Charlie Wilson's War - 12/25/2007
#26
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2003
Posts: 956
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I saw this yesterday, and I would have to agree with some of the other posters that it was decent, but not great. It almost seemed like it was 2 movies, the first 2/3 of the movie was very entertaining, with a lot of great moments, sharp dialogue, and strong performances, especially hoffman, and especially
the last 25-30% of the movie was pretty bad, almost like a bad episode of dateline or 60 minutes. in particular, the sequence
and not to troll, but...
it's tough to make an intelligent and entertaining movie about a subject like this, so i'd give them a lot of credit for trying. hoffman was great, hanks was solid, julia roberts was weak, it was a tough role, and face it, she's no meryl streep, ha.
Spoiler:
the last 25-30% of the movie was pretty bad, almost like a bad episode of dateline or 60 minutes. in particular, the sequence
Spoiler:
and not to troll, but...
Spoiler:
it's tough to make an intelligent and entertaining movie about a subject like this, so i'd give them a lot of credit for trying. hoffman was great, hanks was solid, julia roberts was weak, it was a tough role, and face it, she's no meryl streep, ha.
#27
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2005
Posts: 646
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
watched this last night.
wow, what a terrible movie. no one was likable, the humor was forced, the special effects were poor, tom hanks was boring, poor structure, i can't really think of anything that would make me want to watch it again.
i usually dont hate a movie enough to post about it, but god this was awful- especially that mentioned scene with the soviet helicopter pilots joking with each other.
wow, what a terrible movie. no one was likable, the humor was forced, the special effects were poor, tom hanks was boring, poor structure, i can't really think of anything that would make me want to watch it again.
i usually dont hate a movie enough to post about it, but god this was awful- especially that mentioned scene with the soviet helicopter pilots joking with each other.
#28
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Berkeley, CA
Posts: 1,981
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Started out well enough, with quite a good deal of humour. Ended terribly with an incredibly rushed finale that had absolutely no impact on me. Julia Roberts annoyed me in her role. Seymour Hoffman was the best thing about the movie, but there was very little to like overall.
#29
DVD Talk Hero
Watched this earlier, good movie. Humor flowed pretty well, Hanks was entertaining and the plot flowed extremely well. And while it built up to the ending, I don't think as much thought or effort went into it as what came before hand.
And again w/ the Russian pilots, thought it was something from Hot Shots. Overall though, solid film. Hoffman was great, Roberts seemed forced.
And again w/ the Russian pilots, thought it was something from Hot Shots. Overall though, solid film. Hoffman was great, Roberts seemed forced.
#30
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Finally got around to this one today. LOVED the first half of the movie, Tom Hanks' coked-out good ol' boy, and especially Philip Seymour Hoffman continuing to be the freaking man. His first scene was probably the greatest slice of hilarity he's displayed since Boogie Nights (I'm and idiot, I'm an IDIOT, I'm an IDIOT, I'm a FUCKING IDIOT!). Julia Roberts was, surprisingly, not loathsome, and that scene with her in a bikini got me raging with lust (though nothing compared to Amy Adams or Emily Blunt ).
However, I can't stress PSH's greatness in this movie. The Robert Goulet moustache/glasses added to the effect, but if this movie was all about Gust Avrakatos I'd like it even more.
I thought it petered out towards the end of it (got a bit too Hollywood-y), but Hanks and Hoffman make it incredibly worthwhile. A strong *** or mild ***1/2 out of four for me.
However, I can't stress PSH's greatness in this movie. The Robert Goulet moustache/glasses added to the effect, but if this movie was all about Gust Avrakatos I'd like it even more.
I thought it petered out towards the end of it (got a bit too Hollywood-y), but Hanks and Hoffman make it incredibly worthwhile. A strong *** or mild ***1/2 out of four for me.
#31
I liked this movie somewhat. It doesn't really get going until Hoffman starts getting into the story, which is when he meets Hanks for the first time. That's my favorite scene in the film. There are a few scenes that are very funny also.
On a side note, I know Emily Blunt is one of my favorite actresses at the moment and she's definitely attractive, but in this film, she is just a total babe. Did she get implants?
On a side note, I know Emily Blunt is one of my favorite actresses at the moment and she's definitely attractive, but in this film, she is just a total babe. Did she get implants?