DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   What were Speilberg's influences for Saving Private Ryan? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/558030-what-were-speilbergs-influences-saving-private-ryan.html)

gglass4269 07-11-09 01:42 PM

What were Speilberg's influences for Saving Private Ryan?
 
Seeing how this is my favorite film, I'm really intrigued as to what films Speilberg looked at for inspiration. I just finished OVERLORD which shared alot of similarities with the opening shot of the men in the Higgins boat.

Dr Mabuse 07-11-09 01:49 PM

Re: What were Speilberg's influences for Saving Private Ryan?
 
A technically masterful opening sequence followed by a mediocre-to-crappy war film?

gglass4269 07-11-09 01:52 PM

Re: What were Speilberg's influences for Saving Private Ryan?
 
Overlord did come out about 23 years earlier then SPR...

Mr. Salty 07-11-09 02:16 PM

Re: What were Speilberg's influences for Saving Private Ryan?
 
As far as the filmmaking style, I don't know. But the plot was inspired by the true story of the Sullivan brothers.

cranberries fan 07-11-09 02:37 PM

Re: What were Speilberg's influences for Saving Private Ryan?
 
My guess was that he wanted to make a John Ford war movie for the 90's

Mondo Kane 07-11-09 02:40 PM

Re: What were Speilberg's influences for Saving Private Ryan?
 
There are a few Kurosawa influences.

The solider who picks his severed arm up during the fighting (Forgot which Kurosawa film originated this)

And the scene when Upham is watching a battle from the distance is reminiscent of the spy-abduction sequence from Seven Samurai when Katsushiro watches the event from a distance.

NoirFan 07-11-09 02:59 PM

Re: What were Speilberg's influences for Saving Private Ryan?
 

Originally Posted by Mondo Kane (Post 9563401)
The solider who picks his severed arm up during the fighting (Forgot which Kurosawa film originated this)

Do you mean Yojimbo, in which a stray dog carries a human hand in it's mouth?

Trout 07-11-09 03:05 PM

Re: What were Speilberg's influences for Saving Private Ryan?
 

Originally Posted by Mr. Salty (Post 9563366)
As far as the filmmaking style, I don't know. But the plot was inspired by the true story of the Sullivan brothers.

Actually, it was closer to the story of the Niland Brothers

JimRochester 07-11-09 03:10 PM

Re: What were Speilberg's influences for Saving Private Ryan?
 
I know Spielberg is a WWII buff and being Jewish has a lot of meaning for him personally. It is also one of my favorite films and at the top of my list for upgrades to Blu-ray.

Hokeyboy 07-11-09 03:57 PM

Re: What were Speilberg's influences for Saving Private Ryan?
 

Originally Posted by JimRochester (Post 9563443)
I know Spielberg is a WWII buff and being Jewish has a lot of meaning for him personally. It is also one of my favorite films and at the top of my list for upgrades to Blu-ray.

Steven Spielberg is JEWISH?!

William Fuld 07-11-09 05:23 PM

Re: What were Speilberg's influences for Saving Private Ryan?
 
Cornel Wilde's Beach Red was a big influence on SPR and The Thin Red Line.

NoirFan 07-11-09 05:37 PM

Re: What were Speilberg's influences for Saving Private Ryan?
 

Originally Posted by Hokeyboy (Post 9563504)
Steven Spielberg is JEWISH?!

You wouldn't think it from looking at his last name, but it's true. He was born Steven Spielstein, but changed his name once he got to Hollywood because he was worried it would sound too "ethnic".

RocShemp 07-11-09 05:58 PM

Re: What were Speilberg's influences for Saving Private Ryan?
 

Originally Posted by Hokeyboy (Post 9563504)
Steven Spielberg is JEWISH?!

I thought he was a Mexican. :hscratch:

NoirFan 07-11-09 06:00 PM

Re: What were Speilberg's influences for Saving Private Ryan?
 

Originally Posted by RocShemp (Post 9563622)
I thought he was a Mexican. :hscratch:

http://i226.photobucket.com/albums/d...oxart_160w.jpg

Navinabob 07-11-09 06:15 PM

Re: What were Speilberg's influences for Saving Private Ryan?
 
If I had to guess I'd say he stole everything from the secret CIA files on Frank Dux.

RocShemp 07-11-09 06:52 PM

Re: What were Speilberg's influences for Saving Private Ryan?
 

Originally Posted by NoirFan (Post 9563624)

Now who's a bright penny? ;)

ken_572002 07-11-09 11:30 PM

Re: What were Speilberg's influences for Saving Private Ryan?
 
Spielberg's biggest influences for Saving Private Ryan were:

1) The highly, highly acclaimed "The Story Of GI Joe"
2) "The Fighting Sullivans"

cdollaz 07-11-09 11:41 PM

Re: What were Speilberg's influences for Saving Private Ryan?
 
He's actually a Mexican Jew.

gglass4269 07-12-09 12:00 AM

Re: What were Speilberg's influences for Saving Private Ryan?
 

Originally Posted by cdollaz (Post 9564035)
He's actually a Mexican Jew.

I fking hate this site

The Bus 07-12-09 09:27 AM

Re: What were Speilberg's influences for Saving Private Ryan?
 
Really disappointing that no one has mentioned this yet.

<img src="http://camerastyloonline.files.wordpress.com/2009/01/comeandseepreview3.jpg">

gglass4269, Spielberg's style from SPR seems to come, IMHO at least in part, from Elem Klimov's Idi I Smotri (Come and See).

You should check it out.

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0091251/

Desslok 07-12-09 11:43 AM

Re: What were Speilberg's influences for Saving Private Ryan?
 
Check out a film called "A Walk in the Sun".


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:39 PM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.