DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   Robert Downey Jr is Sherlock Holmes (dir. by Guy Ritchie) (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/535405-robert-downey-jr-sherlock-holmes-dir-guy-ritchie.html)

OldBoy 06-04-08 07:06 PM

"Sherlock Holmes" ...Guy Ritchie developing new movie.
 
just saw this on G4 and Access Hollywood. if it is dark and mysterious with some of Ritchie's patent twists i could go for it.

mrflix 06-04-08 07:39 PM

Read that they are looking to "re-invent" Holmes and make him more "adventuresome."...Seems like a Hollywood dumbing down to bring in the teenagers. IMO Ritchie hasn't done anything worthwhile since "Snatch"

Gerry P. 06-04-08 08:54 PM

Madonna = Moriarty

PopcornTreeCt 06-04-08 09:25 PM

The man still made Snatch and because of that I will always be interested in what he's doing next.

OldBoy 06-05-08 04:01 AM


Originally Posted by PopcornTreeCt
The man still made Snatch and because of that I will always be interested in what he's doing next.

i loved "Lock, Stock..." as well.

PopcornTreeCt 07-11-08 09:11 PM

Robert Downey Jr is Sherlock Holmes (dir. by Guy Ritchie)
 
Robert Downey Jr. to Play Sherlock Holmes

Compiled by JACQUES STEINBERG
Published: July 11, 2008

In the first role he has signed up for since “Iron Man,” Robert Downey Jr., left, will forsake his high-tech suit for a woolen cloak and cap. Mr. Downey has agreed to play the lead role in the film “Sherlock Holmes,” which will be directed by Guy Ritchie for Warner Brothers, Variety reported. The film is scheduled to begin shooting in October, with a screenplay by Anthony Peckham based on the detective stories of Arthur Conan Doyle and on a comic book, also called “Sherlock Holmes.” Most of the movie will be filmed in London. In the role, which Variety said would plumb Holmes’s brawn as well as his brains, Mr. Downey will have some competition. Columbia Pictures is also preparing a movie based on Holmes, this one a comedy with Sacha Baron Cohen as the title character and Will Ferrell as his sidekick, Dr. Watson.

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/07/11/ar...=1&oref=slogin

++

Cool. Funny, 2 Sherlock Holmes movies in one year.

fumanstan 07-11-08 09:28 PM

And weird that it looks like one will be a comedy whereas one will be serious. Guy Ritchie helming this has me interested though.

bee_01 07-11-08 11:36 PM

Why do studios always seem to release movies with similar subjects at the same time (or close to it)?

Red Planet/Mission to Mars
Deep Impact/Armageddon
Troy/Alexander
Ants/Bug's Life
Surf's Up/Happy Feet
Volcano/Dante's Peak
The Illusionist/The Prestige
Sex and the City/Punisher

chris_sc77 07-12-08 12:20 PM


Originally Posted by bee_01
Why do studios always seem to release movies with similar subjects at the same time (or close to it)?


Sex and the City/Punisher

rotfl rotfl

Well done....

Also Capote/Infamous

Mr. Cinema 07-12-08 12:22 PM

I like the casting choices for both films.

NoirFan 09-05-08 01:59 PM


Originally Posted by slashfilm
Here we go. Days ago, rumors hit that Russell Crowe was set to play Watson to Robert Downey Jr.’s Sherlock Holmes. To which the Internet huffed, “He’s not roundy enough!” And the Internet was right, but not quite. Not a first. According to those Palin-loathing dudes at Latino Review, Crowe is in talks to play Moriarty, Holmes creepy-smart arch-nemesis. You’ll recall that director Guy Ritchie only pffft’d Crowe for the aforementioned sidekick role, which still hasn’t been cast. LR report that Gerard Butler was offered the part, but didn’t bite. Not roundy enough?

Coming Soon report that prolific British actor, Mark Strong (Body of Lies, Rocknrolla, Sunshine) has signed on, and LR add that he’ll play a character named Blackwood. More casting news and confirmations as they develop.


NoirFan 09-19-08 04:37 PM

From Variety:

Jude Law is expected to close a deal shortly to play Watson, the super-sleuth's sidekick.

Jon2 09-19-08 08:02 PM

Downey + Holmes = Absurd Miscasting

Groucho 09-19-08 09:45 PM

I think it's pretty much impossible to miscast Downey.

Solid Snake 09-19-08 10:24 PM

Ditto...

Thrush 09-19-08 11:05 PM

I'd be looking forward to this if Guy Ritchie wasn't attached.

Solid Snake 09-19-08 11:08 PM

Yeah, I have a somewhat hard time imagining a Sherlock film by Ritchie...considering that Ritchie's style of tone in his films is kinda hyperish...of course I never saw the one with Madonna so I dunno. Heard that sucked though...so I dunno. So is this a detective film or like action/comedy type of film? Cuz...I wouldn't mind seeing a true Sherlock film that harked to the spirit of the great tales from the past.

toddly6666 09-20-08 08:08 PM

Since this is a Guy Ritchie film, I totally expect Holmes to say "No shit, Sherlock!"

Ronnie Dobbs 09-21-08 08:37 AM

Jude Law seems more like Holmes. RDJ could be Watson he seems like a funny sidekick.

Sean O'Hara 09-21-08 12:44 PM

Watson isn't supposed to be a funny sidekick -- that's the invention of bad adaptations. Why can't anyone make a decent Holmes movie without turning it into a farce, or Indiana Jones adventure with teenagers?

Jon2 09-21-08 06:10 PM


Originally Posted by toddly6666 (Post 8952205)
Since this is a Guy Ritchie film, I totally expect Holmes to say "No shit, Sherlock!"

rotfl


Originally Posted by Sean O'Hara (Post 8953032)
Watson isn't supposed to be a funny sidekick -- that's the invention of bad adaptations. Why can't anyone make a decent Holmes movie without turning it into a farce, or Indiana Jones adventure with teenagers?

Absolutely!

Downey (still) = absurd miscasting.

Who, out of today's big names, would make a good Holmes, is an interesting question. IMHO, Liam Neeson would be interesting to see.

Zen Peckinpah 09-21-08 09:19 PM

I think Ritchie is very overrated, but all I need to hear is Robert Downey Jr. and you've got my interest.

RichC2 09-25-08 08:46 AM

Rachel McAdams has apparently joined the cast:

http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/hr/...3fce47449ed3a5

NoirFan 10-01-08 04:45 PM

Producer Joel Silver is hoping for a franchise.

BDB 10-01-08 04:47 PM

http://pics.livejournal.com/girlyevil/pic/0025h1br


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:42 AM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.