Billy Crystal to host 2012 Oscars (So long Eddie)
#26
DVD Talk Hero
re: Billy Crystal to host 2012 Oscars (So long Eddie)
Last year was James Franco in drag, this year will be Eddie Murphy in a fat suit! I like where the Academy awards is headed.
It's always a good idea to attempt to bring in the Daddy Day Care demographic!
It's always a good idea to attempt to bring in the Daddy Day Care demographic!
#30
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: Sesame Street (the apt. next to Bob's)
Posts: 20,195
Likes: 0
Received 6 Likes
on
6 Posts
re: Billy Crystal to host 2012 Oscars (So long Eddie)
This could be great. Eddie Murphy of this millenium has been all about the fat suit, kiddie movies, and unbelievable bombs. However, there was a time when Murphy was a brilliant outlaw of comedy, poised to take up where no less than Richard Pryor left off. Just watch Delirious or Raw. People would actually protest at his shows.
Unfortunately, somewhere it all went wrong. A lot of his early movies still standup as comedy classics. Best Defense excepted. I think it was around the time of Harlem Nights. He got way too pleased with himself, surrounded himself with sycophants. I think Ebert pointed out that the biggest laughs in HN came during the opening credits when Murphy's name appeared like 5 times in a row. It was downhill after that. He did Boomerang and the Congress movie, and the vampire movie, and pumped a dry well for BHC3, and they all did middling box office. So he made the move into family friendly, which was something I never thought I would see from one of the edgiest, most ferocious comedians I'd ever seen. Of course, that led to some really awful movies. Did the fat suit cost him an Oscar for Dreamgirls? Who knows?
ANYWAY, this is his big chance. I'm looking forward to it. Of course, it being Oscar night, he's not going to do blue material, but I bet he can still do it in a big way. And this could certainly help his career. I'll be rooting for him.
Unfortunately, somewhere it all went wrong. A lot of his early movies still standup as comedy classics. Best Defense excepted. I think it was around the time of Harlem Nights. He got way too pleased with himself, surrounded himself with sycophants. I think Ebert pointed out that the biggest laughs in HN came during the opening credits when Murphy's name appeared like 5 times in a row. It was downhill after that. He did Boomerang and the Congress movie, and the vampire movie, and pumped a dry well for BHC3, and they all did middling box office. So he made the move into family friendly, which was something I never thought I would see from one of the edgiest, most ferocious comedians I'd ever seen. Of course, that led to some really awful movies. Did the fat suit cost him an Oscar for Dreamgirls? Who knows?
ANYWAY, this is his big chance. I'm looking forward to it. Of course, it being Oscar night, he's not going to do blue material, but I bet he can still do it in a big way. And this could certainly help his career. I'll be rooting for him.
#31
DVD Talk Gold Edition
re: Billy Crystal to host 2012 Oscars (So long Eddie)
I thought Life was funny, seems to be the last thing he did I enjoyed. However, him hosting the Oscars isn't a bad choice. He could bring the funny if he colors outside the lines.
#32
re: Billy Crystal to host 2012 Oscars (So long Eddie)
I'm a huge fan of Eddie Murphy as a stand up comic. The Oscars could almost be viewed as his first stand up gig in more than 20 years. On that level I'm pretty excited about this.
#33
DVD Talk Legend
re: Billy Crystal to host 2012 Oscars (So long Eddie)
I think the Oscars could do a hell of a lot worse than Eddie Murphy.....and they have. I honestly hope he gets his groove back for the Oscars and that the naysayers are pleasantly surprised... -kd5-
#34
re: Billy Crystal to host 2012 Oscars (So long Eddie)
To all the naysayers of the current 2011 Eddie Murphy being host,
I'm pretty jazzed about this choice. Eddie can still riff like nobody's business.
I'll take a tamer, laid-back Eddie Murphy over a seasoned Jon Stewart or even Chris Rock any day.
I'm pretty jazzed about this choice. Eddie can still riff like nobody's business.
I'll take a tamer, laid-back Eddie Murphy over a seasoned Jon Stewart or even Chris Rock any day.
#38
re: Billy Crystal to host 2012 Oscars (So long Eddie)
I agree with others here that Murphy hosting could be a very good thing--if he's allowed to be funny. But the track record on funny people allowed to actually be funny while hosting the Oscars hasn't been good in the post-Crystal era.
#39
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Feb 2001
Location: Back in the Good Ole USA
Posts: 21,766
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
re: Billy Crystal to host 2012 Oscars (So long Eddie)
better Eddie than Whoopi, Bill(tired of his act) crystal, and others..
and jesus, last year made the show the pits...
Eddie is something fresh and an actual comedian... the only other person i would want would be RG
and jesus, last year made the show the pits...
Eddie is something fresh and an actual comedian... the only other person i would want would be RG
#40
DVD Talk Legend
#44
DVD Talk Hero
re: Billy Crystal to host 2012 Oscars (So long Eddie)
I'm actually more concerned that Brett Ratner is producer than I am that Eddie Murphy is hosting.
Murphy will do fine assuming he is provided with decent material. If he's got a good sense of humor some self deprecating humor will come across sincere and funny.
Murphy will do fine assuming he is provided with decent material. If he's got a good sense of humor some self deprecating humor will come across sincere and funny.
#45
Moderator
re: Billy Crystal to host 2012 Oscars (So long Eddie)
I seem to recall Murphy doing a good job hosting the MTV Video Awards 25 years ago. So there you go.
#47
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Thread Starter
re: Billy Crystal to host 2012 Oscars (So long Eddie)
Did anybody know that Bruce Vilanche (this guy) is the head joke writer for the Oscars? He's always interviewed on those VH1 shows. Last year was awful! Forget about the deliveries of non comedians Franco and Hathaway, the jokes would have sucked had they been read by a professional.
#49
DVD Talk Legend
re: Billy Crystal to host 2012 Oscars (So long Eddie)
I hate professional joke writers and writers guild people that get so damned comfortable and lazy with their jokes and stories that good comedians and TV shows get cancelled because people just lose interest in the blandness of it.
Let Eddie do his thing dammit! Just caution him to take it easy on the profanity, don't want the censors bleeping every other word that comes out of his mouth. I have Delirious, I remember... -kd5-
Let Eddie do his thing dammit! Just caution him to take it easy on the profanity, don't want the censors bleeping every other word that comes out of his mouth. I have Delirious, I remember... -kd5-
#50
DVD Talk Hero - 2023 TOTY Award Winner
re: Billy Crystal to host 2012 Oscars (So long Eddie)
I predict he will play it too safe, be too respectful, and ultimately be passable but boring.