfect director for a film they made?
 
David Lynch - Blue Velvet

TomOpus 03-25-20 03:21 AM

Re: Who was the perfect director for a film they made?
 

Originally Posted by E Unit (Post 13711402)
Wes Anderson movies are solely his. No other director does that style.

First director that came to mind. You can look at a single frame and know it's a Wes Anderson movie.

devilshalo 03-25-20 09:50 AM

Re: Who was the perfect director for a film they made?
 

Originally Posted by dex14 (Post 13711421)
Correct.
Tarantino
PTA
Coens
etc.

A part of me thinks PTA and Nolan could swap scripts and shoot films that come out very similar.

GoldenJCJ 03-25-20 12:27 PM

Re: Who was the perfect director for a film they made?
 
To keep the thread somewhat interesting and not just listing all unique directorís filmographies Iíll say:

Pulp Fiction - Tarantino

Blackkklansman - Spike Lee


those are the first two that popped into my head.

FunkDaddy J 03-25-20 04:07 PM

Re: Who was the perfect director for a film they made?
 
David Fincher - SE7EN

stvn1974 03-25-20 04:21 PM

Re: Who was the perfect director for a film they made?
 
Another vote for Lynch. I can't imagine Eraserhead coming out of anyone else's brain.

E Unit 03-25-20 04:50 PM

Re: Who was the perfect director for a film they made?
 

Originally Posted by GoldenJCJ (Post 13711789)
To keep the thread somewhat interesting and not just listing all unique directorís filmographies Iíll say:

Pulp Fiction - Tarantino

Blackkklansman - Spike Lee


those are the first two that popped into my head.

Although when I watched Pulp Fiction, I noticed he used a lot of Woody Allen shots, like characters talking with the camera down the hall. Thatís an Allen signature shot.

PhantomStranger 03-25-20 05:15 PM

Re: Who was the perfect director for a film they made?
 
Nolan's The Prestige. If you didn't know, a lot of the magic metaphors playing out in the movie represent his personal philosophy on filmmaking.

Why So Blu? 03-25-20 06:22 PM

Re: Who was the perfect director for a film they made?
 

Originally Posted by E Unit (Post 13711937)
Although when I watched Pulp Fiction, I noticed he used a lot of Woody Allen shots, like characters talking with the camera down the hall. Thatís an Allen signature shot.


In addition to Scorsese and John Carpenter. QT loves Assault on Precinct 13 due to its deliberate pace and cinematography, etc.

Mike86 03-25-20 06:30 PM

Re: Who was the perfect director for a film they made?
 
I feel like this question should really only apply in certain cases. I mean films that were written and directed by the same person are going to be the perfect film for that director because itís their idea and theyíre seeing it through.

The question would make more sense in situations where itís a director hired for a job or tasked with a film and did an exceptionally good job.

OldBoy 03-25-20 06:40 PM

Re: Who was the perfect director for a film they made?
 
Sergio Leone’s The Good, the Bad the Ugly. Arguably the best of the trilogy and up there with greatest of spaghetti westerns. He is utterly unique and all his westerns have certain style that no one else could replicate. of course he didn’t do much, but it seems that every one is a classic. That’s rare.

Perkinsun Dzees 03-25-20 07:51 PM

Re: Who was the perfect director for a film they made?
 
https://cimg6.ibsrv.net/gimg/dvdtalk...74f54bfb14.jpg

dex14 03-25-20 08:08 PM

Re: Who was the perfect director for a film they made?
 
:lol:
Perfect.

Crocker Jarmen 03-25-20 10:44 PM

Re: Who was the perfect director for a film they made?
 

Originally Posted by E Unit (Post 13711937)
Although when I watched Pulp Fiction, I noticed he used a lot of Woody Allen shots, like characters talking with the camera down the hall. Thatís an Allen signature shot.

Hmmm, now you've got me thinking of Pulp Fiction directed by Woody Allen. So far a lot of it is working.

rocket1312 03-26-20 12:11 AM

Re: Who was the perfect director for a film they made?
 

Originally Posted by OldBoy (Post 13711366)
I look at MCU films and the ones the Russo Broís. directed are among the best in series, especially last 2 Avengers. I donít think anyone else could do those so well. I know many more fit the bill, but they have a style that makes their particular films better and imo highly rewatchable. And they really werenít anyone till Winter Soldier.

What exactly is the Russos' style? I'm not trying to be a dick. I'm genuinely curious what stands out to you with regard to their direction? I can't say I've spent time studying their films particularly closely, but it seems to me the thing that made the Russos perfect for those movies was their experience in TV and a willingness to do whatever Feige wanted them to do.

devilshalo 03-26-20 02:09 AM

Re: Who was the perfect director for a film they made?
 
Lau Kar Leung - 36th Chamber of Shaolin


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:59 PM.


Copyright © 2018 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.