DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   Jones, Refn, or Blomkamp? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/598410-jones-refn-blomkamp.html)

jrsl76 01-27-12 04:17 AM

Re: Jones, Refn, or Blomkamp?
 

Originally Posted by Matthew Chmiel (Post 11092549)
Speaking of slow burns, I'd even nominate Ti West based upon The House of the Devil, but he's made more than three films and Cabin Fever 2 is wretched.

You can't really count CF2 against him since it was taken out of his hands and reworked. He's disowned it.

I still need to see The Roost & Trigger Man, but I adore House Of The Devil & The Innkeepers.

The Bus 01-27-12 06:59 AM

Re: Jones, Refn, or Blomkamp?
 
I'm still waiting to see if <a href="http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0358475/">Lance Hammer</a> will ever release another film.

But, from the poll, Refn is the more mature and "better" director, with Neill Blommkampp being the more "exciting" director... We'll see what he does next.

RichC2 01-27-12 08:21 AM

Re: Jones, Refn, or Blomkamp?
 
Refn for me. I respect the fact that Jones is taking Sci-fi back to introspective scifi and liked Moon and Source Code to an extent, but I didn't find either particularly brilliant or memorable. I didn't like District 9 so Blomkamp is out.

Refn works extensively on the atmosphere of his movies, and that's something I've always really liked.

Osiris3657 01-27-12 08:21 AM

Re: Jones, Refn, or Blomkamp?
 
Dang it people, you're killing me about Refn. As I posted before, I included him because he's new to US audiences and relatively young (I consider 41 to be young for a director)

Osiris3657 01-27-12 08:25 AM

Re: Jones, Refn, or Blomkamp?
 
News on Jones' next project called Mute:

Jones said that he would be doing "another science fiction film, called Mute, which takes place in a future Berlin. It's a Blade Runner-inspired piece, a little love letter to that film." The premise is that in future Berlin, a woman's disappearance causes a mystery for her partner, a mute bartender. He must go up against the city’s gangsters to solve the mystery. The film takes place in the same timeline as Jones' Moon, and will feature Sam Rockwell in a cameo as his character Sam Bell.

Dr Mabuse 01-27-12 12:46 PM

Re: Jones, Refn, or Blomkamp?
 

Originally Posted by Supermallet (Post 11092550)
Refn is not comparable to the other two, as previous posters have mentioned. His filmmaking technique is more mature than the others, due to the fact that he's been making films since the 90's.

Agreed.

Refn will go down in history. He's a gigantic talent.

Tarantino 01-27-12 12:54 PM

Re: Jones, Refn, or Blomkamp?
 

Originally Posted by Osiris3657 (Post 11092690)
Dang it people, you're killing me about Refn. As I posted before, I included him because he's new to US audiences and relatively young (I consider 41 to be young for a director)

You're not giving US audiences enough credit. A lot of people have seen his other movies. He's not a rookie.

fumanstan 01-27-12 07:17 PM

Re: Jones, Refn, or Blomkamp?
 

Originally Posted by Supermallet (Post 11092550)
Refn is not comparable to the other two, as previous posters have mentioned. His filmmaking technique is more mature than the others, due to the fact that he's been making films since the 90's.

And he's 41!

fumanstan 01-27-12 07:18 PM

Re: Jones, Refn, or Blomkamp?
 
I hated District 9, so Blomkamp is out. I voted for Duncan Jones because of how much i loved Moon, but Refn and Drive was also fantastic.

Matthew Chmiel 01-27-12 07:45 PM

Re: Jones, Refn, or Blomkamp?
 

Originally Posted by Tarantino (Post 11093108)
You're not giving US audiences enough credit. A lot of people have seen his other movies. He's not a rookie.

Find me one person in the midwest, who doesn't spend their free time on movie message boards, who has seen Valhalla Rising.

... and go.

PopcornTreeCt 01-27-12 07:48 PM

Re: Jones, Refn, or Blomkamp?
 
Affleck is a good option as well.

Solid Snake 01-27-12 08:31 PM

Re: Jones, Refn, or Blomkamp?
 

Originally Posted by Matthew Chmiel (Post 11093559)
Find me one person in the midwest, who doesn't spend their free time on movie message boards, who has seen Valhalla Rising.

... and go.

there's someone like this on netflix...I know. If it were the South I'd say my sister.

MaximumPower 01-27-12 08:55 PM

Re: Jones, Refn, or Blomkamp?
 
Out of those three, Refn would get my vote. I've seen five of his movies and I enjoyed all of them. The other two, I've only seen one movie but both were excellent.

1 excellent movie + 4 good movies > 2 excellent movies

Arpeggi 01-27-12 09:55 PM

Re: Jones, Refn, or Blomkamp?
 
Poll is a joke because of the inclusion of Refn.

Osiris3657 01-28-12 12:15 AM

Re: Jones, Refn, or Blomkamp?
 
Fuck off, I can include whoever I want in MY poll.

Arpeggi 01-28-12 01:17 AM

Re: Jones, Refn, or Blomkamp?
 
If your intention is to look and sound like a clown, then you win.

Gerry P. 01-28-12 03:31 AM

Re: Jones, Refn, or Blomkamp?
 

Originally Posted by Matthew Chmiel (Post 11093559)
Find me one person in the midwest, who doesn't spend their free time on movie message boards, who has seen Valhalla Rising.

... and go.

Valhalla Rising is on Netflix Instant, so I would assume a fair amount of people have seen it.

Osiris3657 01-28-12 08:59 AM

Re: Jones, Refn, or Blomkamp?
 

Originally Posted by Arpeggi (Post 11093788)
If your intention is to look and sound like a clown, then you win.

If your intention is to look and sound like a troll, then you've done it successfully

http://techrights.org/files/trolltra...5004/troll.gif

Congratulations, you're the first person to make my ignore list! :thumbsup:

Dragon Tattoo 01-28-12 03:01 PM

Re: Jones, Refn, or Blomkamp?
 

Originally Posted by Gerry P. (Post 11093834)
Valhalla Rising is on Netflix Instant, so I would assume a fair amount of people have seen it.

Are some of you kidding me? Do you seriously think a large amount of people have seen that movie? I haven't, and I actually frequent movie forums! I've heard how "great" it is numerous times. Just haven
t gotten around to watching it.

No normal person has seen that movie. If you think they have, you're living in a world of delusion.

riotinmyskull 01-28-12 03:11 PM

Re: Jones, Refn, or Blomkamp?
 

Originally Posted by Dragon Tattoo (Post 11094174)
Are some of you kidding me? Do you seriously think a large amount of people have seen that movie? I haven't, and I actually frequent movie forums! I've heard how "great" it is numerous times. Just haven
t gotten around to watching it.

No normal person has seen that movie. If you think they have, you're living in a world of delusion.


Originally Posted by netflix.com
1,530 members reviewed Valhalla Rising


Originally Posted by netflix.com
388 members reviewed Bronson

i'd say more people have seen VALHALLA RISING than BRONSON

LickTheABCs 01-28-12 03:17 PM

Re: Jones, Refn, or Blomkamp?
 
I've watched both. :shrug: ..and as of the other night, Drive too. Which was badass.

Solid Snake 01-28-12 03:19 PM

Re: Jones, Refn, or Blomkamp?
 

Originally Posted by riotinmyskull (Post 11094181)
i'd say more people have seen VALHALLA RISING than BRONSON

nice...

Gerry P. 01-28-12 03:21 PM

Re: Jones, Refn, or Blomkamp?
 

Originally Posted by Dragon Tattoo (Post 11094174)
Are some of you kidding me? Do you seriously think a large amount of people have seen that movie? I haven't, and I actually frequent movie forums! I've heard how "great" it is numerous times. Just haven
t gotten around to watching it.

No normal person has seen that movie. If you think they have, you're living in a world of delusion.

You are a very special boy.

Anyway, my vote goes to Refn. If he's excluded, then I'll go for J.J. Abrahms.

fumanstan 01-28-12 03:21 PM

Re: Jones, Refn, or Blomkamp?
 

Originally Posted by Arpeggi (Post 11093788)
If your intention is to look and sound like a clown, then you win.

I reviewed the scores, and it turns out you actually won that one.

Ash Ketchum 01-28-12 04:39 PM

Re: Jones, Refn, or Blomkamp?
 
How do you pronounce the mature, 41-year-old, ten-films-to-his-credit Refn?

I'm assuming "reffin'," but then I'm the guy who thought Ralph Fiennes was pronounced the way it's spelled. (Wrong! It's pronounced "Rafe Fines.")


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:47 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.