DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   City of Lost Children (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/381911-city-lost-children.html)

treszoks 08-25-04 09:24 AM

City of Lost Children
 
Does anyone recommend this as a blind buy? Any comments on it?

Rivero 08-25-04 09:37 AM

Yes treszoks. This is a fantastic blind buy. It's like a f**ked-up Braque painting come to life. BUY IT! BUY IT! BUY IT!.

.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
but make sure you get/watch it in French.

http://images.amazon.com/images/P/B0...1.LZZZZZZZ.jpg

mllefoo 08-25-04 11:51 AM

Definitely watch it in French. The dubbed version just makes the actors sound weird.

This movie is dark and will destroy your image of Santa Claus.

It will also make you think twice before you bitch about how much Advantage and Frontline cost for your dogs.

I don't know your movie tastes, so I'd say rent it before you buy it. The movie is very good, but it's definitely "out there" in a Terry Gilliam way. A friend showed me the movie and I went out and bought it the next day.

Johnny Zhivago 08-25-04 02:57 PM

Yup, depends on your tastes... It's a little strange, to say the least, but also a very good film. Not something I - personally - would feel the need to keep around, I owned it and traded it, not much in the replay department for me... YMMV, what kind of films do you generally enjoy? Also has a pretty high MSRP for what you get... You could try the Columbia House route, it's available for enrollment (stop by the clubs folder for a good code and info if you've never done CH).

treszoks 08-25-04 03:01 PM

I keep seeing that collector's edition at Circuit City so I wanted to see if it was worth getting. It looks like it has that Dark City/Matrix look to it. Would you classify it sci-fi?

Rivero 08-25-04 03:32 PM


Originally posted by treszoks
It looks like it has that Dark City/Matrix look to it. Would you classify it sci-fi?
It's part sci-fi, sure, but it's more a very dark fable, full of imagination, surreal images, visual flair and larger-than-life characterisations. Either you feel it or you don't.....it's really not an explainable thing with this movie imo. To answer your question again, yes it's worth getting.

mllefoo 08-25-04 10:39 PM

It's a dark fantasy. It could *almost* be sci fi, but it just misses the mark on the genre. Sci Fi fans like me really enjoy it.

Surreal describes the movie perfectly.

Trigger 08-25-04 11:05 PM

I preferred Delicatessen, but yeah - this is a pretty good film.

Sessa17 08-26-04 09:50 AM

Once of my all-time favorite movies & one of my most watched movies ever.

But rent he freakin' thing. These blind buy threads are so annoying. It's a very freaky & weird movie, the average movie goer is not going to like it.

willpos 08-27-04 08:05 AM

Very screwy indeed.

Abranut 08-30-04 01:13 PM

One of my favorites. Worth a blind buy...but you might hate it (I guess that goes for any blind buy). It's not so weird that it's unwatchable by your average movie fan.

It's directed by the same guy who directed Amelie and Delicatessen, so you can see some similarities in those films.

dhmac 08-30-04 05:40 PM

I wouldn't recommend City of Lost Children as a blind buy. I didn't like it very much, although I do like the director's other films Amélie and Delicatessen. (As for Alien: Resurrection - let's all just pretend that one never happened.)

Supermallet 08-30-04 05:43 PM

City of Lost Children is visually stunning, but the pacing is off. It drags at a lot of points. Still, its shortcomings don't ruin it. I also prefer Delicatessen and Amelie.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:36 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.