DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   Movies Based on Songs (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/462931-movies-based-songs.html)

TheAllPurposeNothing 04-20-06 11:23 PM

Movies Based on Songs
 
Got to thinking about this tonight: has anyone ever made a decent film based on a single song?

Heaven knows in the late 70's/early 80's there were a glut of really bad country song adaptations such as

Take This Job and Shove It
The Night the Lights Went Out in Georgia
Ode to Billy Joe
Harper Valley PTA
Convoy


But I'm not sure if anyone ever made a good song to film adaptation.

And, no, I don't think Coal Miner's Daughter or any music bio named after a song (Great Balls of Fire, Walk the Line, Sweet Dreams, etc.) really count.

Is there a diamond in the rough I am missing?

PopcornTreeCt 04-20-06 11:51 PM

Girls Just Wanna Have Fun --with Sarah Jessica Parker?

RichC2 04-20-06 11:52 PM

Blue Velvet.

With one of the best villians to date.

Joe Molotov 04-21-06 12:42 AM

Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band
Yellow Submarine
Hard Day's Night

OwlAtHome 04-21-06 12:57 AM

FYI, the Song The Mighty Quinn ia about the movie Savage Innocents.

Buford T Pusser 04-21-06 01:26 AM

Wasn't Valley Girl inspired by the song?

(but was not in the movie)

darkshadowdog 04-21-06 01:33 AM

Evrey which way but loose? Or did they right the song for the movie, not the movie for the song?

mongoco 04-21-06 02:26 AM


Originally Posted by TheAllPurposeNothing

But I'm not sure if anyone ever made a good song to film adaptation.

Is there a diamond in the rough I am missing?

My Own Private Idaho (song by The B-52's, movie by Keanu Reeves, River Phoenix and Gus Van Sant)

sauce07 04-21-06 02:32 AM

http://Wasn't Valley Girl inspired b... in the movie)



I think you are refering to the Frank Zappa song, funny song and a good movie

sauce07 04-21-06 02:36 AM


Wasn't Valley Girl inspired by the song?

(but was not in the movie)
I think you are refering to the Frank Zappa song, funny song and a good movie

(sorry bout the previous post, i used the wrong code and it wont let me erase or edit it)

Count Dooku 04-21-06 02:45 AM

TheAllPurposeNothing is asking for films (actually, "decent films") of a VERY specific type:

The narrative of the movie must be based on the story told in a song.

The song had to come first.
The song had to tell a story.
And the movie has to (at least, loosely) tell that same story

None of the movies suggested, so far, fit that description..

Drexl 04-21-06 04:03 AM

How about Jailhouse Rock?

TheAllPurposeNothing 04-21-06 08:42 AM


Originally Posted by Count Dooku
TheAllPurposeNothing is asking for films (actually, "decent films") of a VERY specific type:

The narrative of the movie must be based on the story told in a song.

The song had to come first.
The song had to tell a story.
And the movie has to (at least, loosely) tell that same story

None of the movies suggested, so far, fit that description..

While that is what I was looking for, one film mentioned does fit the description pretty well:

Yellow Submarine

Beating myself over the head for missing that one as it is one of my favorite films. So kudos, Joe Molotov.

However, to be honest, I am inclined to take away the kudo for your inclusion of Sgt. Pepper's. Eeeshhhh! :)

Buford T Pusser 04-21-06 09:07 AM


Originally Posted by sauce07
I think you are refering to the Frank Zappa song, funny song and a good movie

(sorry bout the previous post, i used the wrong code and it wont let me erase or edit it)


Yes I was referring to the Frank/Moon Unit Zappa song. I believe a docu extra has the director saying the song made her think of writing the movie. IIRC.

wendersfan 04-21-06 09:19 AM

<a href = "http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0102116/"><b>The Indian Runner</b></a>, directed by Sean Penn and based on the Springsteen song "Highway Patrolman".

GuessWho 04-21-06 09:42 AM

The Gambler

j123vt_99 04-21-06 10:00 AM

Footloose?

Pwman 04-21-06 10:10 AM

The ultimate 60's hippie movie "Alice's Restaurant" based on Arlo Guthries rambling song about getting busted for littering and dealing with the draft board has its moments.

GuessWho 04-21-06 10:39 AM

Footloose, the song, was written for the the movie soundtrack. It wasn't a song first.

josuff247 04-21-06 11:29 AM

Sk8R Boi

HAHAHA....but that never happened

mongoco 04-21-06 12:08 PM

American Pie?

Buford T Pusser 04-21-06 12:15 PM

Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band.

Charlie Goose 04-21-06 12:27 PM

Can't Buy Me Love - One of the greatest movies ever made. :)

Tommy_Harn 04-21-06 12:33 PM

Thankfully, nobody has mentioned "The Hurricane." The movie featured a strong performance by Denzel, but the performances from every other cast member was laughable, at best. Great Song, horrible movie.

DonnachaOne 04-21-06 12:33 PM

I once read a treatment for a vampire flick based on The Eagle's Hotel California. Wasn't bad, but could have been better.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:21 PM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.