View Poll Results: Anakin or Luke...which story did you like better?
Voters: 63. You may not vote on this poll
Anakin or Luke...which story did you like better?
#1
Inane Thread Master, 2018 TOTY
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Are any of us really anywhere?
Posts: 49,439
Received 912 Likes
on
772 Posts
Anakin or Luke...which story did you like better?
as told by the PT and OT, which story did you prefer?
I'm going to have to say Luke just because I think the actors playing the various Anakin's in PT were atrocious.
Mark Hamill portrayed Luke with so much verve and just enough ham to make him someone to root for. while i love the character of Vader, the story was more about his rise prior to the mask...
I'm going to have to say Luke just because I think the actors playing the various Anakin's in PT were atrocious.
Mark Hamill portrayed Luke with so much verve and just enough ham to make him someone to root for. while i love the character of Vader, the story was more about his rise prior to the mask...
#2
Banned
Join Date: Jan 2006
Posts: 6,584
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Anakin or Luke...which story did you like better?
Inane thread master strikes again with easily the most inane thread yet. Do you seriously believe anyone is going to prefer the PT over the OT? Seriously? This is easily the most one-sided question of all time.
#4
Inane Thread Master, 2018 TOTY
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Are any of us really anywhere?
Posts: 49,439
Received 912 Likes
on
772 Posts
Re: Anakin or Luke...which story did you like better?
i not asking which set do you prefer, there is still a story of redemption with Anakin in the OT, which i thought was still powerful and made it a close race with Luke's origins...
#5
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Anakin or Luke...which story did you like better?
Is this really even a question? Luke hands down and it isn't even close. The Prequel Trilogy wasn't good at all and the story of Anakin wasn't very interesting to see unfold. I think the story of his transformation into Vader could have been a lot more interesting, but the way it was done it just wasn't and it made him look like a whiney bitch more than anything. Also honestly one of the cool things about Vader in the Original Trilogy was sort of the mystique behind the character. Trying to make the entire Star Wars saga about the tragedy of that character sort of ruined some of that if you ask me.
Luke's story arc was much more interesting overall. Seeing him go from the somewhat whiney farmboy to his evolution to a hero/Jedi Knight who ultimately had to take on his own father to defeat the Empire was way more interesting and just told a better story in so many ways.
Luke's story arc was much more interesting overall. Seeing him go from the somewhat whiney farmboy to his evolution to a hero/Jedi Knight who ultimately had to take on his own father to defeat the Empire was way more interesting and just told a better story in so many ways.
#6
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Anakin or Luke...which story did you like better?
Luke
I hate whiny brat teenagers in real life, I don't want watch a three film saga about one.
I hate whiny brat teenagers in real life, I don't want watch a three film saga about one.
#7
Re: Anakin or Luke...which story did you like better?
I voted for Anakin because nobody else will.
#9
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Anakin or Luke...which story did you like better?
The way your initial post is worded makes it sound like you're comparing the stories of the two characters in their respective trilogies. In some ways the redemption of Anakin/Vader is interesting but still overall I'd give the edge to Luke. The only real evolution of Vader was in Return of the Jedi when we saw his inner conflict having to choose between his son and the Emperor/the Empire.
#10
DVD Talk Godfather
Re: Anakin or Luke...which story did you like better?
I voted Anakin, as his story arc is actually far more interesting and developed. Specifically, I find the idea of a "chosen one" as a boy growing up, falling from grace and descending into darkness a cool concept; especially the circumstances around his fall and letting emotions like love, jealousy, power and the thought of death and the possibility of preventing it. Luke is more of your basic unsuspecting normal guy turned hero.
This is independent of the quality of the actual movies/trilogies themselves as obviously the execution of said story left a lot to be desired
This is independent of the quality of the actual movies/trilogies themselves as obviously the execution of said story left a lot to be desired
#11
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Anakin or Luke...which story did you like better?
Anakin is burning up on Mustafar screaming at Obiwan and my reaction was? "Thank god we don't have to hear that whiny bitch anymore."
Luke. The Anakin story just failed to move me in any dramatic way.
Luke. The Anakin story just failed to move me in any dramatic way.
#12
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Aug 2010
Posts: 2,080
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Anakin or Luke...which story did you like better?
Of course in Jedi he almost instantly becomes stoic and monk-like.
Consistant character development is not the series' strong suit.
#14
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Anakin or Luke...which story did you like better?
Have you ever actually watched The Empire Strikes Back? Luke is every bit as whiny and bratty as Anakin is. Watch anything on Dagobah with Yoda and tell me he hasn't somehow become even worse after ANH.
Of course in Jedi he almost instantly becomes stoic and monk-like.
Consistant character development is not the series' strong suit.
Of course in Jedi he almost instantly becomes stoic and monk-like.
Consistant character development is not the series' strong suit.
Anakin is more just whiney drama about being held back by the Council and having to hide his love of Padme and whatnot. Granted some of what happened was the fault of him being told that he was the chosen one and all that, but he went down the path rather than rejecting it and was upset over some of what came with his responsibility as a Jedi. He ultimately was much more selfish too and took some pretty drastic measures to save the woman he loved. In ways I could see where he was coming from but killing a bunch of Jedi as well as the young Padawans was pretty damn selfish and just made him a piece of shit.
Last edited by Mike86; 01-19-15 at 01:03 PM.
#15
Re: Anakin or Luke...which story did you like better?
This is just silly.
#17
Re: Anakin or Luke...which story did you like better?
Luke is the better story but Anakin had a good plot that was told in three shitty, awkward movies. As suggested a long time ago in various threads....it would have worked as one movie.
#20
Inane Thread Master, 2018 TOTY
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Are any of us really anywhere?
Posts: 49,439
Received 912 Likes
on
772 Posts
Re: Anakin or Luke...which story did you like better?
you know they really do start out as legitimate arguments in my head. debating the two focal storylines in 6 movies isn't exactly inanity.
#21
Banned
Join Date: Jan 2006
Posts: 6,584
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Anakin or Luke...which story did you like better?
I voted Anakin, as his story arc is actually far more interesting and developed. Specifically, I find the idea of a "chosen one" as a boy growing up, falling from grace and descending into darkness a cool concept; especially the circumstances around his fall and letting emotions like love, jealousy, power and the thought of death and the possibility of preventing it. Luke is more of your basic unsuspecting normal guy turned hero.
This is independent of the quality of the actual movies/trilogies themselves as obviously the execution of said story left a lot to be desired
This is independent of the quality of the actual movies/trilogies themselves as obviously the execution of said story left a lot to be desired
#23
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Anakin or Luke...which story did you like better?
I voted Anakin, as his story arc is actually far more interesting and developed. Specifically, I find the idea of a "chosen one" as a boy growing up, falling from grace and descending into darkness a cool concept; especially the circumstances around his fall and letting emotions like love, jealousy, power and the thought of death and the possibility of preventing it. Luke is more of your basic unsuspecting normal guy turned hero.
This is independent of the quality of the actual movies/trilogies themselves as obviously the execution of said story left a lot to be desired
This is independent of the quality of the actual movies/trilogies themselves as obviously the execution of said story left a lot to be desired
#24
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Anakin or Luke...which story did you like better?
Having just clicked over from the Landlords on my case about my cleanliness! thread, I am now pretty much convinced that OldBoy is a thread hoarder.
#25
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Anakin or Luke...which story did you like better?
as told by the PT and OT, which story did you prefer?
I'm going to have to say Luke just because I think the actors playing the various Anakin's in PT were atrocious.
Mark Hamill portrayed Luke with so much verve and just enough ham to make him someone to root for. while i love the character of Vader, the story was more about his rise prior to the mask...
I'm going to have to say Luke just because I think the actors playing the various Anakin's in PT were atrocious.
Mark Hamill portrayed Luke with so much verve and just enough ham to make him someone to root for. while i love the character of Vader, the story was more about his rise prior to the mask...
Last edited by Hokeyboy; 01-19-15 at 03:15 PM.