DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   Full Metal Jacket 2nd half- yay or nay? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/533123-full-metal-jacket-2nd-half-yay-nay.html)

FRwL 06-06-08 06:58 PM

Full Metal Jacket 2nd half- yay or nay?
 
Yay for me. Many say the movie becomes less interesting after the film leaves boot camp, i used to think it was this bleak bleak thing to view, but then i realized that was the intention by Kubrick to make you feel the war as well as see it, like Coppola once said "my movie isn't about Vietnam, it IS Vietnam" Also i like how it's the only nam movie that centers on the battle of Hue city, the largest battle of the war, no jungles here.

mndtrp 06-06-08 07:04 PM

I enjoy it, but nowhere near as much as the first half. I'm pretty engrossed during the boot camp, but once they leave, I'll only partially pay attention.

Good movie all around, though.

Drop 06-06-08 07:05 PM

I love the whole movie, and it's broken into 3 parts not 2. Kubrick always had this thing with threes.

I like the parts after the bootcamp more, too.

cranberries fan 06-06-08 10:10 PM

It's all good ((I have only seen this movie once)).

EdTheRipper 06-06-08 10:35 PM

Yay...I love it all.

UAIOE 06-06-08 10:59 PM

Without the 2nd part, where would 2 Live Crew get their sample from?

silentbob007 06-06-08 11:53 PM

I like the bootcamp part more ... after that, it tends to blend with other war movies in my mind.

Brack 06-06-08 11:59 PM


Originally Posted by UAIOE
Without the 2nd part, where would 2 Live Crew get their sample from?

:lol: god I love that song.

DeputyDave 06-07-08 12:14 AM

It may be low brow but I have to go with the majority. I loved the first part, partly due to the fact that boot camps have always interested me (even my own) and also because out of the long string of 80's war movies it was the only one that did so (I don't count Heartbreak Ridge, as that was not boot camp).

The 2nd half was good but I didn't like Modine's character or acting, and the rest seemed the same as any other war movie of the time.

FantasticVSDoom 06-07-08 02:07 AM


Originally Posted by DeputyDave
It may be low brow but I have to go with the majority. I loved the first part, partly due to the fact that boot camps have always interested me (even my own) and also because out of the long string of 80's war movies it was the only one that did so (I don't count Heartbreak Ridge, as that was not boot camp).

The 2nd half was good but I didn't like Modine's character or acting, and the rest seemed the same as any other war movie of the time.

:up:

vcuram 06-07-08 07:20 AM

Nay. The first half barely gets a yay from me.

It's weird because I really dig Kubrick, I just don't like FMJ. Or Eyes Wide Shut.

Dave7393 06-07-08 07:50 AM


Originally Posted by FRwL
Many say the movie becomes less interesting after the film leaves boot camp

"WHO THE FUCK SAID THAT!"

TomOpus 06-07-08 07:53 AM

Nay.

Maybe since I was in the military, the bootcamp scenario resonated more with me. Plus, I've never been a fan of Matthew Modine.

rexinnih 06-07-08 10:06 AM

The boot camp stuff is more memorable but I do like the movie as a whole. So yay!

Rad14 06-07-08 11:41 AM

I suppose the first half is the more gripping, but the second is good too, although maybe not as good as it could have been!

cranberries fan 06-07-08 12:09 PM

Rad14 it's the Vietnam War none of it was good,but this movie is rock soild from start to finish.

musick 06-07-08 11:59 PM

movie is brilliant from start to finish like all of Kubrick's work

Mondo Kane 06-08-08 12:12 AM

Although the 2nd half of the movie introduced me to a Baldwin (Non-related to Alec,Stephen,William,and Daniel) it still wasn't enough to persuade me that an AK-47 is capable of doing tremendous sniper damage.

UAIOE 06-08-08 12:36 AM

But you saw it in a movie!

Rad14 06-08-08 01:51 PM


Originally Posted by cranberries fan
Rad14 it's the Vietnam War none of it was good,but this movie is rock soild from start to finish.


Obviously I wasn't inferring that the Vietnam War was good!

I was talking about the cinematic qualities of the movie -rolleyes-

Rizor 06-08-08 02:16 PM

I find the second half of the film to be less compelling than the film, but it's still watchable. The second half has its share of great moments, it's just not as consistent as the first half.

OldBoy 06-08-08 04:37 PM

yay! i don't think it would have endured as long as it has without equal parts brilliance.

starman9000 06-08-08 04:44 PM

Maybe they can do a special edition release called Bootcamp stories where we get the first half of Stripes, FMJ, and In the Army Now :)

DeputyDave 06-08-08 09:10 PM


Originally Posted by starman9000
Maybe they can do a special edition release called Bootcamp stories where we get the first half of Stripes, FMJ, and In the Army Now :)

Don't forget "No Time For Sargents"

Deftones 06-08-08 09:29 PM

Unwatchable to me.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:56 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.