DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   Soul Surfer (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/589750-soul-surfer.html)

Patman 04-17-11 10:58 AM

Soul Surfer
 
Long story short: amatuer girl surfer champion gets left arm chomped off by a shark, and learns to come to grips with it all. Based on a true story.

The cast features AnnaSophia Robb as Bethany Hamilton in a solid turn, and Helen Hunt and Dennis Quaid as her parents. I can't really explain it, but I felt just sadness for Bethany as her story unfolded, but it slowly brings the focus of overcoming tragedy by reminding us that there are even bigger tragedies out there, and living right is the best revenge. The script is a little clunky at times, but its heart is in the right place.

I give it 2.75 stars, or a grade of B-.

Alvis 04-18-11 09:32 AM

Re: Soul Surfer
 
Real popular among church (Baptists) people, apparently. Not sure why as I haven't seen it.

Patman 04-18-11 10:17 AM

Re: Soul Surfer
 
Yeah, there's a bit of faith-based storyline going on, mainly answering that age-old question: Why does God let bad things happen. The short answer: to overcome adversity and inspire others.

Solid Snake 04-18-11 10:26 AM

Re: Soul Surfer
 

Originally Posted by Patman (Post 10730454)
Yeah, there's a bit of faith-based storyline going on, mainly answering that age-old question: Why does God let bad things happen. The short answer: to overcome adversity and inspire others.

They should tell that to the Jews in the Holocaust. I'm sure they'd love that response.

Patman 04-18-11 10:31 AM

Re: Soul Surfer
 
Your cynicism is delightful.

Giantrobo 04-18-11 04:30 PM

Re: Soul Surfer
 
Wow. :lol:

Groucho 04-18-11 04:35 PM

Re: Soul Surfer
 

Originally Posted by Patman (Post 10729111)
Long story short: amatuer girl surfer champion gets left arm chomped off by a shark, and learns to come to grips with it all.

Well, coming to grip anyway.

Patman 04-18-11 04:52 PM

Re: Soul Surfer
 
You didn't see what she can do with her feet...

Groucho 04-18-11 04:55 PM

Re: Soul Surfer
 
I saw an interview with the girl about the movie, and it truly is an inspirational story. I'm not thrilled that they felt the need to overlay a "Christian" message on top of it.

Boba Fett 04-18-11 05:01 PM

Re: Soul Surfer
 

Originally Posted by Groucho (Post 10731123)
I saw an interview with the girl about the movie, and it truly is an inspirational story. I'm not thrilled that they felt the need to overlay a "Christian" message on top of it.

I think some of its funding came from a Christian group. The real Bethany Hamilton showed up in a terrible surfing "documentary" that was more a commercial for a Christian Surfing Ministry. One of the bonus features was related to SOUL SURFER, so I'm not shocked there's a religious message attached.

SkullOrchard 04-18-11 05:15 PM

Re: Soul Surfer
 
The real Bethany Hamilton talks funny. Did the shark bite off a piece of her tongue too?

Numanoid 04-18-11 05:24 PM

Re: Soul Surfer
 

Originally Posted by Groucho (Post 10731123)
I saw an interview with the girl about the movie, and it truly is an inspirational story. I'm not thrilled that they felt the need to overlay a "Christian" message on top of it.

It's a true story, and the girl is very religious, apparently. So how is that "overlaying" a Christian message? That's ridiculous.

The article I read said that the studio really wanted to downplay her faith, because it doesn't "sell well".

TimeandTide 04-18-11 05:38 PM

Re: Soul Surfer
 

Originally Posted by Solid Snake PAC (Post 10730468)
They should tell that to the Jews in the Holocaust. I'm sure they'd love that response.

:doh:

Giantrobo 04-18-11 06:33 PM

Re: Soul Surfer
 
I heard the film was disarmingly good in spite of the Christian arm waving.

MrSmearkase 04-18-11 07:47 PM

Re: Soul Surfer
 
/\ Too soon :(

http://a.espncdn.com/media/other/200...amilton_vi.jpg

Solid Snake 04-18-11 08:59 PM

Re: Soul Surfer
 

Originally Posted by SkullOrchard (Post 10731151)
The real Bethany Hamilton talks funny. Did the shark bite off a piece of her tongue too?

she has a lisp thing going on..she has braces here but...I don't think that affects her speech...that's a little lisp I think.

<iframe title="YouTube video player" width="480" height="390" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/duelon0MF2o" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

Lateralus 04-18-11 08:59 PM

Re: Soul Surfer
 
rotfl threads in other forums are having the same basic discussion.


Diana says:

April 10, 2011 at 3:53 pm

She is a lovely and inspiring girl. She loves God also which is even better!

Reply


jay says:

April 11, 2011 at 7:57 am

Your an asshole!

rocket1312 04-18-11 09:09 PM

Re: Soul Surfer
 

Originally Posted by Numanoid (Post 10731170)
It's a true story, and the girl is very religious, apparently. So how is that "overlaying" a Christian message? That's ridiculous.

The article I read said that the studio really wanted to downplay her faith, because it doesn't "sell well".

Seriously. They make a movie about a girl who relied on her faith to overcome a horrible situation and you want them to remove the "faith" part? That's like criticizing Milk for "overlaying" a pro-gay rights message.

Numanoid 04-18-11 11:35 PM

Re: Soul Surfer
 

Originally Posted by Giantrobo (Post 10731256)
I heard the film was disarmingly good in spite of the Christian arm waving.

You're going to hell.


:lol:

PopcornTreeCt 04-19-11 12:27 AM

Re: Soul Surfer
 
"Soul" Surfer, ah I get it now.

TimeandTide 04-19-11 12:34 AM

Re: Soul Surfer
 

Originally Posted by Solid Snake PAC (Post 10731505)
she has a lisp thing going on..she has braces here but...I don't think that affects her speech...that's a little lisp I think.

Seriously, why do you even care?

Solid Snake 04-19-11 12:40 AM

Re: Soul Surfer
 
because someone mentioned her speech...I got curious..so....I found a video w/ her talking....soooo..yeah...

RocShemp 04-19-11 06:23 AM

Re: Soul Surfer
 
The trailers do nothing for me but I might catch it on TV down the road.


Originally Posted by Patman (Post 10731114)
You didn't see what she can do with her feet...

So this is foot fetish-themed erotica? :drool:

Giantrobo 04-19-11 09:04 AM

Re: Soul Surfer
 

Originally Posted by RocShemp (Post 10731973)

So this is foot fetish-themed erotica? :drool:

< Off to Youtube to search for Teen girls peeling bananas with their feet....

Solid Snake 04-19-11 09:53 AM

Re: Soul Surfer
 
<iframe title="YouTube video player" width="480" height="390" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/WPFRnyQ7Xro" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:55 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.