DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   Elliot Page discussion thread (formerly Ellen Page) (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/618033-elliot-page-discussion-thread-formerly-ellen-page.html)

GoldenJCJ 03-18-21 05:08 PM

Re: Elliot Page discussion thread (formerly Ellen Page)
 

Originally Posted by urrutiap (Post 13907736)
Same with Bruce Jenner that was born and raised as a male.

You were born a male, Bruce Jenner. Same with Ellen Page born as a female.

You seem to be purposely taking a contumacious stance on the matter but literally no one is disputing this.

Runaway 03-18-21 06:13 PM

Re: Elliot Page discussion thread (formerly Ellen Page)
 

Originally Posted by urrutiap (Post 13907736)
Ellen Page was born a woman. Shes still Ellen Page. Period.

What about the star of Beetlejuice, Batman, Birdman or Spotlight. Is he still Michael Douglas? Question mark.

Decker 03-18-21 06:44 PM

Re: Elliot Page discussion thread (formerly Ellen Page)
 
I will never forget the first time I had a trans girl patient like 15 years ago. She was like seven. She was very nice and happy, but she was insistent she was a girl. Didn't want anyone to call her a boy. She would cry and say "I'm a girl!". And that's when it hit me and I finally understood. Clearly that's not a sexual desire thing. And it's not driven by the intention to compete in girl's athletics. Sometimes what a person just knows their gender is just isn't what their chromosomes say they are. And you know what? That's okay. Why force them to live their life a lie just because you feel it's better? How does that benefit them?
I am proud of Elliot for speaking out, and helping others understand. No matter how much I enjoyed Juno (and I loved that movie), I'm happier knowing he is living his best life now. Was a little sad to hear he got divorced already.

Dan 03-18-21 06:55 PM

Re: Elliot Page discussion thread (formerly Ellen Page)
 
I listened to a great interview with a clinician who specializes in transgender kids and there was some good discussion about some of the misconceptions. Really interesting.

Kurt D 03-18-21 06:57 PM

Re: Elliot Page discussion thread (formerly Ellen Page)
 

Originally Posted by MLBFan24 (Post 13907740)
The only problem I have with the Time magazine piece is...

...what is up with the shitty clothing? Put on some nice clothing for a photoshoot :lol:

They may not be flashy, but those are clearly quality threads, I bet that tee-shirt in the first shot cost close to $100.

GoldenJCJ 03-18-21 07:11 PM

Re: Elliot Page discussion thread (formerly Ellen Page)
 

Originally Posted by Decker (Post 13907873)
I will never forget the first time I had a trans girl patient like 15 years ago. She was like seven. She was very nice and happy, but she was insistent she was a girl. Didn't want anyone to call her a boy. She would cry and say "I'm a girl!". And that's when it hit me and I finally understood. Clearly that's not a sexual desire thing. And it's not driven by the intention to compete in girl's athletics. Sometimes what a person just knows their gender is just isn't what their chromosomes say they are. And you know what? That's okay. Why force them to live their life a lie just because you feel it's better? How does that benefit them?
I am proud of Elliot for speaking out, and helping others understand. No matter how much I enjoyed Juno (and I loved that movie), I'm happier knowing he is living his best life now. Was a little sad to hear he got divorced already.

It was a documentary called Gender Revolution hosted by Katie Couric that opened up my eyes. It’s not just about wanting to be a boy or a girl and insisting society fall in steps with their silly fantasies. For anyone who is having trouble understanding it, I’d recommend they watch it.


Edit: Even though that trailer says it’s on Netflix, I don’t see listed. Either way, search it out.

RichC2 03-18-21 09:34 PM

Re: Elliot Page discussion thread (formerly Ellen Page)
 
It'd be on Disney+ now due to Nat Geo.

story 03-18-21 09:38 PM

Re: Elliot Page discussion thread (formerly Ellen Page)
 

Originally Posted by urrutiap (Post 13907736)
Ellen Page was born a woman. Shes still Ellen Page. Period.

Same with Bruce Jenner that was born and raised as a male.

You were born a male, Bruce Jenner. Same with Ellen Page born as a female.

What a gross attitude.

GoldenJCJ 03-18-21 09:44 PM

Re: Elliot Page discussion thread (formerly Ellen Page)
 

Originally Posted by RichC2 (Post 13907944)
It'd be on Disney+ now due to Nat Geo.

Oh, good call! I didn’t think of that. I just checked, it is on Disney+. I’d recommend everyone watch it.

Daytripper 03-19-21 12:22 AM

Re: Elliot Page discussion thread (formerly Ellen Page)
 

Originally Posted by urrutiap (Post 13907736)
Ellen Page was born a woman. Shes still Ellen Page. Period.


Same with Bruce Jenner that was born and raised as a male.

You were born a male, Bruce Jenner. Same with Ellen Page born as a female.

Marjorie Taylor Greene, is that you ??

Hazel Motes 03-19-21 01:42 AM

Re: Elliot Page discussion thread (formerly Ellen Page)
 

Originally Posted by urrutiap (Post 13907736)
Ellen Page was born a woman. Shes still Ellen Page. Period.


Same with Bruce Jenner that was born and raised as a male.

You were born a male, Bruce Jenner. Same with Ellen Page born as a female.

Not only is Caitlyn Jenner a woman, and Elliot Page a man, but they are both on their way to your home as we speak to take away your Dr Seuss books.

Runaway 03-19-21 02:09 AM

Re: Elliot Page discussion thread (formerly Ellen Page)
 

Originally Posted by MLBFan24 (Post 13907740)
The only problem I have with the Time magazine piece is...

...what is up with the shitty clothing? Put on some nice clothing for a photoshoot :lol:

Clothing and haircut aren't the best choice, he looks like it's the first day of kindergarten, but that's the prerogative of men, no one asks you who are you wearing.

Noonan 03-19-21 07:07 AM

Re: Elliot Page discussion thread (formerly Ellen Page)
 
I'm not sure who needs to see this, but...


milo bloom 03-19-21 09:30 AM

Re: Elliot Page discussion thread (formerly Ellen Page)
 

Originally Posted by urrutiap (Post 13907736)
Ellen Page was born a woman. Shes still Ellen Page. Period.


Same with Bruce Jenner that was born and raised as a male.

You were born a male, Bruce Jenner. Same with Ellen Page born as a female.

An outdated and simplistic view of life, borne of centuries of repression by patriarchal and religious oppression.

Gender is a social construct - 99% of the things we associate with gender are culturally created and the rest aren't significant enough to matter.

Elliot Page is a man. Caitlin Jenner is a woman. Chelsea Manning is a woman. Autumn Burchett is a woman.

This is such a simple thing we can do to respect our fellow humans.

Artman 03-19-21 10:56 AM

Re: Elliot Page discussion thread (formerly Ellen Page)
 
It should only matter how we treat people, much more than what our personal beliefs may be. Do I actually think Elliot is a man? Of course not, but I'm more than happy to address a person by whatever they prefer.

leacha 03-19-21 06:52 PM

Re: Elliot Page discussion thread (formerly Ellen Page)
 

​​​​

The Black 03-19-21 07:42 PM

Re: Elliot Page discussion thread (formerly Ellen Page)
 

Originally Posted by milo bloom (Post 13908080)
An outdated and simplistic view of life, borne of centuries of repression by patriarchal and religious oppression.

Gender is a social construct - 99% of the things we associate with gender are culturally created and the rest aren't significant enough to matter.

Elliot Page is a man. Caitlin Jenner is a woman. Chelsea Manning is a woman. Autumn Burchett is a woman.

This is such a simple thing we can do to respect our fellow humans.

If urrutiap is one end of the spectrum, then you are the complete other end. Guess what? Both of you can be right. Why? Because everyone is entitled to their opinion.

My opinion: I hope for every human being to be happy, be whatever they want to be and cause no harm to others.

milo bloom 03-19-21 10:09 PM

Re: Elliot Page discussion thread (formerly Ellen Page)
 

Originally Posted by The Black (Post 13908408)
If urrutiap is one end of the spectrum, then you are the complete other end. Guess what? Both of you can be right. Why? Because everyone is entitled to their opinion.

My opinion: I hope for every human being to be happy, be whatever they want to be and cause no harm to others.

“Both sides are the same” kind of false equivalencies are the scourge of modern discourse.
Nobody is saying you have to date them or ask them into your home for drinks, but instead we are asking that they be treated with the same respect as everyone else. That includes using their proper pronouns.

urrutiap 03-19-21 10:53 PM

Re: Elliot Page discussion thread (formerly Ellen Page)
 
No i will not use the "proper pronoun" when it involved someone like Ellen Page or Bruce Jenner.


Why So Blu? 03-19-21 11:01 PM

Re: Elliot Page discussion thread (formerly Ellen Page)
 

Originally Posted by urrutiap (Post 13908513)
No i will not use the "proper pronoun" when it involved someone like Ellen Page or Bruce Jenner.


You know you're about to get banned right? Keep it up. :sarcasm:

majorjoe23 03-19-21 11:43 PM

Re: Elliot Page discussion thread (formerly Ellen Page)
 
Spoiler alert: You’ve probably called a trans person by their preferred pronoun and not even realized it.

Daytripper 03-20-21 12:39 AM

Re: Elliot Page discussion thread (formerly Ellen Page)
 
I always liked Page. And truly hope he's happy now. I also hope he can continue finding work as an actor.

urrutiap 03-20-21 08:53 AM

Re: Elliot Page discussion thread (formerly Ellen Page)
 
pretty sure Ellen Page is continuing to be an actress. Shes been in that Umbrella Academy show on Netflix where Hollywood actors and actresses go instead of ending up in a bad sci fi movie that ends up on the Sy Fy Channel

milo bloom 03-20-21 09:04 AM

Re: Elliot Page discussion thread (formerly Ellen Page)
 
He will continue to be an actor because there are creative types that can not only accept changes like this but can use them to deepen their stories and make them more meaningful.

DaveyJoe 03-20-21 10:11 AM

Re: Elliot Page discussion thread (formerly Ellen Page)
 

Originally Posted by urrutiap (Post 13908600)
pretty sure Ellen Page is continuing to be an actress. Shes been in that Umbrella Academy show on Netflix where Hollywood actors and actresses go instead of ending up in a bad sci fi movie that ends up on the Sy Fy Channel

Actor is a gender neutral term.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:48 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.