DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   Similiarities between White Heat (1949) and Batman (1989) (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/457480-similiarities-between-white-heat-1949-batman-1989-a.html)

PopcornTreeCt 02-28-06 11:52 PM

Similiarities between White Heat (1949) and Batman (1989)
 
I just finished watching White Heat with James Cagney. Amazing performance, GREAT movie. Tim Burton must've used this movie as an influence for Batman. More specifically, in White Heat, the final scene takes place in what looks like a chemical plant and there are shots almost identical to the chemical factory scene in Batman. Cagney and another guy are the last two guys left in the plant, the cops surround them. Cagney climbs up on top to a balcony area, the other guy goes to turn himself in. As the guy is walking, Cagney holds out his gun and grins pretty much the same way Nicholoson did when he shot "Eckhart". And then Cagney gets shot and starts laughing maniacally which is pretty close to the same laugh Jack does when he walks out of the surgery place after falling into the acid. Tim Burton and Jack Nicholoson must've both used this movie as a part influence. This is all my opinion of course.

Spiderbite 03-28-14 06:40 PM

Re: Similiarities between White Heat (1949) and Batman (1989)
 
This was the only thread I found discussing White Heat. Had a quick question and I didn't want to start a new thread. Just finished watching this and I must have missed something. Where did the inmate rooming with Cagney get the gun that he brought to Cagney when serving the food?

I figured there had to be an explanation how he got it but I scanned back thru the movie and didn't find anything.

TomOpus 03-28-14 07:15 PM

Re: Similiarities between White Heat (1949) and Batman (1989)
 
Can't help with the movie but I am amazed no one responded to the thread way back when.

Sonic 03-28-14 07:18 PM

Re: Similiarities between White Heat (1949) and Batman (1989)
 

Originally Posted by TomOpus (Post 12060720)
Can't help with the movie but I am amazed no one responded to the thread way back when.

Same here.

Now I'm curious if Burton indeed was inspired by that scene in White Heat for his Batman 1989.

Ash Ketchum 03-28-14 09:23 PM

Re: Similiarities between White Heat (1949) and Batman (1989)
 

Originally Posted by Spiderbite (Post 12060699)
This was the only thread I found discussing White Heat. Had a quick question and I didn't want to start a new thread. Just finished watching this and I must have missed something. Where did the inmate rooming with Cagney get the gun that he brought to Cagney when serving the food?

I figured there had to be an explanation how he got it but I scanned back thru the movie and didn't find anything.

I'm a big fan of WHITE HEAT and I can answer your question. When Vic Pardo, aka Hank Fallon (Edmond O'Brien), the undercover Treasury agent, first arrives at the prison and is put in the cell with Jarrett (Cagney) and the others, someone tells Jarrett that Tommy Riley (Robert Osterloh) has got a gun stashed.
Spoiler:
Later, when Jarrett has had the meltdown over news of his mother's death and is in a straitjacket, Riley is the one assigned to tend to him and it's then that Jarrett gets the idea to make a break and mouths to Riley, "Get the gun." Riley, not wanting to cross up Jarrett, obeys and when he comes back for the evening feeding of Jarrett, culminating in the order from the doctor to free the now calmed-down Jarrett from his straitjacket, Riley passes the gun to Jarrett as he's getting out of the straitjacket. It's a very smooth maneuver.


And, yeah, it's a safe bet that the scene in BATMAN cited in the opening post owes a lot to WHITE HEAT.

NEW JACK CITY also pays homage to WHITE HEAT.

Spiderbite 03-29-14 12:09 AM

Re: Similiarities between White Heat (1949) and Batman (1989)
 

Originally Posted by Ash Ketchum (Post 12060835)
I'm a big fan of WHITE HEAT and I can answer your question. When Vic Pardo, aka Hank Fallon (Edmond O'Brien), the undercover Treasury agent, first arrives at the prison and is put in the cell with Jarrett (Cagney) and the others, someone tells Jarrett that Tommy Riley (Robert Osterloh) has got a gun stashed.

Thanks for the clarification. I figured that was what happened but I missed it twice.

I have never seen White Heat before today and I loved it.

Solid Snake 03-29-14 03:37 AM

Re: Similiarities between White Heat (1949) and Batman (1989)
 

Originally Posted by Ash Ketchum (Post 12060835)
I'm a big fan of WHITE HEAT and I can answer your question. When Vic Pardo, aka Hank Fallon (Edmond O'Brien), the undercover Treasury agent, first arrives at the prison and is put in the cell with Jarrett (Cagney) and the others, someone tells Jarrett that Tommy Riley (Robert Osterloh) has got a gun stashed.
Spoiler:
Later, when Jarrett has had the meltdown over news of his mother's death and is in a straitjacket, Riley is the one assigned to tend to him and it's then that Jarrett gets the idea to make a break and mouths to Riley, "Get the gun." Riley, not wanting to cross up Jarrett, obeys and when he comes back for the evening feeding of Jarrett, culminating in the order from the doctor to free the now calmed-down Jarrett from his straitjacket, Riley passes the gun to Jarrett as he's getting out of the straitjacket.


And, yeah, it's a safe bet that the scene in BATMAN cited in the opening post owes a lot to WHITE HEAT.

NEW JACK CITY also pays homage to WHITE HEAT.

You ever get the BD? Fucking gorgeous image, man. Still need to get that gangsters set from WB hat has WH, Public Enemy, Petrified Forest, and Little Caesar.

Ash Ketchum 03-29-14 06:14 AM

Re: Similiarities between White Heat (1949) and Batman (1989)
 

Originally Posted by Solid Snake (Post 12061044)
You ever get the BD? Fucking gorgeous image, man. Still need to get that gangsters set from WB hat has WH, Public Enemy, Petrified Forest, and Little Caesar.

I have the set that has WHITE HEAT, G MEN, EACH DAWN I DIE and CITY FOR CONQUEST, every one of them a winner. CITY FOR CONQUEST is possibly my favorite Cagney film after WHITE HEAT,

Solid Snake 03-29-14 06:26 AM

Re: Similiarities between White Heat (1949) and Batman (1989)
 
Is that a DVD set? Or a BD set?

Ash Ketchum 03-29-14 10:32 AM

Re: Similiarities between White Heat (1949) and Batman (1989)
 

Originally Posted by Solid Snake (Post 12061072)
Is that a DVD set? Or a BD set?

DVD - "TCM Greatest Gangster Films Collection: James Cagney"

Solid Snake 03-29-14 12:30 PM

Re: Similiarities between White Heat (1949) and Batman (1989)
 
Ah. You should get that gangsters BD set from WB. It's top notch work. I love it when old movies get some proper care on BD

Spiderbite 03-29-14 01:50 PM

Re: Similiarities between White Heat (1949) and Batman (1989)
 
I gotta agree with Snake. I rented the White Heat BD thru Netflix and the transfer is fantastic. It looks like it was filmed yesterday.

Shannon Nutt 03-29-14 06:07 PM

Re: Similiarities between White Heat (1949) and Batman (1989)
 
You know, WHITE HEAT was a modern-day blockbuster...

hanshotfirst1138 03-29-14 07:21 PM


Originally Posted by Spiderbite (Post 12061292)
I gotta agree with Snake. I rented the White Heat BD thru Netflix and the transfer is fantastic. It looks like it was filmed yesterday.

Those 4K remasters look stunning when done right. And here I have friends who insist that upscales DVDs "look exactly the same." I saw the Blu of Jaws projected on a big cinema screen as part of a local film club thing (basically, a bunch of horror fans rent a theater and make smartass remarks while watching movies and hitting each other after probably drinking), and was surprised just how good it looked when it was blown up to that size. My HDTV is so inexpensive, sometimes I forget they Blu-Ray is almost 2K. Incidentally, WH is a cracking good gangster flick with a fantastic, almost feral performance from Cagney at his ferocious best.

Trevor 03-29-14 07:31 PM

Re: Similiarities between White Heat (1949) and Batman (1989)
 

Originally Posted by Shannon Nutt (Post 12061439)
You know, WHITE HEAT was a modern-day blockbuster...

Bah! It was under two hours and wasn't rated R.

Ash Ketchum 03-30-14 04:28 AM

Re: Similiarities between White Heat (1949) and Batman (1989)
 

Originally Posted by Trevor (Post 12061529)
Bah! It was under two hours and wasn't rated R.

If there had been ratings in 1949 it would have gotten whatever the equivalent to an "R" would have been. You should read some of the reviews of it. Bosley Crowther, the lead reviewer at The New York Times for 20-odd years, was outraged at the Times Square crowd's enthusiastic reaction to the film in a Sunday piece that followed his review by a couple of days. He was worried about the crowd's morals. Apparently, some kid in the audience responded to a piece of Cagney business with, as Crowther spelled it, "Bee-yoo-ti-ful!" Unfortunately, he doesn't say what scene it was. I'm guessing it was either the one where Cagney pulls the pistol from the sun visor holder in the car and shoots the Treasury agent who's trying to arrest him, or the scene where Riley slips him the gun as he unties his straitjacket. More likely the first. Of course for me, it would be when Cagney tells the inmate who'd tried to kill him and is now locked in the car trunk yelling for air, "Okay, Parker, I'll give you some air," upon which he empties a .45 into the trunk. That's one of my favorite lines in the film, along with:

"If that battery's dead, it's gonna have company."
"If I turned my back long enough for Big Ed to put a hole in it, there'd be a hole in it."
"And I was gonna split fifty-fifty with a copper!"

Hailey G 03-30-14 09:13 AM

Re: Similiarities between White Heat (1949) and Batman (1989)
 

Originally Posted by Ash Ketchum (Post 12061772)
If there had been ratings in 1949 it would have gotten whatever the equivalent to an "R" would have been. You should read some of the reviews of it. Bosley Crowther, the lead reviewer at The New York Times for 20-odd years, was outraged at the Times Square crowd's enthusiastic reaction to the film in a Sunday piece that followed his review by a couple of days. He was worried about the crowd's morals. Apparently, some kid in the audience responded to a piece of Cagney business with, as Crowther spelled it, "Bee-yoo-ti-ful!" Unfortunately, he doesn't say what scene it was. I'm guessing it was either the one where Cagney pulls the pistol from the sun visor holder in the car and shoots the Treasury agent who's trying to arrest him, or the scene where Riley slips him the gun as he unties his straitjacket. More likely the first. Of course for me, it would be when Cagney tells the inmate who'd tried to kill him and is now locked in the car trunk yelling for air, "Okay, Parker, I'll give you some air," upon which he empties a .45 into the trunk. That's one of my favorite lines in the film, along with:

"If that battery's dead, it's gonna have company."
"If I turned my back long enough for Big Ed to put a hole in it, there'd be a hole in it."
"And I was gonna split fifty-fifty with a copper!"

You know that you typed all that up in response to a recurring joke on this forum, right?

Solid Snake 03-30-14 10:06 AM

Re: Similiarities between White Heat (1949) and Batman (1989)
 
He's old, man. Let it go. He won't remember this shit after his morning shit.

Ash Ketchum 03-30-14 06:55 PM

Re: Similiarities between White Heat (1949) and Batman (1989)
 

Originally Posted by Obi-Wan Jabroni (Post 12061831)
You know that you typed all that up in response to a recurring joke on this forum, right?

Of course, but Trevor gave me an opening to give a history lesson, so how could I pass it up?

Ash Ketchum 03-30-14 07:03 PM

Re: Similiarities between White Heat (1949) and Batman (1989)
 

Originally Posted by Ash Ketchum (Post 12060835)
I'm a big fan of WHITE HEAT and I can answer your question. When Vic Pardo, aka Hank Fallon (Edmond O'Brien), the undercover Treasury agent, first arrives at the prison and is put in the cell with Jarrett (Cagney) and the others, someone tells Jarrett that Tommy Riley (Robert Osterloh) has got a gun stashed.

Okay, I just watched the film again. Here's what happens: as they plan a jailbreak in their cell at night, talking in whispers, Jarrett himself tells Pardo that Riley has a gun stashed and he wants to use that in the break. Pardo counters that they'll then have to take Riley with them and he wants to keep it just to the two of them. As we see later, of course, the gun turns out to be key.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:59 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.