DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   Rogue One: A Star Wars Story (12/16/16, D: Edwards) S: Jones, Luna, Mendelsohn, Yen (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/620224-rogue-one-star-wars-story-12-16-16-d-edwards-s-jones-luna-mendelsohn-yen.html)

dex14 12-29-14 09:31 AM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 
The article says there is no direct implication that he will be playing Solo... if this rumor is even true.

He would be an awful choice for a young Solo.

Guru Askew 12-29-14 10:03 AM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 

Originally Posted by DaveyJoe (Post 12346730)
I would think history would leave you folks very wary of prequel stories with this franchise.

So you're saying that Disney should just declare everything before the end of ROTJ off-limits?

Seems absolutely arbitrary, especially in a situation like this. I can't imagine that a post-ROTJ old-man Han Solo story has as much potential as a young Solo origin story.

There is potential for cool Star Wars stories at pretty much any given point in the SW timeline.

DaveyJoe 12-29-14 10:56 AM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 

Originally Posted by Guru Askew (Post 12346791)
So you're saying that Disney should just declare everything before the end of ROTJ off-limits?

Seems absolutely arbitrary, especially in a situation like this. I can't imagine that a post-ROTJ old-man Han Solo story has as much potential as a young Solo origin story.

There is potential for cool Star Wars stories at pretty much any given point in the SW timeline.

Everything featuring those characters, yeah. They should come up with new stories featuring new characters. We saw how the prequels turned out. A Han Solo prequel story would feature some BS with characters like Lando and Jabba that are just there to wink at the audience instead of further the plot, and there would be no suspense because we know Han doesn't die. For the record, I don't really want to see Old Han/Luke/Leia either.

TGM 12-29-14 11:28 AM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 
if the prequels kicked ass, then people wouldn't care if the Skywalker clan was always at the center of every Star Wars movie between now and doomsday. Then again, if my mother had wheels she'd be a car...

Ranger 12-29-14 11:46 AM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 
If it's Han Solo, then I wonder if young Leia and Luke get their own spin-offs.

I was just thinking that it'd be interesting if the spin-off was about the Millennium Falcon itself, like the James Luceno book, as Fortune cover with the Falcon. It could cover the previous owners of the Falcon, how Lando got it and lost it to Han, etc.

d2cheer 12-29-14 12:13 PM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 

Originally Posted by Mike86 (Post 12345973)
I know nothing is confirmed yet but I think Aaron Paul would be a decent choice for young Han Solo.





Originally Posted by dex14 (Post 12346748)
The article says there is no direct implication that he will be playing Solo... if this rumor is even true.

He would be an awful choice for a young Solo.

I agree. He should be a black actor.

Spoiler:
-wink- Idris Elba

resinrats 12-29-14 12:14 PM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 
I always thought they'd do a R2 & 3PO movie.

Guru Askew 12-29-14 12:20 PM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 
There's no meat on the bone when it comes to a Luke Skywalker origin story. The existing story dictates that he lived a dull and unremarkable life before ANH. It would basically show him doing farm chores and at best you could have a scene with him shooting wamprats in his skyhopper or whatever its called. You could probably repurpose all the stuff from the deleted scenes with his friends too but even then that's not a movie that would really interest many people except for farm chore enthusiasts.

Leia's story could potentially have interesting elements with the rebellion forming around her as she grew up but even then it could easily fall into PT-style beaurocratic or aristocratic boredom.

Han Solo, on the other hand, could be dropped into just about any adventure you could think off before or even during the OT.

Mike86 12-29-14 12:41 PM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 

Originally Posted by dex14 (Post 12346748)
The article says there is no direct implication that he will be playing Solo... if this rumor is even true.

He would be an awful choice for a young Solo.

I don't think he'd be that bad of a choice. He's a good young actor as proven on Breaking Bad. I wouldn't say that he's had the best film career to date but I think that's just the films he's been in haven't been the greatest not necessarily that he's bad in them. I could kind of see him as a young Solo.

dex14 12-29-14 12:59 PM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 
I like Paul... but he is no Han Solo. No way. The only way to cast this is with an unknown.

DaveyJoe 12-29-14 02:10 PM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 

Originally Posted by Mike86 (Post 12346926)
I don't think he'd be that bad of a choice. He's a good young actor as proven on Breaking Bad. I wouldn't say that he's had the best film career to date but I think that's just the films he's been in haven't been the greatest not necessarily that he's bad in them. I could kind of see him as a young Solo.

He was great as Jesse Pinkman, but I haven't seen enough to know if he has any range. Has anybody seen him in Exodus?

joe_b 12-29-14 02:41 PM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 
Yeah, there's no way in hell Aaron Paul is playing Han. First, he looks nothing like Ford. Second, he's older than Harrison was in the first film. If we do see a Solo movie, I'm sure it will be a teenage version so the audience can actually buy that this is the same person at an earlier point in their life.

I really wish they would nix the idea of making prequel films for established characters, but it looks like that ain't happening.

TGM 12-29-14 02:47 PM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 
I want an 2-1B prequel movie. With him in medical school, residency, etc.

Mike86 12-29-14 02:52 PM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 

Originally Posted by DaveyJoe (Post 12346990)
He was great as Jesse Pinkman, but I haven't seen enough to know if he has any range. Has anybody seen him in Exodus?

His best film role is probably Smashed.


Originally Posted by joe_b (Post 12347031)
Yeah, there's no way in hell Aaron Paul is playing Han. First, he looks nothing like Ford. Second, he's older than Harrison was in the first film. If we do see a Solo movie, I'm sure it will be a teenage version so the audience can actually buy that this is the same person at an earlier point in their life.

Actually Aaron Paul is 35 which is the same age that Harrison Ford was when A New Hope came out. Paul looks younger than Ford even at that age did though so I think he could get away with playing a Han in his late twenties or early thirties. I don't think we'll see a Han in his teens, I'd imagine the film would focus more on his smuggling days before meeting up with Luke and Obi-Wan.

DaveyJoe 12-29-14 03:03 PM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 

Originally Posted by TGM (Post 12347042)
I want an 2-1B prequel movie. With him in medical school, residency, etc.

What about a 'Scrubs' style sitcom?


Originally Posted by Mike86 (Post 12347053)
His best film role is probably Smashed.

Never heard of it.

Mike86 12-29-14 03:06 PM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 

Originally Posted by DaveyJoe (Post 12347073)
Never heard of it.

It wasn't really a mainstream film and was more indie.

Shannon Nutt 12-29-14 05:00 PM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 
Given the reported fate of said character in Episode VIII, a prequel that comes either right before or right after that movie (depending on when they're going to release it) makes sense.

Although I'm unsure about someone else playing Han Solo...although it semi-worked for Indiana Jones.

Honestly, I'd rather see a movie about a lesser-known character...like Lando, perhaps.

At least they didn't go with Yoda or Ben Kenobi...I have no interest in seeing either - especially after all the Clone Wars stuff (sure, animated, but enough with the Jedi - I want to see stories from outside that realm).

Shannon Nutt 12-29-14 05:04 PM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 

Originally Posted by joe_b (Post 12347031)
Yeah, there's no way in hell Aaron Paul is playing Han. First, he looks nothing like Ford. Second, he's older than Harrison was in the first film. If we do see a Solo movie, I'm sure it will be a teenage version so the audience can actually buy that this is the same person at an earlier point in their life.

Maybe Paul will play the guy who gives Han his vest.

"You lost today, kid...but that doesn't mean you have to like it." ;)

windom 12-29-14 05:28 PM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 

Originally Posted by TGM (Post 12347042)
I want an 2-1B prequel movie. With him in medical school, residency, etc.

I'd be up for that. I've been wondering how he first met FX-7 all these years.

Jason 12-31-14 08:41 AM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 
I want a Jar Jar movie, preferably marketed as a SAW sequel.

Abob Teff 12-31-14 09:31 PM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 

Originally Posted by TGM (Post 12347042)
I want an 2-1B prequel movie. With him in medical school, residency, etc.

Star Wars: Grey Metal Anatomy

Abob Teff 12-31-14 09:41 PM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 

Originally Posted by DaveyJoe (Post 12346730)
Exactly, after 6 movies I'm sick of the Skywalker fucking family. Aaron Johnson was great in Breaking Bad, but I don't want to see him(or anybody else) imitating the iconic Ford role. I would think history would leave you folks very wary of prequel stories with this franchise. All we're hearing about these films makes it seem like Disney is just cashing in on the Star Wars name and doesn't bode well for having exciting new stories to tell.

Aaron Paul is nothing more than Nicolas Cage for a new age.

If they want to tell me a story about the Rebellion, the Clone Wars, the Sith, or any other "prequel" event I am OK with that. If they want to continue shoehorning in one family and one set of characters, I am out.

If you took this approach to real history it would entail George Washington's descendants continually crossing paths with the descendants of Thomas Jefferson and Benjamin Franklin as they lead the United States to victory in the Civil War, WWI, WW2, the Korean War, Vietnam, the Gulf War, and the War on Drugs. (Yes, that is intended to be as goofy as I wrote it.)

karoomba 01-02-15 01:26 PM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 
Clearly a Han Solo prequel film can only star Shia LaBeouf!

Shannon Nutt 01-02-15 02:50 PM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 

Originally Posted by karoomba (Post 12350407)
Clearly a Han Solo prequel film can only star Shia LaBeouf!

...and monkeys. Don't forget the monkeys.

Drexl 01-02-15 08:55 PM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 
I'd rather see Paul as Dash Rendar in a Shadows of the Empire movie.

Abob Teff 01-02-15 09:26 PM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 

Originally Posted by Shannon Nutt (Post 12350483)
...and monkeys. Don't forget the monkeys.

Those aren't monkeys ... they are baby Chewbaccas!

windom 01-02-15 09:42 PM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 

Originally Posted by Abob Teff (Post 12350738)
Those aren't monkeys ... they are baby Chewbaccas!

Maybe one of the spinoffs could feature Lumpawaroo. He should be fully grown at this point.

joe_b 01-10-15 12:56 AM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 
Gary Whitta has left the movie after finishing an initial draft. There's speculation a new screenwriter will be brought in:

http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/hea...e-loses-762372

EDIT: Slash Film now has an unconfirmed report that Simon Kinberg is revising the script. So they're replacing the guy who wrote After Earth with the guy who wrote X-Men: The Last Stand? Talk about going from bad to worse. At this rate, I'm expecting Akiva Goldsman to be brought in to script the next spin-off (with revisions by Ehren Kruger, of course). :sarcasm:

dex14 01-20-15 09:49 PM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 
:thumbsup: :thumbsup: :thumbsup: :thumbsup: :thumbsup: to Maslany.


The first Star Wars standalone could come under attack from a clone.

Sources tell The Hollywood Reporter that Tatiana Maslany, the Canadian actress who stars as multiple replicants in BBC America's hit series Orphan Black, is testing for the female lead in the Star Wars spinoff that is being directed by Gareth Edwards.

Rooney Mara, who starred in the David Fincher version of Girl With the Dragon Tattoo, is also due to test this week among a handful of others, according to multiple sources.

Additionally Felicity Jones, who just received an Oscar nomination for best actress for her work in The Theory of Everything, is said to be on the want list, although there may be scheduling issues with Inferno, the Da Vinci Code sequel that Ron Howard is due to direct this spring and summer.

Plot and character details for the movie (will it focus on young Han Solo? Young Leia?) are being kept hidden deep in an R2 unit. Insiders say that reading and testing for the movie occurred in the U.K. in December and has now moved stateside.

At this stage, Lucasfilm has two Star Wars standalones in development, one with Edwards, the filmmaker behind last year's Godzilla movie, and Josh Trank. Only the Edwards one has a release date: Dec. 16, 2016.

Edwards' project is currently seeking writers after Garry Whitta completed a first draft and left the project.

In the aftermath, rumors surfaced that Simon Kinberg, who is already co-writing the Trank standalone with Lawrence Kasdan, would take over writing during. Sources, however, say that while Kinberg is creatively involved in Star Wars in an overall manner, there are no plans for him to take over. Kinberg is additionally crafting the X-Men universe, writing the X-Men: Apocalypse script for Fox and overseeing the upcoming Fantastic Four reshoots for which he did the rewrites.

Disney had no comment on the testing nor did the actress' reps.
https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/he...testing-764807

joe_b 01-20-15 10:07 PM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 
Ugh, I really don't care for Rooney Mara... so I'm sure she'll get the role. :lol:

Only seen Felicity Jones in bit parts on Doctor Who and in The Amazing Spider-Man 2 (seemed like a poor choice for Black Cat if that's where they're heading), so it's hard to judge her. I do think Tatiana is a talented actress. Haven't watched Orphan Black yet, but she was great as Ghost in Ginger Snaps 2.

Mabuse 01-21-15 09:30 AM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 
The sexist in me doesn't really want a SW film centered on a female character. My daughters will probably love it.

Obi-Wanma 01-21-15 09:32 AM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 
It doesn't say that the film is centered on a female character. It says they are testing for the female lead. Presumably there could also be male leads. Carrie Fisher is the female lead of the OT.

Ranger 01-21-15 09:38 AM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 
I like the Orphan Black show.

Now I'm thinking maybe X-Wing spin-off with a female pilot as the lead. Would be strange if they leave out the Force users and light sabers but it could work.

Josh-da-man 01-21-15 12:33 PM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 
Star Wars needs more chicks. It's too much of a sausagefest as it stands now.

Michael Corvin 01-21-15 08:46 PM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 
Yeah, but Leia and Padme more than made up for the lack of other females.

superdeluxe 01-21-15 10:36 PM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 
Kate Mara also screen tested.

hanshotfirst1138 01-21-15 10:58 PM


Originally Posted by superdeluxe (Post 12371962)
Kate Mara also screen tested.

Is she a hot property right now? She seems to mostly be stuck in supporting roles.

devilshalo 01-26-15 07:49 PM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 

'Star Wars' Stand-alone Movie Hiring Oscar-Nominated Writer (Exclusive)
3:58 PM PST 1/26/2015 by Borys Kit, Austin Siegemund-Broka

Sources tell The Hollywood Reporter that the latest scribe headed to a galaxy far, far away is Chris Weitz, whose credits include the 2002 film About A Boy and Disney's upcoming Cinderella.
He will replace Gary Whitta, who exited the Lucasfilm/Disney project earlier this month after he completed a first draft.

Weitz is both a screenwriter and a director, not to mention an author. He received an Oscar nomination for his adapted screenplay for About A Boy, which he also co-directed. His other directing credits include the Oscar-nominated Demian Bichir drama A Better Life, The Golden Compass (he also wrote the script adapting the Philip Pulman YA fantasy) and — perhaps most notably — The Twilight Saga: New Moon.

He's also in the middle of writing a YA trilogy set in a post-apocalyptic world, with the first book, titled The Young World, having hit shelves last summer. He is repped by WME.

His hiring on Star Wars isn't the first time the franchise has seen a change of writers. Michael Arndt worked on a treatment and script for what would become Star Wars: Episode VII - The Force Awakens before leaving it more than a year after commencing. J.J. Abrams and Lawrence Kasdan took over the scripting duties.

Edwards' Star Wars movie is heating up and is in the early stages of casting. Actresses were testing in Los Angeles last week.

The movie is one of two spin-offs Disney and Lucasfilm have in development, with Chronicle's Josh Trank set to direct the second.

It has a release date of Dec. 16, 2016, a year after The Force Awakens hits theaters.

Ranger 01-26-15 09:58 PM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 
Hmm, interesting. Can he write/re-write a good story this quickly? Think I heard that they already have all the shooting locations scheduled.

joe_b 01-27-15 03:47 AM

re: Rogue One - Star Wars spinoff (12/16/16) D: Gareth Edwards
 
I thought he did a respectable job on The Golden Compass. Shame he never got to adapt the other two books.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:01 AM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.