DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   Most overrated Stanley Kubrick Movie (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/542877-most-overrated-stanley-kubrick-movie.html)

abe55 11-02-08 11:18 PM

Most overrated Stanley Kubrick Movie
 
Unless you love everything the man has done, there has to be at least one movie of his that you disliked, or think gets too much praise.

MaxMFP 11-02-08 11:34 PM

http://i206.photobucket.com/albums/b...EpicFail02.jpg

Ginwen 11-03-08 12:09 AM

None. Eyes Wide Shut is my least favorite (still not terrible but not one I want to see often) but it isn't that highly rated so isn't overrated. The rest are all excellent.

Sid Yobbo 11-03-08 04:35 AM

With the exception of Barry Lyndon, everything Kubrick made from A Clockwork Orange onwards has been quite spectacularly overrated.

Double_Oh_7 11-03-08 07:15 AM

All of them.

AVP77 11-03-08 07:35 AM

I've always found that Lolita is really tough to sit through - long and mostly dull.

RichC2 11-03-08 07:42 AM

Full Metal Jacket, the first bit is classic, the rest is cliche and dull.

chris_sc77 11-03-08 11:53 AM

Full Metal Jacket and 2001.

cactusoly 11-03-08 11:57 AM

2001. I really tried to like it and recognize it's meriits, but it bores the hell out of me

Shannon Nutt 11-03-08 12:00 PM

A CLOCKWORK ORANGE is the most over-rated (or over-praised would be a better term). EYES WIDE SHUT, consequently, is the most under-rated.

RichC2 11-03-08 12:06 PM

2001 is a fantastic movie and a space opera rolled into one.

I'm a fan of the movie parts, lots of thought provoking stuff, not such a big fan of the long, drawn out space stuff, chop 30 minutes off and it'd be a far more accessible movie, but that'd sort of wreck the point :D.

NoirFan 11-03-08 12:47 PM

Spartacus is basically a studio spectacle film with Kubrick as a director for hire, so I'd certainly say it's his worst film, with very few creative touches, though Barry Lyndon I find to be his most overrated. Lolita's explanatory wrap-up was both long-winded and insulting, as if Kubrick thought the audience not smart enough to have followed all of the film's twists and turns successfully. I still like the film, but I view it as an overall failure to bring the book to the screen. I also can't stand Eyes Wide Shut, but it has gotten it's far share of critical bashing, so I don't think I can label it overrated. In my opinion, Kubrick made three perfect films: The Killing, Dr. Strangelove and 2001. The rest all have their flaws.

chanster 11-03-08 12:54 PM

Clockwork Orange

Doughboy 11-03-08 03:14 PM

Dr. Strangelove. I've tried watching that 3 times now and while I admire parts of it, it's an extremely overrated film. Give me Fail-Safe any day of the week.

jrsl76 11-03-08 03:41 PM

None, I love them all, though of the celebrated films, 2001 is my least favorite. Other than that, Killer's Kiss is the weakest I've seen (the only one I haven't seen is Fear & Desire).

taa455 11-03-08 03:42 PM

Spartacus for me. I was honestly bored with it. I have never seen Eyes Wide Shut and don't really have a desire to.

cranberries fan 11-03-08 03:58 PM

Not one of them is Overrated.

Drop 11-03-08 04:04 PM


Originally Posted by RichC2 (Post 9046310)
Full Metal Jacket, the first bit is classic, the rest is cliche and dull.

I find it to be the opposite.

I love all his films, none are overrated.

inri222 11-03-08 04:24 PM

Least Favorite : Killer's Kiss
Most Overrated : None
Most Underrated : Eyes Wide Shut

Larry C. 11-03-08 05:03 PM

I despise this thread.

Torchur317 11-03-08 05:25 PM

2001: A Space Odyssey,I tried to like it but I couldn't get into it....
Very booooring....

wm lopez 11-03-08 05:40 PM

2001 may bore people but I think the people it bores are the ones who have seen movies like STAR WARS 1st. It's like the same way people don't think much of ROCKY because they have seen that plot through out the 80's and today.
But when 2001 came out there never was anything like that. The fx are great!

riley_dude 11-03-08 06:03 PM

He is definitely an aquired taste.

CloverClover 11-03-08 06:19 PM

Dr Strangelove is overrated, and I didn't think Spartacus was that highly rated to begin with, the rest are world class

BobSchlapowitz 11-03-08 06:36 PM

I understand and respect it's place in movie history.......But I'm of the opinion that 2001 can cure insomnia!


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:42 PM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.