Why does Terminator 3 get so much hate on here?
#26
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Why does Terminator 3 get so much hate on here?
I thought it was a solid popcorn action flick that just pales in comparasion to Terminator and T2. Both movies I thought were absolute classics for the genre while T3 was just a by the numbers action movie.
As for the end
It almost seemed like the studios decided that they wanted another Terminator movie eventhough there was perfect closure in the second one so they screwed with the ending of T2.
As for the end
Spoiler:
It almost seemed like the studios decided that they wanted another Terminator movie eventhough there was perfect closure in the second one so they screwed with the ending of T2.
I really liked the ballsy ending to T3 but it definitely had a Mummy Returns vibe to it where I got the feeling the only reason it was made was to transition to the next series of Terminator films.
#27
Member
Join Date: Sep 2008
Posts: 178
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Why does Terminator 3 get so much hate on here?
I've seen many posts talking about how Terminator 3 sucks. I couldn't disagree more. While nowhere near as good as T2, I think it is on par with T1. It has great action, a great villain, and a great surprise ending. Yes, some of the humor is cheesy but overall I like T3 a lot.
So what is everybody's beef??
So what is everybody's beef??
#28
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Nov 2007
Posts: 1,107
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Why does Terminator 3 get so much hate on here?
Yeah, I couldn't understand all the T3 hate either, especially when it came out it pretty goood reviews.
I remember before the movie came out, I was badmouthing it to no end. "No Cameron, No Hamilton, No Furlong, fuck that."
Not only was it not as bad as I thought i'd be, not only was it very good, but I'd say it was just as good as the first two. The first time I saw it I thought it was surprising, the second time I thought it was amazing.
The car chase was just amazing (the best chase of that summer, better than Matrix Reloaded, 2 Fast 2 Furious, and Bad Boys II), the story came together perfectly without once feeling like a contrived cash-in, it was extremely well-acted, honest, and fast-paced. I loved it.
I remember before the movie came out, I was badmouthing it to no end. "No Cameron, No Hamilton, No Furlong, fuck that."
Not only was it not as bad as I thought i'd be, not only was it very good, but I'd say it was just as good as the first two. The first time I saw it I thought it was surprising, the second time I thought it was amazing.
The car chase was just amazing (the best chase of that summer, better than Matrix Reloaded, 2 Fast 2 Furious, and Bad Boys II), the story came together perfectly without once feeling like a contrived cash-in, it was extremely well-acted, honest, and fast-paced. I loved it.
OTOH, I hated The Sarah Conner Chronicles. The storylines were so ridiculous and pretended like T3 never happened.
#29
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Why does Terminator 3 get so much hate on here?
As an action film its solid, but as part of the Terminator series its unnecessary when the ending was perfect after T2.
#30
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Why does Terminator 3 get so much hate on here?
T3 is a fun summer popcorn flick, T1 & T2 are much more then that, as they are one of those rare movies from this genre that don't rely on action and CGI. Cameron does a great job of establishing the characters, and really making you care about them, and in the process tells a very interesting story too.
This was the same with the Star Wars Original Trilogy compared to the Prequels. The Prequels were fun popcorn flicks, but lacked that depth with character development, where the Original Trilogy really did a great job of establishing the characters in Star Wars, and you actually cared about them for Empire and Jedi.
This was the same with the Star Wars Original Trilogy compared to the Prequels. The Prequels were fun popcorn flicks, but lacked that depth with character development, where the Original Trilogy really did a great job of establishing the characters in Star Wars, and you actually cared about them for Empire and Jedi.
#31
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Why does Terminator 3 get so much hate on here?
"Talk to the hand."
Studio Exec: "We need a catchphrase for Arnold... what did my 11 year old daughter used to say in 1994?? YES!!!" *high-5's nobody*
Studio Exec: "We need a catchphrase for Arnold... what did my 11 year old daughter used to say in 1994?? YES!!!" *high-5's nobody*
Last edited by Hokeyboy; 05-19-09 at 04:29 PM.
#32
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 738
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Why does Terminator 3 get so much hate on here?
The humour was awful and overdone
The casting was terrible
The movie was just a cheap re-hash of Terminator 2 instead of bringing the franchise in a different direction while still having Arnold involved
Its an unecessary movie, and its woefully mediocre in its execution to boot.
The casting was terrible
The movie was just a cheap re-hash of Terminator 2 instead of bringing the franchise in a different direction while still having Arnold involved
Its an unecessary movie, and its woefully mediocre in its execution to boot.
#33
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Why does Terminator 3 get so much hate on here?
I agree. And I think a lot of the haters had spent so much time hating on it that even when they saw it was a decent flick they couldn't admit it or they'd lose face. And some of them still won't admit it.
#35
Banned
Join Date: Feb 2002
Posts: 7,982
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Why does Terminator 3 get so much hate on here?
I liked it. I just didn't the actor who played John Conner. After such a touching story between the kid & terminator in T2 we get no such thing in T3.
And the FX in T3 were not as good as T2.
And the FX in T3 were not as good as T2.
#36
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Why does Terminator 3 get so much hate on here?
The problem is the movie brings nothing new to the Terminator series, it is just a fun popcorn summer flick that has no replay value. T1 & T2 are classics, as I have seen them a zillion times.
Why do people always think the haters want to hate the movie going in? I wanted the Prequels to be great, I wanted Godfather III to be great, I wanted Rocky V to be great, saw them all opening weekend, all were a disappointment. That's just the way it is.
#37
Re: Why does Terminator 3 get so much hate on here?
The humour was awful and overdone
The casting was terrible
The movie was just a cheap re-hash of Terminator 2 instead of bringing the franchise in a different direction while still having Arnold involved
Its an unecessary movie, and its woefully mediocre in its execution to boot.
The casting was terrible
The movie was just a cheap re-hash of Terminator 2 instead of bringing the franchise in a different direction while still having Arnold involved
Its an unecessary movie, and its woefully mediocre in its execution to boot.
If they were going to negate the entire point of T2, (the time travel point is a bit misguided as if the war was still going to happen, you would just keep sending people back in perpetuity to stop it) then have the film focus a bit on trying to stop it and failing but leave the majority to how they try to start a resistance. I think the best parts of the film were the scenes of people fleeing from these flying or track-driven robots. How are you going to stop these things?
Last edited by gmanca; 05-19-09 at 06:12 PM.
#38
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Oct 1999
Location: Up State NY
Posts: 1,886
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Why does Terminator 3 get so much hate on here?
I actually liked T3 more than T2. " hated all the the paradoxed T2 created, T2 fixed that. Also the TX made more sense than the T1000 in that it was more like a machine rather than a blob of molten metal
#39
Senior Member
Re: Why does Terminator 3 get so much hate on here?
My problem with T3 was it made itself irrelevent almost straight from the start.
The whole deal was you couldn't stop judgement day, you can only delay it. Fine.
The movie starts, only a few days before the new judgement day if I recall.
They send the female terminator back to kill John and his generals but where does she find them?
Conner was in jail, or a cage at an animal hospital and the other kids were partying at home. When judgement day happens in a few short days they would have been killed anyway. They were toast.
But by sending the female terminator back in time it caused Conner to survive instead of die.
That just bugs me to no end. The end was nice though and Terminator 4 certainly makes up for the crap that was part 3.
The whole deal was you couldn't stop judgement day, you can only delay it. Fine.
The movie starts, only a few days before the new judgement day if I recall.
They send the female terminator back to kill John and his generals but where does she find them?
Conner was in jail, or a cage at an animal hospital and the other kids were partying at home. When judgement day happens in a few short days they would have been killed anyway. They were toast.
But by sending the female terminator back in time it caused Conner to survive instead of die.
That just bugs me to no end. The end was nice though and Terminator 4 certainly makes up for the crap that was part 3.
#40
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Why does Terminator 3 get so much hate on here?
I remember when this first came out in the theaters, most said that this was much better than it should have been. And I agree. I had zero expectations going in. But ended up really enjoying it. It is an admirable and worthy film in the franchise. And I had no complaints about it.
#41
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Nov 2004
Posts: 1,775
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Why does Terminator 3 get so much hate on here?
Well, Terminator 2 managed to up the ante thematically rather than just rehash the first one. Terminator 3 brought nothing to the series except painfully bad attempts at humor. "Talk to the hand". Then it tries to be profound with Arnold gritting through his teeth "Desire is irrelevant... I ... am ... a ... MACHINE". For a moment I thought I was watching a Borg episode of Star Trek.
The ending was kind of cool, but it basically made the bulk of the movie pointless. Why not start with what happened at the end rather than "remake" T2 with horrible dialogue and acting?
T1 had a point, T2 had a point, T3 was a waste of time. I actually had some hope for T4 to be interesting, but early reviews are quickly dispelling that. I'm actually thinking about skipping opening weekend if only because I don't want that unbelievable prick(and insanely overrated actor) Christian Bale to keep doing good opening numbers.
The ending was kind of cool, but it basically made the bulk of the movie pointless. Why not start with what happened at the end rather than "remake" T2 with horrible dialogue and acting?
T1 had a point, T2 had a point, T3 was a waste of time. I actually had some hope for T4 to be interesting, but early reviews are quickly dispelling that. I'm actually thinking about skipping opening weekend if only because I don't want that unbelievable prick(and insanely overrated actor) Christian Bale to keep doing good opening numbers.
#42
Banned by request
Re: Why does Terminator 3 get so much hate on here?
I remember hearing about T3 without Cameron, and figured it was going to be a waste of time. But I actually quite enjoyed it. Mostow was an excellent choice for the director. He knows how to do action that isn't flashy and "look at me!" but rather suspenseful and full of tension. Sure, it was a step down from the first two movies, but what did you expect without James Cameron writing and directing?
As for the ending, I always saw it this way:
As for the ending, I always saw it this way:
Spoiler:
#43
Re: Why does Terminator 3 get so much hate on here?
My problem with T3 was it made itself irrelevent almost straight from the start.
The whole deal was you couldn't stop judgement day, you can only delay it. Fine.
The movie starts, only a few days before the new judgement day if I recall.
They send the female terminator back to kill John and his generals but where does she find them?
Conner was in jail, or a cage at an animal hospital and the other kids were partying at home. When judgement day happens in a few short days they would have been killed anyway. They were toast.
But by sending the female terminator back in time it caused Conner to survive instead of die.
That just bugs me to no end. The end was nice though and Terminator 4 certainly makes up for the crap that was part 3.
The whole deal was you couldn't stop judgement day, you can only delay it. Fine.
The movie starts, only a few days before the new judgement day if I recall.
They send the female terminator back to kill John and his generals but where does she find them?
Conner was in jail, or a cage at an animal hospital and the other kids were partying at home. When judgement day happens in a few short days they would have been killed anyway. They were toast.
But by sending the female terminator back in time it caused Conner to survive instead of die.
That just bugs me to no end. The end was nice though and Terminator 4 certainly makes up for the crap that was part 3.
#44
DVD Talk Godfather
Join Date: Apr 1999
Location: Gateway Cities/Harbor Region
Posts: 63,288
Received 1,808 Likes
on
1,129 Posts
Re: Why does Terminator 3 get so much hate on here?
When it comes to Time travel films there is ALWAYS room for change simply due to multiple paths in the time stream. I accept this. All you guys pissed because it didn't follow a set path should lighten up a bit.
That said, I like T3 as much as any other T-Film or show.
That said, I like T3 as much as any other T-Film or show.
#46
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Why does Terminator 3 get so much hate on here?
That's James Cameron's fault really. In the special features of the Ultimate Edition DVD of T2, Cameron admits that he removed the future Sarah ending and stuck with the highway ending because the future Sarah ending concluded the series. He chose to leave it open for a sequel in case T2 was a success. Later on he gradually lost interest in making T3. However the fact that there was an opening for a third (and now fourth) film is in large part because of James Cameron.
#47
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Why does Terminator 3 get so much hate on here?
I thought it was a solid popcorn action flick that just pales in comparasion to Terminator and T2. Both movies I thought were absolute classics for the genre while T3 was just a by the numbers action movie.
As for the end
It almost seemed like the studios decided that they wanted another Terminator movie eventhough there was perfect closure in the second one so they screwed with the ending of T2.
As for the end
Spoiler:
It almost seemed like the studios decided that they wanted another Terminator movie eventhough there was perfect closure in the second one so they screwed with the ending of T2.
#50
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Traverse City, MI
Posts: 3,955
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Why does Terminator 3 get so much hate on here?
I liked it and thought the ending was great, but I still dont think its as good as the other two.