DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   Movies SAVED by the casting of ONE role (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/577137-movies-saved-casting-one-role.html)

MrSmearkase 07-28-10 02:58 PM

Re: Movies SAVED by the casting of ONE role
 

Originally Posted by thematahara (Post 10291988)
Also...Kevin Bacon, Tremors.

I dunno... Tremors still has its charms, although Bacon carries definitely it over the finish line.

toddly6666 07-28-10 03:01 PM

Re: Movies SAVED by the casting of ONE role
 
Vincent Gallo's penis

http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_F_2xvc04me...400/poster.jpg

Meglos 07-28-10 03:01 PM

Re: Movies SAVED by the casting of ONE role
 
http://a.imageshack.us/img829/8301/039z.jpg

Travis McClain 07-28-10 03:06 PM

Re: Movies SAVED by the casting of ONE role
 

Originally Posted by Meglos (Post 10292017)

It would have been different having Tom Selleck as Indy, but Raiders of the Lost Ark would have required a lot more changes than not having Harrison Ford for that to have turned out a bad movie.

notkevinbacon 07-28-10 03:09 PM

Re: Movies SAVED by the casting of ONE role
 

Originally Posted by thematahara (Post 10291988)
Also...Kevin Bacon, Tremors.

:lol: I hate to be "that guy" and I know this is an opinion question... but man, NO!!!

Fred Ward (just as important) and Kevin Bacon are great together... but I love Tremors all around. A lot. It's got a lot going for it besides just Kevin Bacon. Michael Gross is totally fun in it too... and Reba. Plus the creature design is one of the best ever IMHO... it's witty... it's fun and somewhat scary when it needs to be... it's a great little flick.

Sorry, I just totally disagree with this in every way possible.

Michael Corvin 07-28-10 03:11 PM

Re: Movies SAVED by the casting of ONE role
 

Originally Posted by MinLShaw (Post 10292031)
It would have been different having Tom Selleck as Indy, but Raiders of the Lost Ark would have required a lot more changes than not having Harrison Ford for that to have turned out a bad movie.

Yeah, Indy would have been different with Selleck, but it would have still been an awesome fucking movie.

Trevor 07-28-10 03:29 PM

Re: Movies SAVED by the casting of ONE role
 

Originally Posted by notkevinbacon (Post 10292038)
:lol: I hate to be "that guy" and I know this is an opinion question... but man, NO!!!

Fred Ward (just as important) and Kevin Bacon are great together... but I love Tremors all around. A lot. It's got a lot going for it besides just Kevin Bacon. Michael Gross is totally fun in it too... and Reba. Plus the creature design is one of the best ever IMHO... it's witty... it's fun and somewhat scary when it needs to be... it's a great little flick.

Sorry, I just totally disagree with this in every way possible.

I agree with all your points there. Tremors is a great flick even without you, I mean not you.

FRwL 07-28-10 04:56 PM

Re: Movies SAVED by the casting of ONE role
 
The Bergman-Pacino trilogy, the movies Bergman produced specifically tailored for Pacion, Serpico, Dog Day, Scarface. I liked Scarface's iconic bright 80s look though.

Numanoid 07-28-10 05:16 PM

Re: Movies SAVED by the casting of ONE role
 

Originally Posted by Jaymole (Post 10291210)
And people here are mentioning films like The Big Lebowski & There Will be Blood which do not fit in at all with what the OP is asking....in fact most of the films mentioned so far don't fit.

Yeah, this one went off the rails real fast. That's what I love/hate about this place. Few people answer the question as asked, while many answer the question as they would have asked it.

inri222 07-28-10 05:45 PM

Re: Movies SAVED by the casting of ONE role
 

Originally Posted by FRwL (Post 10292267)
The Bergman-Pacino trilogy, the movies Bergman produced specifically tailored for Pacion, Serpico, Dog Day, Scarface. I liked Scarface's iconic bright 80s look though.

Bregman as in Martin.

He also produced Sea of Love & Carlito's Way.

Buttmunker 07-29-10 02:51 PM

Re: Movies SAVED by the casting of ONE role
 
01: 12 Monkeys was good with Bruce Willis......but the insertion of Brad Pitt in the supporting role made it a GREAT MOVIE!!!

02: I personally didn't like The Usual Suspects, although Kevin Spacey allowed it to not get demoted to the "Bargain Bins."

03: Does it need mentioning that, without Anthony Hopkins as "Hannibal Lector" in Silence of the Lambs, it would have merely been a "pretty good flick."

Trevor 07-29-10 03:03 PM

Re: Movies SAVED by the casting of ONE role
 

Originally Posted by Buttmunker (Post 10293887)
03: Does it need mentioning that, without Anthony Hopkins as "Hannibal Lector" in Silence of the Lambs, it would have merely been a "pretty good flick."

No need to mention it because it isn't true. While I love Hopkins, Brian Cox was a better Lector imo, and at least proves that others could have done the role.

bunkaroo 07-29-10 03:40 PM

Re: Movies SAVED by the casting of ONE role
 
Wow nobody's mentioned Lord of the Rings yet. No way it would have had the same impact with Stuart Townsend as Aragorn. Viggo was perfect for the role IMO.

jfoobar 07-29-10 06:39 PM

Re: Movies SAVED by the casting of ONE role
 

Originally Posted by Trevor (Post 10293915)
No need to mention it because it isn't true. While I love Hopkins, Brian Cox was a better Lector imo, and at least proves that others could have done the role.

Agreed. Lector was simply a good role. Hopkins benefited from playing that role, but he was hardly deserving of all the praise he received for playing it. Cox in SotL would have been more sinister and intellectual and a better fit overall.

I am of a similar mind about Jack Nicholson in A Few Good Men.

Groucho 07-29-10 07:48 PM

Re: Movies SAVED by the casting of ONE role
 
I was going to walk out on The Fifth Element until Chris Tucker showed up and saved the movie.

boredsilly 07-29-10 07:49 PM

Re: Movies SAVED by the casting of ONE role
 
http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_gsUALeZML1...rt-englund.jpg

While I think the original Nightmare on Elm Street would have been decent without Englund, he is crucial to Dream Warriors working.

Heat 07-29-10 11:19 PM

Re: Movies SAVED by the casting of ONE role
 

Originally Posted by KillerCannibal (Post 10290443)
Anything starring Ah-nuld in the '80s, especially Commando.

While Ah-nuld was certainly good, a lot of the '80s roles were interchangable between Ah-nuld, Jesse "The Body" Ventura, and to an extent Sylvester Stallone. Just like Chuck Norris, Jean Claude Van Damme, and Steven Segal were all pretty interchangable.

Don't get me wrong, I really like them all as actors and love their movies, but you could switch them and still have a good movie.


Originally Posted by toddly6666 (Post 10292015)
Vincent Gallo's penis

I haven't seen the movie but heard that it was a dildo.

Nick Danger 07-30-10 11:26 PM

Re: Movies SAVED by the casting of ONE role
 

Originally Posted by MinLShaw (Post 10291197)
I don't think you need to speculate at all about what might have been; the OP simply asked if you could think of a movie where virtually nothing else worked, but one single performance rescued the entire production. That doesn't require any imagination; only an analysis of what you've actually seen.

Peter Cushing, Vincent Price, Christopher Lee, and Boris Karloff have been in many movies in which they were the only worthwhile ingredient. Through skillful performances, they raised movies from bad to tolerable.

My favorite Vincent Price story is that he would completely rewrite his own dialogue, leaving only the last couple of words of each line so the other actors would still have their cue.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:58 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.