The Official - I've actually Seen Farenheit 9/11 and want to talk about THE MOVIE
#201
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Mar 2000
Location: San Antonio
Posts: 20,804
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by RyoHazuki
You said he's always sought justice for the little guy, but now he's just the messenger? I think you were right the second time. He just shows a lot of problems and doesn't offer any solutions.
You said he's always sought justice for the little guy, but now he's just the messenger? I think you were right the second time. He just shows a lot of problems and doesn't offer any solutions.
For instance:
Fixing that gross federal budget surplus.
Taking care of all those pesky Iraqi terrorists.
Proposing a constitutional amendment to oppress those pesky gay folks.
Patriot Act: Who really needed civil liberties anyway?
DUCK!!! It's another "Orange Alert"!!!
#203
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Wouldn't you like to know?
Posts: 1,819
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Originally posted by RyoHazuki
You said he's always sought justice for the little guy, but now he's just the messenger? I think you were right the second time. He just shows a lot of problems and doesn't offer any solutions.
You said he's always sought justice for the little guy, but now he's just the messenger? I think you were right the second time. He just shows a lot of problems and doesn't offer any solutions.
#204
DVD Talk Reviewer
Join Date: May 2000
Location: Blu-ray.com
Posts: 10,380
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Mr.Briggs
Got to agree with you. MM shows a LOT of problems with the Bush administration and (in only a 2 hour movie) not all of the solutions. Perhaps it is because he is a film maker not an office holder. By pointing out the problems this administration has brought upon the American people they can vote for the person who will work for change in the policies they dislike. Can you say One Termer like daddy?
Got to agree with you. MM shows a LOT of problems with the Bush administration and (in only a 2 hour movie) not all of the solutions. Perhaps it is because he is a film maker not an office holder. By pointing out the problems this administration has brought upon the American people they can vote for the person who will work for change in the policies they dislike. Can you say One Termer like daddy?
Pro-B
#205
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Ok I'll try to do this step by step.
1. No comment.
2. Beheadings, suicide bombers, and crazed milita. Not at all. All Iraqis are fun loving, good natured people who should be coddled. We should have came into Iraq with big nerf swords and had a tickle fight.
3. I missed the oppressing gay rights portion of Fahrenheit 9/11?
4+5. Damned if you do, damned if you don't. First they are overstepping your rights, next they didn't do enough to protect you.
Originally posted by chess
For instance:
Fixing that gross federal budget surplus.
Taking care of all those pesky Iraqi terrorists.
Proposing a constitutional amendment to oppress those pesky gay folks.
Patriot Act: Who really needed civil liberties anyway?
DUCK!!! It's another "Orange Alert"!!!
For instance:
Fixing that gross federal budget surplus.
Taking care of all those pesky Iraqi terrorists.
Proposing a constitutional amendment to oppress those pesky gay folks.
Patriot Act: Who really needed civil liberties anyway?
DUCK!!! It's another "Orange Alert"!!!
1. No comment.
2. Beheadings, suicide bombers, and crazed milita. Not at all. All Iraqis are fun loving, good natured people who should be coddled. We should have came into Iraq with big nerf swords and had a tickle fight.
3. I missed the oppressing gay rights portion of Fahrenheit 9/11?
4+5. Damned if you do, damned if you don't. First they are overstepping your rights, next they didn't do enough to protect you.
#206
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally posted by Mr.Briggs
Got to agree with you. MM shows a LOT of problems with the Bush administration and (in only a 2 hour movie) not all of the solutions. Perhaps it is because he is a film maker not an office holder. By pointing out the problems this administration has brought upon the American people they can vote for the person who will work for change in the policies they dislike. Can you say One Termer like daddy?
Got to agree with you. MM shows a LOT of problems with the Bush administration and (in only a 2 hour movie) not all of the solutions. Perhaps it is because he is a film maker not an office holder. By pointing out the problems this administration has brought upon the American people they can vote for the person who will work for change in the policies they dislike. Can you say One Termer like daddy?
#207
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Wouldn't you like to know?
Posts: 1,819
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Originally posted by RyoHazuki
Mr. Kerry voted for this "false" war.
Mr. Kerry voted for this "false" war.
Last edited by Mr.Briggs; 07-05-04 at 02:19 AM.
#208
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Wouldn't you like to know?
Posts: 1,819
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
I love the "no comment" on fixing the budget mess that Bush got us into after 8 years of hard work by the Clinton admin to fix the red ink that they inherited. Repubs seem very good at writing checks with nothing in the account to back it up. When was the last time taxes were cut during a war (& 3 times at that)? What sacrifices did Bush ask the country to perform (a point F9/11 made), shopping? I guess I did my part buying dvds while the war was on. Perhaps I should get a medal.
Last edited by Mr.Briggs; 07-05-04 at 02:21 AM.
#210
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally posted by Mr.Briggs
I love the "no comment" on fixing the budget mess that Bush got us into after 8 years of hard work by the Clinton admin to fix the red ink that they inherited. Repubs seem very good at writing checks with nothing in the account to back it up. When was the last time taxes were cut during a war (& 3 times at that)? What sacrifices did Bush ask the country to perform (a point F9/11 made), shopping? I guess I did my part buying dvds while the war was on. Perhaps I should get a medal.
I love the "no comment" on fixing the budget mess that Bush got us into after 8 years of hard work by the Clinton admin to fix the red ink that they inherited. Repubs seem very good at writing checks with nothing in the account to back it up. When was the last time taxes were cut during a war (& 3 times at that)? What sacrifices did Bush ask the country to perform (a point F9/11 made), shopping? I guess I did my part buying dvds while the war was on. Perhaps I should get a medal.
Are Democrats the rightful owners of the White House?
Last edited by RyoHazuki; 07-05-04 at 03:01 AM.
#211
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Wouldn't you like to know?
Posts: 1,819
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Originally posted by RyoHazuki
Are Democrats the rightful owners of the White House?
Are Democrats the rightful owners of the White House?
#212
DVD Talk Reviewer
Join Date: May 2000
Location: Blu-ray.com
Posts: 10,380
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Mr.Briggs
Repubs seem very good at writing checks with nothing in the account to back it up. When was the last time taxes were cut during a war (& 3 times at that)? What sacrifices did Bush ask the country to perform (a point F9/11 made), shopping? I guess I did my part buying dvds while the war was on. Perhaps I should get a medal.
Repubs seem very good at writing checks with nothing in the account to back it up. When was the last time taxes were cut during a war (& 3 times at that)? What sacrifices did Bush ask the country to perform (a point F9/11 made), shopping? I guess I did my part buying dvds while the war was on. Perhaps I should get a medal.
Pro-B
#213
DVD Talk Limited Edition
I just saw the movie today. Overall I'd say my opinion is more negative than positive.
Some people have commented on how they thought Moore talking to the Congressman about their kids enlisting was funny. I thought this was incredibly stupid. I had no idea that a parent could enlist their child in the military. While it may be the case that there are very few Congressman with children in the military, that is the choice of their children.
I also thought that the frequent shots of bush looking stupid were a bit petty. When you have hours upon hours of footage of someone, it is easy to pull out a couple seconds here and there of him looking stupid, but is it necessary? That combined with the frequent ironic juxtaposition (as another poster said earlier) took away some from the film for me. If you have a good point, you shouldn't need to show these video clips and 2 second sound bytes that are taken out of context.
Some people have commented on how they thought Moore talking to the Congressman about their kids enlisting was funny. I thought this was incredibly stupid. I had no idea that a parent could enlist their child in the military. While it may be the case that there are very few Congressman with children in the military, that is the choice of their children.
I also thought that the frequent shots of bush looking stupid were a bit petty. When you have hours upon hours of footage of someone, it is easy to pull out a couple seconds here and there of him looking stupid, but is it necessary? That combined with the frequent ironic juxtaposition (as another poster said earlier) took away some from the film for me. If you have a good point, you shouldn't need to show these video clips and 2 second sound bytes that are taken out of context.
#214
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Originally posted by Dr_Evil
I just saw the movie today. Overall I'd say my opinion is more negative than positive.
Some people have commented on how they thought Moore talking to the Congressman about their kids enlisting was funny. I thought this was incredibly stupid. I had no idea that a parent could enlist their child in the military. While it may be the case that there are very few Congressman with children in the military, that is the choice of their children.
I just saw the movie today. Overall I'd say my opinion is more negative than positive.
Some people have commented on how they thought Moore talking to the Congressman about their kids enlisting was funny. I thought this was incredibly stupid. I had no idea that a parent could enlist their child in the military. While it may be the case that there are very few Congressman with children in the military, that is the choice of their children.
#215
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Originally posted by lisadoris
While hopefully parents can't actually enlist their children into the military, I think the point Moore was trying to make was it is easier to send children off to war when they aren't in fact your children.
While hopefully parents can't actually enlist their children into the military, I think the point Moore was trying to make was it is easier to send children off to war when they aren't in fact your children.
#216
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Join Date: Feb 2000
Location: Twin Cities, Minnesota
Posts: 3,807
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by lisadoris
While hopefully parents can't actually enlist their children into the military, I think the point Moore was trying to make was it is easier to send children off to war when they aren't in fact your children.
While hopefully parents can't actually enlist their children into the military, I think the point Moore was trying to make was it is easier to send children off to war when they aren't in fact your children.