The Martian -- 2015, D: Ridley Scott; S: Damon
#51
Re: The Martian -- D: Ridley Scott; S: Damon
This film looks like a mix of MISSION TO MARS, INTERSTELLAR and GRAVITY. And it's got at least two of the cast of INTERSTELLAR. Aren't you guys tired of this stuff by now?
My question is this: if Damon is stranded on Mars, why doesn't he do what Nolan had McConnaughey do in INTERSTELLAR? Go into a black hole, without a space ship, and communicate via Morse Code to his daughter in Texas. It's so easy!
My question is this: if Damon is stranded on Mars, why doesn't he do what Nolan had McConnaughey do in INTERSTELLAR? Go into a black hole, without a space ship, and communicate via Morse Code to his daughter in Texas. It's so easy!
#52
DVD Talk Hero
Re: The Martian -- D: Ridley Scott; S: Damon
That's the single most scrutinized part of that movie, many people base their opinions of that movie (dislike) around that last minute addition.
#54
Banned
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Formerly known as "Solid Snake PAC"/Denton, Tx
Posts: 39,239
Likes: 0
Received 4 Likes
on
4 Posts
Re: The Martian -- D: Ridley Scott; S: Damon
I really thought it was a damn good movie and it would have even better if that last minute or two was changed. It just devalued so much of the film. I still really dig the movie but all it takes is that last bit and it just kills me like crazy.
#55
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Behind the Orange Curtain
Posts: 20,085
Likes: 0
Received 7 Likes
on
7 Posts
Re: The Martian -- D: Ridley Scott; S: Damon
Solid trailer. I'm interested.
On a character note, it looks like Wiig has the important role of constantly holding her hands together in front of her mouth and looking nervous.
On a character note, it looks like Wiig has the important role of constantly holding her hands together in front of her mouth and looking nervous.
#56
DVD Talk Legend
Re: The Martian -- D: Ridley Scott; S: Damon
Dave Bowman and the Podbay Doors: The Musical!! (without the music)
Last edited by Hokeyboy; 06-10-15 at 02:54 PM.
#57
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Re: The Martian -- D: Ridley Scott; S: Damon
I'm about 50 pages from finishing this book. It's excellent, and I'm genuinely looking forward to this movie.
The 'meet the crew' thing they did was a neat concept, but it was not executed very well. The trailer, on the other hand, was very, very good.
The 'meet the crew' thing they did was a neat concept, but it was not executed very well. The trailer, on the other hand, was very, very good.
#59
DVD Talk Godfather
Re: The Martian -- D: Ridley Scott; S: Damon
This film looks like a mix of MISSION TO MARS, INTERSTELLAR and GRAVITY. And it's got at least two of the cast of INTERSTELLAR. Aren't you guys tired of this stuff by now?
My question is this: if Damon is stranded on Mars, why doesn't he do what Nolan had McConnaughey do in INTERSTELLAR? Go into a black hole, without a space ship, and communicate via Morse Code to his daughter in Texas. It's so easy!
My question is this: if Damon is stranded on Mars, why doesn't he do what Nolan had McConnaughey do in INTERSTELLAR? Go into a black hole, without a space ship, and communicate via Morse Code to his daughter in Texas. It's so easy!
Spoiler:
But really, just 3 movies in space that aren't really similar at all would be enough to be "tired" of them?
#60
DVD Talk Hero
#61
Re: The Martian -- D: Ridley Scott; S: Damon
Interestingly, she has 3rd billing though (after Damon and Chastain), so it would appear her role is substantial.
#62
DVD Talk Hero
Re: The Martian -- D: Ridley Scott; S: Damon
Finally got around to seeing the trailer and it looks like Interstellar's "redheaded" cousin. I'll be there. A friend of mine read teh book and said it was awesome.
I did chuckle, because Kristen Wiig's sole purpose in that trailer is to hold her hands together over her mouth in despair.
I did chuckle, because Kristen Wiig's sole purpose in that trailer is to hold her hands together over her mouth in despair.
#64
DVD Talk Legend
Re: The Martian -- D: Ridley Scott; S: Damon
Anyone honestly think this will be any good? You guys saw PROMETHEUS, right?
I wonder how many "general public" moviegoers will see this trailer and think, "Hey, didn't we already see this movie last Christmas?"
I wonder how many "general public" moviegoers will see this trailer and think, "Hey, didn't we already see this movie last Christmas?"
#65
#66
DVD Talk Hero
Re: The Martian -- D: Ridley Scott; S: Damon
It all depends on the quality of the script. Scott storyboards and puts exactly what was in the script on screen with just enough necessary subtext to glue it together.
The only things a Scott movie guarantees anymore, are the specific tone and visuals. Old age must have hit him hard though, he has kept himself heavily buried in work since he turned 62...and now he's 77.
I like Andy Weir's imdb credits page:
Warcraft II: Tides of Darkness (Video Game) (programmer: installer)
Quite the career change
The only things a Scott movie guarantees anymore, are the specific tone and visuals. Old age must have hit him hard though, he has kept himself heavily buried in work since he turned 62...and now he's 77.
I like Andy Weir's imdb credits page:
Warcraft II: Tides of Darkness (Video Game) (programmer: installer)
Quite the career change
Last edited by RichC2; 06-10-15 at 05:41 PM.
#67
Re: The Martian -- D: Ridley Scott; S: Damon
» Thu May 1 2014 06:06:45 Flag ▼
| Reply |
IMDb member since April 2005
......Sir Ridley Scott is a cinematographer at heart. He is not much of a director, with -- as I said -- little interest or ability when it comes to story, writing, or actors and acting.
Scott's pictures are beautiful junk without those things, and it's no coincidence that his few good movies -- Alien, Blade Runner and The Duellists -- have all of them.
#69
DVD Talk Hero
Re: The Martian -- D: Ridley Scott; S: Damon
The_Strangeler
» Thu May 1 2014 06:06:45 Flag ▼
| Reply |
IMDb member since April 2005
......Sir Ridley Scott is a cinematographer at heart. He is not much of a director, with -- as I said -- little interest or ability when it comes to story, writing, or actors and acting.
Scott's pictures are beautiful junk without those things, and it's no coincidence that his few good movies -- Alien, Blade Runner and The Duellists -- have all of them.
» Thu May 1 2014 06:06:45 Flag ▼
| Reply |
IMDb member since April 2005
......Sir Ridley Scott is a cinematographer at heart. He is not much of a director, with -- as I said -- little interest or ability when it comes to story, writing, or actors and acting.
Scott's pictures are beautiful junk without those things, and it's no coincidence that his few good movies -- Alien, Blade Runner and The Duellists -- have all of them.
He just doesn't care to put his own spin on any given story, nor does he particularly care to dig into it and explore concepts past a surface level. A point of view? I guess that's it. Other than the point of view that "this looks beautiful!"
I just wish somebody would throw him a solid script again. This might be one for all I know.
#70
Re: The Martian -- D: Ridley Scott; S: Damon
It all depends on the script and how good the actors are. In Kingdom of Heaven Jeremy Irons, Edward Norton & Liam Neeson were good. Now Orlando Bloom, I wished that I could punch him through the tv screen. The acting in Prometheus was also a mixed bag.
#71
DVD Talk Legend
Re: The Martian -- D: Ridley Scott; S: Damon
The movie's been moved from a Thanksgiving release to an October 2nd release. I'm sure the studio will say its because it's so good they wanted to get it to audiences sooner, but we all know that's a bad signal about what the suits at Fox think about it.
It's switching places with the new Frankenstein movie, which won't be out until AFTER Halloween now, which probably tells you what Fox thinks of that movie, as well.
It's switching places with the new Frankenstein movie, which won't be out until AFTER Halloween now, which probably tells you what Fox thinks of that movie, as well.
#72
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Thread Starter
Re: The Martian -- D: Ridley Scott; S: Damon
The movie's been moved from a Thanksgiving release to an October 2nd release. I'm sure the studio will say its because it's so good they wanted to get it to audiences sooner, but we all know that's a bad signal about what the suits at Fox think about it.
It's switching places with the new Frankenstein movie, which won't be out until AFTER Halloween now, which probably tells you what Fox thinks of that movie, as well.
It's switching places with the new Frankenstein movie, which won't be out until AFTER Halloween now, which probably tells you what Fox thinks of that movie, as well.
#73
Re: The Martian -- D: Ridley Scott; S: Damon
<iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/TNu0Ei9y-Ko" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>
#74
DVD Talk Legend
Re: The Martian -- D: Ridley Scott; S: Damon
If Fox had moved it to January or February, THAT would have been a bad sign.
#75
DVD Talk Hero
Re: The Martian -- D: Ridley Scott; S: Damon
If it got moved to September or January/Feb that's a bad sign. October is fine.