View Poll Results: Which is worst?
Bad Boys (1995)




11
4.38%
The Rock (1996)




4
1.59%
Armageddon (1998)




34
13.55%
Pearl Harbor (2001)




126
50.20%
Bad Boys II (2003)




76
30.28%
Voters: 251. You may not vote on this poll
Worst Michael Bay movie
#52
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Originally posted by Joem
I'm not going to bother to vote. None of those are bad movies by any stretch (and yes, I did see Pearl Harbor).
I'm not going to bother to vote. None of those are bad movies by any stretch (and yes, I did see Pearl Harbor).
#53
DVD Talk Legend
Bay's films suck to people here because well, they're not 'smart', they don't have a 'twist ending', they're not made on $4,500 dollar budgets, oh, and because they're action movies.
Seriously, I don't get how someone can NOT be entertained by a movie like Bad Boys or The Rock...it's amazing to me.
Oh, and I voted for Bad Boys II because the last half hour just fell apart...but I did like the beginning of it, the car chase in the beginning is awesome.
Seriously, I don't get how someone can NOT be entertained by a movie like Bad Boys or The Rock...it's amazing to me.
Oh, and I voted for Bad Boys II because the last half hour just fell apart...but I did like the beginning of it, the car chase in the beginning is awesome.
#55
DVD Talk Legend
Seriously, I don't get how someone can NOT be entertained by a movie like Bad Boys or The Rock...it's amazing to me.
When I go see Michael Bay films, I don't want plot. I want shit blowing up. I want cars flipping, people getting shot, buildings exploding... whatever can be destroyed, I want to see destroyed. **** plot.
#56
Banned
Thread Starter
Originally posted by Tarantino
Seriously, I don't get how someone can NOT be entertained by a movie like Bad Boys or The Rock...it's amazing to me.
Seriously, I don't get how someone can NOT be entertained by a movie like Bad Boys or The Rock...it's amazing to me.
Good: Die Hard, Aliens, Terminator 2, Predator, Time and Tide
Bad: Gone in 60 Seconds, Con Air, Michael Bay's entire resume
#57
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by Rivero
What's not to get. They're headache-inducing and dumb. And there IS a difference between a dumb popcorn action flick and a good one.
Good: Die Hard, Aliens, Terminator 2, Predator, Time and Tide
What's not to get. They're headache-inducing and dumb. And there IS a difference between a dumb popcorn action flick and a good one.
Good: Die Hard, Aliens, Terminator 2, Predator, Time and Tide
#58
Needs to contact an admin about multiple accounts
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: Las Vegas, NV
Posts: 2,730
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Tarantino
Seriously, I don't get how someone can NOT be entertained by a movie like Bad Boys or The Rock...it's amazing to me.
Seriously, I don't get how someone can NOT be entertained by a movie like Bad Boys or The Rock...it's amazing to me.

#59
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by Matthew Chmiel
If Michael Bay would stick to making films concentrating more on action and less on plot, I would like him more. Michael Bay is one of the few directors who can pull "style over substance" off extremely well. But his last three films have tried to have substance to them, which is completely unnecessary for a Michael Bay flick. If Bad Boys II was maybe 90 - 120 minutes, I would've enjoyed it a lot more. If Pearl Harbor was just 120 minutes of Pearl Harbor getting attacked, I would've loved it.
When I go see Michael Bay films, I don't want plot. I want shit blowing up. I want cars flipping, people getting shot, buildings exploding... whatever can be destroyed, I want to see destroyed. **** plot.
If Michael Bay would stick to making films concentrating more on action and less on plot, I would like him more. Michael Bay is one of the few directors who can pull "style over substance" off extremely well. But his last three films have tried to have substance to them, which is completely unnecessary for a Michael Bay flick. If Bad Boys II was maybe 90 - 120 minutes, I would've enjoyed it a lot more. If Pearl Harbor was just 120 minutes of Pearl Harbor getting attacked, I would've loved it.
When I go see Michael Bay films, I don't want plot. I want shit blowing up. I want cars flipping, people getting shot, buildings exploding... whatever can be destroyed, I want to see destroyed. **** plot.
#60
Banned
Thread Starter
Originally posted by Matthew Chmiel
When I go see Michael Bay films, I don't want plot. I want shit blowing up. I want cars flipping, people getting shot, buildings exploding... whatever can be destroyed, I want to see destroyed. **** plot.
When I go see Michael Bay films, I don't want plot. I want shit blowing up. I want cars flipping, people getting shot, buildings exploding... whatever can be destroyed, I want to see destroyed. **** plot.
#62
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by Rivero
How old are you?
How old are you?
When I go see a Michael Bay film, I don't go in expecting something on par with an Akira Kurosawa or François Truffaut film. I expect mindless entertainment that I can just watch and enjoy. I don't go in expecting it to have a great plot or good acting. I come in to watch millions of dollars pumped into two hours of non-stop destruction put on 35mm film.
If I wanted something "smart" that I could enjoy and satisfy my brain with, I'd go pop in Rashomon or The 400 Blows, not Armageddon or Bad Boys.
And unlike yourself, I know the difference between great movies I can enjoy and shitty movies I can enjoy.
#63
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by Matthew Chmiel
I'm eighteen and I also do not have a stick shoved up my ass, unlike yourself.
When I go see a Michael Bay film, I don't go in expecting something on par with an Akira Kurosawa or François Truffaut film. I expect mindless entertainment that I can just watch and enjoy. I don't go in expecting it to have a great plot or good acting. I come in to watch millions of dollars pumped into two hours of non-stop destruction put on 35mm film.
If I wanted something "smart" that I could enjoy and satisfy my brain with, I'd go pop in Rashomon or The 400 Blows, not Armageddon or Bad Boys.
And unlike yourself, I know the difference between great movies I can enjoy and shitty movies I can enjoy.
I'm eighteen and I also do not have a stick shoved up my ass, unlike yourself.
When I go see a Michael Bay film, I don't go in expecting something on par with an Akira Kurosawa or François Truffaut film. I expect mindless entertainment that I can just watch and enjoy. I don't go in expecting it to have a great plot or good acting. I come in to watch millions of dollars pumped into two hours of non-stop destruction put on 35mm film.
If I wanted something "smart" that I could enjoy and satisfy my brain with, I'd go pop in Rashomon or The 400 Blows, not Armageddon or Bad Boys.
And unlike yourself, I know the difference between great movies I can enjoy and shitty movies I can enjoy.
#64
DVD Talk Legend
Sometimes you just want to go to a movie to see spectacular car chases and insane shootouts.
#66
DVD Talk Legend
I'm curious about what kind of action film Bad Boys 2 haters do like... and if they hate most action movies and all of Michael Bay's previous films, why the hell did they go see BB2??
#67
Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2000
Posts: 556
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Here we go again.
Threads like this are a huge reminder of how pretentious people are that post here. Michael Bay does NOT make bad films. Michael Bay makes some of the most entertaining action films of the last 10 years. He is also consistent, and out does himself every film.
When you sit around here and trash Michael Bay, maybe you should realize that HE is the film maker, and you are the one who sits on your ass and watches HIS work.
Dont get me wrong, I believe everyone is entitled to thier opinion, but sometimes it seems like people for thier opinions based on what they think will be 'cool' to their peers.
In conclusion, if you think you are so supeior in intellect and talent to Michael Bay, then lets see your film.
PS:
When i'm in the mood to relax and be entertained for a couple hours, I'd rather watch a Bay film than a Kurosawa or Kubrick film anytime.
Threads like this are a huge reminder of how pretentious people are that post here. Michael Bay does NOT make bad films. Michael Bay makes some of the most entertaining action films of the last 10 years. He is also consistent, and out does himself every film.
When you sit around here and trash Michael Bay, maybe you should realize that HE is the film maker, and you are the one who sits on your ass and watches HIS work.
Dont get me wrong, I believe everyone is entitled to thier opinion, but sometimes it seems like people for thier opinions based on what they think will be 'cool' to their peers.
In conclusion, if you think you are so supeior in intellect and talent to Michael Bay, then lets see your film.
PS:
When i'm in the mood to relax and be entertained for a couple hours, I'd rather watch a Bay film than a Kurosawa or Kubrick film anytime.
#68
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: Virginia Beach, VA USA
Posts: 3,583
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Banky
Here we go again.
Threads like this are a huge reminder of how pretentious people are that post here. Michael Bay does NOT make bad films. Michael Bay makes some of the most entertaining action films of the last 10 years. He is also consistent, and out does himself every film.
When you sit around here and trash Michael Bay, maybe you should realize that HE is the film maker, and you are the one who sits on your ass and watches HIS work.
Dont get me wrong, I believe everyone is entitled to thier opinion, but sometimes it seems like people for thier opinions based on what they think will be 'cool' to their peers.
In conclusion, if you think you are so supeior in intellect and talent to Michael Bay, then lets see your film.
PS:
When i'm in the mood to relax and be entertained for a couple hours, I'd rather watch a Bay film than a Kurosawa or Kubrick film anytime.
Here we go again.
Threads like this are a huge reminder of how pretentious people are that post here. Michael Bay does NOT make bad films. Michael Bay makes some of the most entertaining action films of the last 10 years. He is also consistent, and out does himself every film.
When you sit around here and trash Michael Bay, maybe you should realize that HE is the film maker, and you are the one who sits on your ass and watches HIS work.
Dont get me wrong, I believe everyone is entitled to thier opinion, but sometimes it seems like people for thier opinions based on what they think will be 'cool' to their peers.
In conclusion, if you think you are so supeior in intellect and talent to Michael Bay, then lets see your film.
PS:
When i'm in the mood to relax and be entertained for a couple hours, I'd rather watch a Bay film than a Kurosawa or Kubrick film anytime.
I didn't know Micheal Bay's mom posted in this forum. Cool!
D
#71
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: Ottawa
Posts: 9,975
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Pearl Harbor has no redeeming qualities in it at all. Sure, you all say the attack sequence is good... but think about it for a second, you're thinking about how cool the reinactment of a national tragedy was. Awesome guys!
Ok, if that's not enough, let's expand on it. The battle is TOTALLY cliched and crappy. Sure, there might be a few good exploisions, but it's full of crap as well.
We also have crap like the potato peeler pealing potatos thinking it's a drill, and then a torpedo lands right by him, and he looks down, and gets blown up. WTF? I couldn't tell if that was supposed to be funny or not. Another similar thing... there's the guy who stutters... the base is under attack and he's stuttering trying to warn everyone.. but he can't... and then everyone gets straffed by a plane and starts running. Again, is this supposed to be a funny part? I can't tell! Oh, one more too.. a torpedo or whatever lands by a bunch of soilders, but it doens't go off. One of the guys is so happy, exlaiming, "It's a dud!" it then blows up and kills them all! Hahaha!
I've only seen the movie once, so I can't comment that much on the rest... but I remember a whole bunch of laughable stuff in that battle sequence. Like the planes doing their neat chicken trick to fool the Japanese, what the hell? that's cliched crap. That whole battle was like watching science fiction, the battle was supposed to be over the top and cool and wow enducing.
Pearl Harbor is THE suck. I could at least laugh at Armageddon. Pearl Harbor was even too bad to laugh at. Bay tried to blend Titanic and a war movie together in order to make a lot of money by appealing to as many people as possible.
Ok, if that's not enough, let's expand on it. The battle is TOTALLY cliched and crappy. Sure, there might be a few good exploisions, but it's full of crap as well.
We also have crap like the potato peeler pealing potatos thinking it's a drill, and then a torpedo lands right by him, and he looks down, and gets blown up. WTF? I couldn't tell if that was supposed to be funny or not. Another similar thing... there's the guy who stutters... the base is under attack and he's stuttering trying to warn everyone.. but he can't... and then everyone gets straffed by a plane and starts running. Again, is this supposed to be a funny part? I can't tell! Oh, one more too.. a torpedo or whatever lands by a bunch of soilders, but it doens't go off. One of the guys is so happy, exlaiming, "It's a dud!" it then blows up and kills them all! Hahaha!
I've only seen the movie once, so I can't comment that much on the rest... but I remember a whole bunch of laughable stuff in that battle sequence. Like the planes doing their neat chicken trick to fool the Japanese, what the hell? that's cliched crap. That whole battle was like watching science fiction, the battle was supposed to be over the top and cool and wow enducing.
Pearl Harbor is THE suck. I could at least laugh at Armageddon. Pearl Harbor was even too bad to laugh at. Bay tried to blend Titanic and a war movie together in order to make a lot of money by appealing to as many people as possible.
#74
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by BizRodian
...didn't I just say that?
...didn't I just say that?
The battle sequences in Pearl Harbor were some of the best ever, in my opinion.
#75
DVD Talk Legend
The battle sequences in Pearl Harbor were some of the best ever, in my opinion.

You could have done better than that.
