DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   9 extra's who completely ruined their scenes (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/608889-9-extras-who-completely-ruined-their-scenes.html)

FRwL 02-25-13 01:19 AM

Re: 9 extra's who completely ruined their scenes
 
Goodfellas scene- whoever wrote that article needs to be fucking have his brain examined.

RocShemp 02-25-13 08:36 AM

Re: 9 extra's who completely ruined their scenes
 

Originally Posted by Drexl (Post 11592415)
It's been a REALLY long time since I listened to it, but in the commentary for Gladiator, didn't Ridley Scott complain about one or more of the extras in the crowd? I'm not even sure that was the movie, actually.

When Maximus kills Commodus, one of the extras is scratching his head and just looks like he has no idea what just happened. That's the scene Ridley Scott points out in the commentary.

Tarantino 02-25-13 11:53 AM

Re: 9 extra's who completely ruined their scenes
 

Originally Posted by FRwL (Post 11592447)
Goodfellas scene- whoever wrote that article needs to be fucking have his brain examined.

Pot, meet kettle.

Guru Askew 02-25-13 12:18 PM

Re: 9 extra's who completely ruined their scenes
 
That guy who was in that Super Bowl ad kissing Bar Rafaeli is the king of distracting extras. I remember going crazy seeing him in Spider-Man, Austin Powers and Old School within a year plus a few other places. There's a YouTube video of him that will blow your mind with several appearances, and it's not even compete.

jeffkjoe 02-25-13 12:25 PM

Re: 9 extra's who completely ruined their scenes
 
Here's a classic goof:

In the movie CLIFFHANGER, Ralph Waite (aka, the father from the Waltons - not really an extra) - totally smiles like a maniac when the girlfriend falls to her death at the beginning:

Check out that CRAZY FACE at 1:52 and again at 2:50


<iframe width="560" height="315" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/5d6-5UdFCis" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

Groucho 02-25-13 12:28 PM

Re: 9 extra's who completely ruined their scenes
 
That was Michael Rooker's girlfriend. Waite's character barely knew her, might as well laugh it up.

Why So Blu? 02-25-13 12:33 PM

Re: 9 extra's who completely ruined their scenes
 

Originally Posted by Guru Askew (Post 11592902)
That guy who was in that Super Bowl ad kissing Bar Rafaeli is the king of distracting extras. I remember going crazy seeing him in Spider-Man, Austin Powers and Old School within a year plus a few other places. There's a YouTube video of him that will blow your mind with several appearances, and it's not even compete.

Yeah, he's one of the most famous ones of all. That's his professional gig.

Decker 02-25-13 01:03 PM

Re: 9 extra's who completely ruined their scenes
 

Originally Posted by Numanoid (Post 11589278)
9 extra's what?

I find none of those extras' goofs nearly as distracting as the extra apostrophe in this thread's title.

bootsy 02-25-13 01:12 PM

Re: 9 extra's who completely ruined their scenes
 

Originally Posted by Groucho (Post 11592935)
That was Michael Rooker's girlfriend. Waite's character barely knew her, might as well laugh it up.

:lol:

FRwL 02-25-13 02:18 PM

Re: 9 extra's who completely ruined their scenes
 

Originally Posted by Tarantino (Post 11592851)
Pot, meet kettle.

What if i told you...


...that grammar was intentional.[/morpheus]

Decker 02-26-13 06:22 PM

Re: 9 extra's who completely ruined their scenes
 

Originally Posted by joe_b (Post 11592270)
In the theatrical cut of The Phantom Menace, there were some distracting extras in the senate scene. When Amidala calls for the no confidence vote, a couple in one of the pods start waving their arms in front of them in protest. It was really overdone and looked as if they were trying to flag down a car. Of course, Lucas digitally replaced them in the DVD version. :lol:

http://www.starwarsautographcollecti...iggarCameo.jpg

Phantom Menace didn't have an original VHS release. It came to home video in 1999 in a pretty nice DVD. Maybe that original picture is from somebody's camcorder?

joe_b 02-26-13 06:28 PM

Re: 9 extra's who completely ruined their scenes
 

Originally Posted by Decker (Post 11594796)
Phantom Menace didn't have an original VHS release. It came to home video in 1999 in a pretty nice DVD. Maybe that original picture is from somebody's camcorder?

It certainly did have a VHS release (in April of 2000). The DVD didn't come along until the fall of 2001.

GoldenJCJ 02-26-13 07:26 PM

Re: 9 extra's who completely ruined their scenes
 

Originally Posted by Drexl (Post 11592415)
It's been a REALLY long time since I listened to it, but in the commentary for Gladiator, didn't Ridley Scott complain about one or more of the extras in the crowd? I'm not even sure that was the movie, actually.

I also seem to remember in one of the Mummy DVD commentaries Stephen Sommers goes on a rant about how one of the extras kept ruining takes by staring at the camera. In the end they had to use CG to cloud out his eyes to make him look more zombie-ish.

majorjoe23 02-26-13 07:38 PM

Re: 9 extra's who completely ruined their scenes
 

Originally Posted by joe_b (Post 11594802)
It certainly did have a VHS release (in April of 2000). The DVD didn't come along until the fall of 2001.

I thought Lucas even said for a bit that none of the films would be on DVD until the third fil came out, since they weren't sure they would have time to do a SE right.

The Valeyard 02-26-13 08:02 PM

Re: 9 extra's who completely ruined their scenes
 

Originally Posted by Decker (Post 11594796)
Phantom Menace didn't have an original VHS release. It came to home video in 1999 in a pretty nice DVD. Maybe that original picture is from somebody's camcorder?


Phantom Menace VHS - April 2000. DVD came out in 2001.

joe_b 02-26-13 08:26 PM

Re: 9 extra's who completely ruined their scenes
 

Originally Posted by majorjoe23 (Post 11594874)
I thought Lucas even said for a bit that none of the films would be on DVD until the third fil came out, since they weren't sure they would have time to do a SE right.

He did. But like so many other times in career, he went back on his word. :lol:

I'm sure he also saw high-def on the horizon and wanted to milk every penny from each format while the iron was hot. I certainly would have skipped the VHS had I known the DVD was coming so soon after.

Defiant1 02-26-13 11:41 PM

Re: 9 extra's who completely ruined their scenes
 
I can't find a Youtube clip of it but I'm surprised the battle scene from Star Trek Generations hasn't been mentioned yet. One of the extras on the bridge pumps his fist in a "YES!" motion after the Enterprise destroys the Bird-of-Prey, totally ruining the joke as Data (in his hyper-emotive state) does the same thing about five seconds later. It's even mentioned on the commentary track.

Deadman31 02-27-13 04:54 AM

Re: 9 extra's who completely ruined their scenes
 
I remember watching Braveheart during one of the battles(not sure where in the movie its been a long time) but there were two extras in the background prancing around and just acting strange not really fighting.

majorjoe23 02-27-13 06:48 AM

Re: 9 extra's who completely ruined their scenes
 

Originally Posted by Defiant1 (Post 11595090)
I can't find a Youtube clip of it but I'm surprised the battle scene from Star Trek Generations hasn't been mentioned yet. One of the extras on the bridge pumps his fist in a "YES!" motion after the Enterprise destroys the Bird-of-Prey, totally ruining the joke as Data (in his hyper-emotive state) does the same thing about five seconds later. It's even mentioned on the commentary track.

Weird, I thought someone had, then I thought maybe it had been in the article. But maybe someone just mentioned it in the comments on the article.

Mattflix 02-27-13 08:39 AM

Re: 9 extra's who completely ruined their scenes
 
Die Hard With a Vengeance - There's an extra I always notice in the scene where the subway gets bombed, a female extra in a dress. When McClane is scouring the train for the bomb he accidentally touches her and she screams, and he says sorry. Then from Zeus' perspective on the subway platform, the same extra in on the platform with her back to the camera and does a sideways scamper when the train blows.

She does nothing wrong, but she stands out as being obviously the same person.

Numanoid 03-04-13 09:40 PM

Re: 9 extra's who completely ruined their scenes
 
The Generations one never bothered me. It's a typical reaction to something like that, and the extra did it far less obviously, so in the universe of the film it makes sense. In fact, I didn't even notice it the first 20 times I saw it. But I agree that once you see it, it steals Data's thunder. They should have used another take.

GoldenJCJ 03-04-13 11:40 PM

Re: 9 extra's who completely ruined their scenes
 
I don't know what's worse, extras that ruin scenes or that there's people who have watched Star Trek Generations over 20 times!

bluetoast 03-04-13 11:44 PM

Re: 9 extra's who completely ruined their scenes
 

Originally Posted by The Valeyard (Post 11594898)
Phantom Menace VHS - April 2000. DVD came out in 2001.

And I read at the time that the laserdisc version was the last Japanese laserdisc film released.

RocShemp 03-05-13 08:22 AM

Re: 9 extra's who completely ruined their scenes
 
The Dark Knight. When Harvey Dent is giving his big speech about the Batman turning himself in. Look at the moment when a cop exclaims "no more dead cops!" Keep an eye on the extra almost directly in front of him. The guy gets a closeup and has this goofy bug-eyed look on his face when he's nodding emphatically. He looks like he's trying so hard to look serious and it just totally backfires. It cracks me up every time I watch that scene.

mrhan 03-05-13 08:33 AM

Re: 9 extra's who completely ruined their scenes
 

Originally Posted by bluetoast (Post 11601874)
And I read at the time that the laserdisc version was the last Japanese laserdisc film released.

There was also a VHS gift set.

http://i.ebayimg.com/t/Star-Wars-Epi...bew~~60_12.JPG


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:22 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.