DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   Your thoughts on The Notebook. (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/370877-your-thoughts-notebook.html)

animalmystic 06-21-04 09:58 AM

Your thoughts on The Notebook.
 
Haven't heard much about this movie with all the big summer blockbusters, but I read just a little on it on IMDB, and it sounds like it might be pretty good. Has anybody heard anything on this movie? Good? Bad? I think it opens in a couple weeks, now I am intrigued

Geofferson 06-21-04 10:15 AM

I'm seeing a sneak preview of it this Thursday. I'll chime in with my thoughts then.

Groucho 06-21-04 10:23 AM

The previews make it look like "Sweet Home Alabama" redone as a serious period piece.

scott shelton 06-21-04 10:51 AM


Originally posted by Groucho
The previews make it look like "Sweet Home Alabama" redone as a serious period piece.
Well, that isn't the movie. I can assure you.

It's a textbook southern-fried romance, well acted by Rachel McAdams, and features stunning veteran work from James Garner and Gena Rowlands...

I was less impressed by Ryan Gosling, who people seem to love. His cliched, "method" brood is annoying, and he swallows his dialog over and over... He's not a good actor. Intense, but not good.

NOTEBOOK is a good summer tearjerker.

animalmystic 06-21-04 12:21 PM


Originally posted by Geofferson
I'm seeing a sneak preview of it this Thursday. I'll chime in with my thoughts then.
Great sounds good.

Thanks for everybodys thoughts so far.

Pants 06-21-04 01:46 PM

Isn't Ryan Gosling the guy from Saved By The Bell?

Jericho 06-21-04 02:27 PM


Originally posted by Pants
Isn't Ryan Gosling the guy from Saved By The Bell?
you mean Young Hercules?

Catch 21 06-21-04 03:56 PM

I did 2 screenings of this in the OC area . This makes Titanic look like Happy Gilmore. It was mostly women that attended.

IF romance makes you emotional
Spoiler:
bring some tissue

Giles 06-21-04 08:07 PM

well now that I read the book, I don't really care for the Hollywood version of the novel. Cinematography is gorgeous and the cast is commendable.
Spoiler:
the ending though is a tad too much and is an eye-roller IMO

smirnoffski 06-22-04 02:08 AM


Originally posted by scott shelton
Well, that isn't the movie. I can assure you.

It's a textbook southern-fried romance, well acted by Rachel McAdams, and features stunning veteran work from James Garner and Gena Rowlands...

I was less impressed by Ryan Gosling, who people seem to love. His cliched, "method" brood is annoying, and he swallows his dialog over and over... He's not a good actor. Intense, but not good.

NOTEBOOK is a good summer tearjerker.

Saw it at the opener tonite in Westwood and couldn't have said things better myself!

Pants 06-22-04 10:57 AM

Why does the son of John Casavettes make these undercooked, phoney emotion, three hanky, lame ass movies?

Didn't he learn anything from his father? His father made movies with balls.

Geofferson 06-24-04 11:10 PM

I just got back from the sneak preview of this and it was a decent tearjerker. A bit heavy-handed and cliched, but I sort of expected that going into it, so it really didn't take anything away from my view of the movie.

I, for one, enjoyed Gosling's performance. His scenes with McAdams were the highlight of the film (they both outshined Garner and Rowlands IMO).

2 1/2 stars (out of 4)

Geofferson 06-25-04 08:52 AM

Ebert's 3 1/2 star review here.

tanman 06-26-04 03:17 PM

I just saw it last night and I thought it was quite good. The shots were just beautiful and I thought the acting was superb. I thought Ryan Gosling and James Garner did a wonderful job.

Gosling especially not only looked older/younger but actually changed subtle mannerisms to really appear much older/younger.

Overall a good solid Romantic/Drama

NiceGal123 07-01-04 11:55 PM

I saw it few days ago---
Well, it was good, except for some parts of the screenplay. In certain scenes, the language was waaay off, and was more of a 2004 than 1940s. Whoever seen the movie, will most likely know what I am talking about.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:07 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.