DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   Have the Oscars ever given out an acting award to someone who started as a comedian? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/625324-have-oscars-ever-given-out-acting-award-someone-who-started-comedian.html)

Hazel Motes 02-24-15 11:01 PM

Have the Oscars ever given out an acting award to someone who started as a comedian?
 
comedian, comedic actor or sketch show actor?

best I can come up with is Whoopi Goldberg.

they've nominated a bunch, but none have won to my recollection.

bluetoast 02-24-15 11:03 PM

Re: Have the Oscars ever given out an acting award to someone who started as a comedi
 
Robin Williams
Jamie Foxx

Hazel Motes 02-24-15 11:05 PM

Re: Have the Oscars ever given out an acting award to someone who started as a comedi
 
haha shit. oh yeah.

Groucho 02-24-15 11:07 PM

Re: Have the Oscars ever given out an acting award to someone who started as a comedi
 
Roberto Benigni
Tom Hanks
Sally Field
Goldie Hawn
Marisa Tomei
Mo'Nique
Red Buttons
George Burns
Tim Robbins

majorjoe23 02-24-15 11:08 PM

Re: Have the Oscars ever given out an acting award to someone who started as a comedi
 
Tom Hanks, Roberto Begnini, Nicolas
Cage, Sean Penn (counting Fast Times at Ridgemont High), Gina Davis.

Mondo Kane 02-24-15 11:37 PM

Re: Have the Oscars ever given out an acting award to someone who started as a comedi
 
Art Carney beat a Corleone.

Hazel Motes 02-25-15 01:25 AM

Re: Have the Oscars ever given out an acting award to someone who started as a comedi
 
guess I should have researched a little more.

MScottM 02-25-15 09:14 AM

Re: Have the Oscars ever given out an acting award to someone who started as a comedi
 
Bob Hope

Although he was never nominated for a competitive Oscar, Hope was awarded five honorary awards by the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Science.

Rypro 525 02-25-15 11:22 AM

Re: Have the Oscars ever given out an acting award to someone who started as a comedi
 
The guy from the Artist is apparently a big comedian in France. Believe thats the most recent one

Shannon Nutt 02-25-15 11:26 AM

Re: Have the Oscars ever given out an acting award to someone who started as a comedi
 
Kevin Spacey and Emma Thompson. They both started out in stand-up comedy before diving into acting.

Mr. Salty 02-25-15 11:47 AM

Re: Have the Oscars ever given out an acting award to someone who started as a comedi
 
Woody Allen
Charlie Chaplin
Harold Lloyd
Buster Keaton
Stan Laurel
Jack Lemmon
Art Carney
Red Buttons
Walter Matthau
George Burns
Jennifer Lawrence
Goldie Hawn
Geena Davis
Mo'Nique

Ash Ketchum 02-25-15 11:55 AM

Re: Have the Oscars ever given out an acting award to someone who started as a comedi
 

Originally Posted by Mr. Salty (Post 12406605)
Woody Allen
Charlie Chaplin
Harold Lloyd
Buster Keaton
Stan Laurel
Jack Lemmon
Art Carney
Red Buttons
Walter Matthau
George Burns
Jennifer Lawrence
Goldie Hawn
Geena Davis
Mo'Nique

When were Jennifer Lawrence and Geena Davis comedians?

Mr. Salty 02-25-15 12:11 PM

Re: Have the Oscars ever given out an acting award to someone who started as a comedi
 

Originally Posted by Ash Ketchum (Post 12406615)
When were Jennifer Lawrence and Geena Davis comedians?

Jennifer Lawrence's first big gig was as a regular on the sitcom "The Bill Engvall Show" (although you could argue it wasn't actually funny) and Geena Davis started out mostly in comedy, including "Tootsie," "Family Ties" and "Buffalo Bill."

Though they weren't stand-up comics, the OP did qualify the question as "comedian, comedic actor or sketch show actor."

Shannon Nutt 02-25-15 02:50 PM

Re: Have the Oscars ever given out an acting award to someone who started as a comedi
 

Originally Posted by Mr. Salty (Post 12406629)
Jennifer Lawrence's first big gig was as a regular on the sitcom "The Bill Engvall Show" (although you could argue it wasn't actually funny) and Geena Davis started out mostly in comedy, including "Tootsie," "Family Ties" and "Buffalo Bill."

Though they weren't stand-up comics, the OP did qualify the question as "comedian, comedic actor or sketch show actor."

By this logic, Leonardo DiCaprio is a comedian...so when he wins, we can add him to the list.

inri222 02-25-15 03:26 PM

Re: Have the Oscars ever given out an acting award to someone who started as a comedi
 

Originally Posted by Mr. Salty (Post 12406605)
Charlie Chaplin
Harold Lloyd
Buster Keaton
Stan Laurel

Honorary Oscars.

digidoh 02-26-15 09:48 AM

Re: Have the Oscars ever given out an acting award to someone who started as a comedi
 

Originally Posted by Mr. Salty (Post 12406605)
Woody Allen

Allen hasn't received an Oscar for acting. According to Wikipedia (which is hardly ever wrong (except when it's not right)), Allen was only nominated for acting once (Annie Hall, 1977). He lost to Richard Dreyfuss (The Goodbye Girl).

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of...by_Woody_Allen

Groucho 02-26-15 09:54 AM

Re: Have the Oscars ever given out an acting award to someone who started as a comedi
 
For an example of the opposite, look at Kevin Kline. After years of dramatic credentials, he finally won an Oscar for a comedic role in A Fish Called Wanda.

Ash Ketchum 02-26-15 09:57 AM

Re: Have the Oscars ever given out an acting award to someone who started as a comedi
 

Originally Posted by Groucho (Post 12407565)
For an example of the opposite, look at Kevin Kline. After years of dramatic credentials, he finally won an Oscar for a comedic role in A Fish Called Wanda.


After decades of serious roles on TV, Leslie Nielsen only got Emmy nominations for his comedy roles (in 1982 and 1989, no wins).

EddieMoney 02-26-15 10:12 AM

Re: Have the Oscars ever given out an acting award to someone who started as a comedi
 
Not quite the same, but Sean Penn won for "Mystic River" following the comedy "I Am Sam."

Rob V 02-26-15 03:31 PM

Re: Have the Oscars ever given out an acting award to someone who started as a comedi
 
I'm waiting for Carrot Top or Paulie Shore to emerge as the next Oscar hopeful

Brack 02-27-15 06:12 AM

Re: Have the Oscars ever given out an acting award to someone who started as a comedi
 

Originally Posted by Shannon Nutt (Post 12406876)
By this logic, Leonardo DiCaprio is a comedian...so when he wins, we can add him to the list.

:lol: He was the best part of Growing Pains by the time he arrived.

Helen Hunt works well in this respect.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:11 PM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.