Which 5 of the 10 Best Pic noms would have made the cut?
02-02-10, 08:04 AM
#1
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
Which 5 of the 10 Best Pic noms would have made the cut?
Which of the following 10 Best Picture nominees would have been on the list if there were still only five nominees?
The 10 nominees are:
AVATAR
THE BLIND SIDE
DISTRICT 9
AN EDUCATION
THE HURT LOCKER
INGLORIOUS BASTERDS
PRECIOUS
A SERIOUS MAN
UP
UP IN THE AIR
The 5 I'd suspect would have made the "short" list:
AVATAR
THE HURT LOCKER
INGLORIOUS BASTERDS
PRECIOUS
UP IN THE AIR
The 10 nominees are:
AVATAR
THE BLIND SIDE
DISTRICT 9
AN EDUCATION
THE HURT LOCKER
INGLORIOUS BASTERDS
PRECIOUS
A SERIOUS MAN
UP
UP IN THE AIR
The 5 I'd suspect would have made the "short" list:
AVATAR
THE HURT LOCKER
INGLORIOUS BASTERDS
PRECIOUS
UP IN THE AIR
02-02-10, 08:15 AM
#3
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Which 5 of the 10 Best Pic noms would have made the cut?
The directors are the easiest choice, but sometimes they don't match up. I think they would have done that this year, but if not I'll just guess that An Education would have made the cut (over what, I don't know). I just don't think something like District 9 or Up would get in with just 5 nominees.
That said, it is highly unlikely that a movie not nominated for directing would win. It hasn't happened since Driving Miss Daisy in 1990, and not since 1932 before that.
That said, it is highly unlikely that a movie not nominated for directing would win. It hasn't happened since Driving Miss Daisy in 1990, and not since 1932 before that.
02-02-10, 08:42 AM
#4
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Join Date: Nov 2001
Location: Guelph, Ontario
Posts: 9,921
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Which 5 of the 10 Best Pic noms would have made the cut?
Originally Posted by marty888
The 5 I'd suspect would have made the "short" list:
AVATAR
THE HURT LOCKER
INGLORIOUS BASTERDS
PRECIOUS
UP IN THE AIR
AVATAR
THE HURT LOCKER
INGLORIOUS BASTERDS
PRECIOUS
UP IN THE AIR
02-02-10, 08:44 AM
#5
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Berkeley, CA
Posts: 1,981
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Which 5 of the 10 Best Pic noms would have made the cut?
Basterds, Avatar, Hurt Locker, Up in the Air, Precious. Not coincidentally the 5 highest nomination-scorers and directing nominees. So the films "reaching the wider audience" are A Serious Man (Jews), Up (Kids), District 9 (Prawns), The Blind Side (retarded footballers and Bullock fans), and An Education (The Brits).
02-02-10, 08:45 AM
#6
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: Which 5 of the 10 Best Pic noms would have made the cut?
Why did they not say the producers name on some of them? They didn't know who produced it?
Bit confused.
Bit confused.
02-02-10, 09:12 AM
#7
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Join Date: Jun 2002
Posts: 8,487
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Which 5 of the 10 Best Pic noms would have made the cut?
Originally Posted by jdslater1
Why did they not say the producers name on some of them? They didn't know who produced it?
Bit confused.
Bit confused.
So I guess for those titles, there are more producers than the allowed number for nominations, and the studios haven't determined the final list of names to submit yet. You can imagine the amount of squabbling over this that probably goes on.
02-02-10, 09:14 AM
#8
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 1,361
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Which 5 of the 10 Best Pic noms would have made the cut?
I think they have a rule only up to 3- 4 people can be nominated as a Producer for Best Picture and that film probably has more than that. It's also the case in original song where you might have 4-5 writers.
02-02-10, 09:27 AM
#9
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Muskegon, MI
Posts: 5,199
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Which 5 of the 10 Best Pic noms would have made the cut?
Academy rules state that up to 3 producers can be named for a Best Picture nominee. According to IMDB, The Hurt Locker has 8 producers:
Kathryn Bigelow .... producer
Mark Boal .... producer
Nicolas Chartier .... producer
Jenn Lee .... associate producer
Tony Mark .... executive producer
Donall McCusker .... co-producer
Jack Schuster .... associate producer
Greg Shapiro .... producer
If the old rules were in place and Narc was nominated for Best Picture, the presenters would have had to read off 19 names!
Kathryn Bigelow .... producer
Mark Boal .... producer
Nicolas Chartier .... producer
Jenn Lee .... associate producer
Tony Mark .... executive producer
Donall McCusker .... co-producer
Jack Schuster .... associate producer
Greg Shapiro .... producer
If the old rules were in place and Narc was nominated for Best Picture, the presenters would have had to read off 19 names!
02-02-10, 10:14 AM
#10
Re: Which 5 of the 10 Best Pic noms would have made the cut?
Someone correct me if I'm wrong but I believe that only someone with the credit of "producer" and not "co-producer", "executive producer" or "associate producer" is eligible to win Best Picture. That still leaves 4 names for The Hurt Locker, so someone is getting bumped off.
02-02-10, 10:20 AM
#11
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Which 5 of the 10 Best Pic noms would have made the cut?
Originally Posted by mdc3000
THIS. Without question those would have been the 5.
02-02-10, 10:29 AM
#12
Re: Which 5 of the 10 Best Pic noms would have made the cut?
Originally Posted by marty888
Which of the following 10 Best Picture nominees would have been on the list if there were still only five nominees?
The 5 I'd suspect would have made the "short" list:
AVATAR
THE HURT LOCKER
INGLORIOUS BASTERDS
PRECIOUS
UP IN THE AIR
The 5 I'd suspect would have made the "short" list:
AVATAR
THE HURT LOCKER
INGLORIOUS BASTERDS
PRECIOUS
UP IN THE AIR
02-02-10, 11:15 AM
#13
Moderator
Re: Which 5 of the 10 Best Pic noms would have made the cut?
Absolutely this:
AVATAR
THE HURT LOCKER
INGLORIOUS BASTERDS
PRECIOUS
UP IN THE AIR
I'd love to think DISTRICT 9 would have made the cut, though I can't think of what wouldn't have made it instead.
AVATAR
THE HURT LOCKER
INGLORIOUS BASTERDS
PRECIOUS
UP IN THE AIR
I'd love to think DISTRICT 9 would have made the cut, though I can't think of what wouldn't have made it instead.
02-02-10, 11:39 AM
#14
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Which 5 of the 10 Best Pic noms would have made the cut?
Yeah have to agree with the consensus so far and go with
AVATAR
THE HURT LOCKER
INGLORIOUS BASTERDS
PRECIOUS
UP IN THE AIR
AVATAR
THE HURT LOCKER
INGLORIOUS BASTERDS
PRECIOUS
UP IN THE AIR
02-02-10, 11:54 AM
#16
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Which 5 of the 10 Best Pic noms would have made the cut?
Originally Posted by Groucho
My guess:
THE BLIND SIDE
DISTRICT 9
AN EDUCATION
A SERIOUS MAN
UP
THE BLIND SIDE
DISTRICT 9
AN EDUCATION
A SERIOUS MAN
UP
02-02-10, 12:14 PM
#17
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Which 5 of the 10 Best Pic noms would have made the cut?
Originally Posted by dogmatica
Absolutely this:
AVATAR
THE HURT LOCKER
INGLORIOUS BASTERDS
PRECIOUS
UP IN THE AIR
I'd love to think DISTRICT 9 would have made the cut, though I can't think of what wouldn't have made it instead.
AVATAR
THE HURT LOCKER
INGLORIOUS BASTERDS
PRECIOUS
UP IN THE AIR
I'd love to think DISTRICT 9 would have made the cut, though I can't think of what wouldn't have made it instead.
I can see Avatar for director and all the effects awards, but it's not a Best Picture IMO.
02-02-10, 01:09 PM
#19
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Sep 2004
Posts: 1,008
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Which 5 of the 10 Best Pic noms would have made the cut?
Originally Posted by bunkaroo
I agree except for Avatar. Record gross or not, I think either Blind Side or A Serious Man would have been in its place.
I can see Avatar for director and all the effects awards, but it's not a Best Picture IMO.
I can see Avatar for director and all the effects awards, but it's not a Best Picture IMO.
02-02-10, 01:19 PM
#20
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Which 5 of the 10 Best Pic noms would have made the cut?
Originally Posted by hapgilmore
Well you're gonna eat those words because Avatar is a shoe-in for best picture.
But seriously, why is it a shoe-in? Because of the box office numbers? Sure it's breaking ground with effects, but that doesn't equal a best pic award. A little film called Star Wars comes to mind.
And honestly, it's not that great of a film. Titanic is a better film, and that shouldn't have been best picture either.
02-02-10, 01:27 PM
#21
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: USDA Zone 6a
Posts: 1,741
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Which 5 of the 10 Best Pic noms would have made the cut?
Originally Posted by zekeburger1979
Avatar
The Hurt Locker
Inglourious Basterds
Up
Up in the Air
The Hurt Locker
Inglourious Basterds
Up
Up in the Air
02-02-10, 01:48 PM
#22
Senior Member
Re: Which 5 of the 10 Best Pic noms would have made the cut?
Originally Posted by bunkaroo
Really? We'll see. If it does win, I'll just take it as a huge apology from the Academy for snubbing The Dark Knight.
But seriously, why is it a shoe-in? Because of the box office numbers? Sure it's breaking ground with effects, but that doesn't equal a best pic award. A little film called Star Wars comes to mind.
And honestly, it's not that great of a film. Titanic is a better film, and that shouldn't have been best picture either.
But seriously, why is it a shoe-in? Because of the box office numbers? Sure it's breaking ground with effects, but that doesn't equal a best pic award. A little film called Star Wars comes to mind.
And honestly, it's not that great of a film. Titanic is a better film, and that shouldn't have been best picture either.
02-02-10, 02:11 PM
#23
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Which 5 of the 10 Best Pic noms would have made the cut?
Sorry, but I think Avatar is a better film than The Dark Knight.
I mean how much better is The Dark Knight than Batman Begins? I think they're both very good movies, but I've never understood all the praise that The Dark Knight got.
Personally, and not to sound like a heartless bastard, but I truly think that had Heath Ledger not died, The Dark Knight wouldn't have made nearly as much money as it did and nobody would would ever think of it as a best picture candidate.
Don't get me wrong, it was a good movie and Ledger did a very good job. It sure wasn't a virtuoso performance like people seem to think it was though and again, had he not died, I really don't think he would have gotten the praise he did either.
Looking at both films objectively, I fail to see how The Dark Knight was THAT much better than Batman Begins.
I mean how much better is The Dark Knight than Batman Begins? I think they're both very good movies, but I've never understood all the praise that The Dark Knight got.
Personally, and not to sound like a heartless bastard, but I truly think that had Heath Ledger not died, The Dark Knight wouldn't have made nearly as much money as it did and nobody would would ever think of it as a best picture candidate.
Don't get me wrong, it was a good movie and Ledger did a very good job. It sure wasn't a virtuoso performance like people seem to think it was though and again, had he not died, I really don't think he would have gotten the praise he did either.
Looking at both films objectively, I fail to see how The Dark Knight was THAT much better than Batman Begins.
02-02-10, 02:20 PM
#24
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Which 5 of the 10 Best Pic noms would have made the cut?
The answer to the question is so obvious, I have to post the inevitable:
Why is this a thread?
Why is this a thread?
