DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   Best Gangster/Mob movies of all-time (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/541790-best-gangster-mob-movies-all-time.html)

Daytripper 10-16-08 06:38 PM

Best Gangster/Mob movies of all-time
 
OK, like always, I did a search for such a thread and I did not find anything. So if one exists, nothing showed up on my search. And mods, please merge. Anyway, I read the most interesting review on the newly released "Casino" on Blu-Ray (http://www.blu-ray.com/movies/movies...88&show=review), and I kind of agree. That said, what would you say the 5 best gangster/mob movies are. My vote goes to:

1) "The Godfather Part II"
2) "The Godfather"
3) "Goodfellas"
4) "Casino"
5) "Bugsy"

chris_sc77 10-16-08 06:44 PM

1. Once Upon A Time In America
2. Casino
3. Godfather 1/2/3
4. Road To Perdition
5. Miller's Crossing

emachine 10-16-08 06:46 PM

I never enjoyed The Godfather movies. I'll go with Goodfellas. The rest i'm not too sure about.

GoldenJCJ 10-16-08 06:56 PM


Originally Posted by Daytripper (Post 9009680)
My vote goes to:

1) "The Godfather Part II"
2) "The Godfather"
3) "Goodfellas"
4) "Casino"
5) "Bugsy"

:up: That would be my ranking as well
Although I've never seen Bugsy so I can't really say about that one. But 1-4 are ranked accordingly, IMO.

Daytripper 10-16-08 07:23 PM


Originally Posted by GoldenJCJ (Post 9009704)
:up: That would be my ranking as well
Although I've never seen Bugsy so I can't really say about that one. But 1-4 are ranked accordingly, IMO.

Well, #5 was a tough choice. I know "Bugsy" is not one of the *best* gangster/mob movies. But it's one of my favorites. chris_sc77 definitely chose films that were better. And believe me, narrowing it down to just five was very tough. You also have "Donnie Brasco", "The Untouchables", "The Departed", "Lock Stock" and "Snatch", "Scarface". To name a few. All favorites of mine. But I just found "Bugsy" to be one of the better film noirs. Up there with "L.A. Confidential". And possibly Barry Levinson's best effort.

Mountain Biker 10-16-08 07:52 PM

1. Goodfellas
2. Casino
3. The Untouchables
4. Scarface
5. Carlito's Way

Michael T Hudson 10-16-08 09:45 PM

No really a mob movie but I always thought Roy Scheider was a bad ass character in Romeo is Bleeding.

MaxMFP 10-16-08 09:55 PM

The Godfather I and II
Goodfellas
The Killing of a Chinese Bookie
Miller's Crossing
Once Upon a Time in America
Scarface (1932)
Mean Streets
The King of New York
Casino
Gotti

PopcornTreeCt 10-16-08 09:57 PM

I've always enjoyed Donnie Brasco.

Al Pacino's performance is utterly amazing and probably his last subtle one.

Goldberg74 10-16-08 10:03 PM

No love for "Johnny Dangerously" or "Oscar"? ;)

inri222 10-16-08 10:38 PM

The Long Good Friday
State of Grace
Eastern Promises
The Krays
Mona Lisa
Rififi
Sonatine
Graveyard of Honor
The Killer
Touchez pas au Grisbi
Le Samourai
The Funeral
Le Cercle Rouge
Little Caeser
White Heat
Branded to Kill
Youth of the beast
Shoot the Piano Player
Carlito's Way
Miller's Crossing
A Bronx Tale

DeanoBKN 10-16-08 11:01 PM

Some of my favorites...

American Gangster
Casino
Donnie Brasco
Godfather
Godfather Pt. II
Goodfellas
Road To Perdition
Scarface
Snatch

Sonic 10-17-08 04:07 AM

1) Godfather
2) Godfather II
3) Godfather III
4) Scarface
5) Goodfellas
6) Miller's Crossing

wm lopez 10-17-08 06:16 AM

COTTON CLUB is a good one.

coli 10-17-08 06:34 AM

1. The Godfather (The greatest movie of all-time, along with the greatest cast: Brando, Pacino, Caan, Duvall, Talia Shire, Cazale, etc)

2. Goodfellas (Marty's best movie)

3. Untouchables (Sean Connery steals the movie)

4. The Godfather, Part 2 (love the flashbacks, still think the Pacino parts are overrated)

5. Donnie Brasco (very underrated)

Dr Mabuse 10-17-08 08:38 AM

'The Yakuza Papers: Battles Without Honor & Humanity'.

I'm surprised no one mentioned this, it's one of the best series of films ever.. Hell it's from the autobiography of the lead character, it's all based on eyewitness accounts and is highly accurate to actual events like 'Goodfellas'. That box set is one of my favorite DVD releases too.

'Infernal Affairs'.

"American Me' was a good film, and pretty hard core as compared to most as to the reality of gangster stuff.

I really like 'Dillinger' with Warren Oates.

'True Romance' IS "gangster", and what a great movie.

Another gangster film I really like that I didn't see mentioned is 'Brother' by Takeshi Kitano. I really like that film.

islandclaws 10-17-08 12:01 PM

Obvious choices aside (Scorsese flicks, Godfather, etc.) since we all agree those are the tops:

Le Cercle Rogue
Borsalino & Co.
Little Caesar
Youth of the Beast
Road to Perdition
Mean Streets
Bob le Flambeur

Nick Danger 10-17-08 01:20 PM

Yojimbo
Godfather I and II
Goodfellas
Le Cercle Rouge
Bob le Flambeur
Rififi
Miller's Crossing
White Heat
Little Ceasar
Scarface (1932)

Sean O'Hara 10-17-08 02:35 PM

The Long Good Friday and Ghost Dog: Way of the Samurai.

OldBoy 10-17-08 04:30 PM

http://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/...right-now.html

in order:
Goodfellas
Godfather I & II
Once Upon a Time in America
The Departed
Mean Streets
The Untouchables
Casino
The King of New York
Miller's Crossing
Point Blank
Ichi The Killer

iamiam 10-17-08 04:40 PM

Best Korean Gangster Movie
 
Janggunui adeul (1990) aka "Son of the General"

wm lopez 10-17-08 05:12 PM

THE KILLER , LEON are gangster movies.

OldBoy 10-17-08 05:17 PM


Originally Posted by wm lopez (Post 9011799)
THE KILLER , LEON are gangster movies.

def. of gangster is member of gang of criminals. neither applies or else you would have a whole nother thread. assassins don't equate to gangster.

Michael T Hudson 10-17-08 11:10 PM


Originally Posted by scott1598 (Post 9011805)
def. of gangster is member of gang of criminals. neither applies or else you would have a whole nother thread. assassins don't equate to gangster.



I would say the cops in Leon would qualify as a gang of criminals.

mytzplyx 10-18-08 04:50 AM

No fans of Hoodlum?


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:45 PM.


Copyright 2018 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.