DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   "Star Wars... SREWUP?" (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/360589-star-wars-srewup.html)

Sabrina29D 04-25-04 08:33 PM

"Star Wars... SREWUP?"
 
Ok... Did anyone notice in the first Star Wars they made (A new Hope.) When luke got out of his ship and everyone was in celebration. He went to scream Leia. But instead he screamed her real name Carrie instead.

Ok did that actully happen/ I played a few times to make sure. And i am pretty sure that it did.

Correct me if i am wrong. Did anyone else see it?

Dr. DVD 04-25-04 08:37 PM

Yep. It happened and is noted in a film flubs book.

Sabrina29D 04-25-04 08:41 PM

HA! Thanks for clearing that up...

milo bloom 04-25-04 08:41 PM

It's not Carrie, he starts to say "Hey, there she is" looking for Leia, but he kinda chokes for some reason. I'm fairly sure the official site has debunked it.

Rivero 04-25-04 09:15 PM

[BillMurray/].............oh Staaaaar Waaarrs...........nothing but Staaaaaaaaaar Waaaaaaaaaars............[BillMurray/]

Sabrina29D 04-25-04 09:17 PM

Are you sure. Cause i am pretty sure he says Carrie. It really does not sound like "Hey, there she is."

Jackskeleton 04-25-04 09:22 PM

He does scream Carrie. Trust me on it. Though they did eventually fix it.

Sabrina29D 04-25-04 10:12 PM

Yeah that is what i thought.

The Antipodean 04-25-04 10:15 PM

What the hell is a "srewup?" Or was that intentional bit of irony on your part in a post about mistakes. ;)

Josh-da-man 04-25-04 10:21 PM

"SREWUP?"

I thought it was an acronym for the title of Ep 3 when I clikced the thread.

devilshalo 04-25-04 10:31 PM

Some Really Evil Wookie Union Plan?

Sabrina29D 04-25-04 10:51 PM

lol sorry you guys. I meant they screwed up and missed the mistake. Didn't mean to disappoint anyone.

lol Sorry again!

Sabrina29D 04-25-04 11:01 PM

Jackskeleton:
"Though they did eventually fix it."

When did they fix the "Srewup" ?

Jackskeleton 04-25-04 11:14 PM

Think in the special editions they altered it. not entirely sure which version it was, but it was eventually removed.

Lara Means 04-26-04 03:50 AM

He didn't say Carrie. He said "HEY"

Shannon Nutt 04-26-04 07:58 AM

I still have the originals on laserdisc (as well as an old RCA Videodisc)...they never changed the line in the SE. He yells "HEY!", not "Carrie". There are a lot of so-called "flubs" listed in those movie guides and websites that aren't flubs at all...this is one of them.

chrisih8u 04-26-04 08:12 AM

Before the movie starts, my local theatre used to put that up on the screen as a flub.

Groucho 04-26-04 08:28 AM

When the SE came out, I compared it to the original...the delivery is the same. No change. Quite frankly, it's hard to tell if he's yelling "HEY!" or "Carrie!"

I've shown the scene to a few people unaware of the flub, and they all guess that he's saying "Hey!" If you tell them that he says "Carrie!" beforehand, then that's what they hear.

Kind of like the whole "Take off your clothes" thing in Aladdin.

Pants 04-26-04 01:26 PM

He did not say "Carrie".

He never said "Carrie".

They never "fixed" the line because there was nothing ever wrong with it.

This is just a stupid rumor that won't die (mostly because of the internet, erroneous books, theater trivia, etc.)

TK-421 04-26-04 01:31 PM

This is what you seek:
http://www.starwars.com/episode-iv/f...0/indexp3.html

Pants 04-26-04 02:17 PM


Originally posted by TK-421
This is what you seek:
http://www.starwars.com/episode-iv/f...0/indexp3.html

Thank you...the defense rests.

Jackskeleton 04-26-04 02:22 PM


Originally posted by Groucho
When the SE came out, I compared it to the original...the delivery is the same. No change. Quite frankly, it's hard to tell if he's yelling "HEY!" or "Carrie!"

I've shown the scene to a few people unaware of the flub, and they all guess that he's saying "Hey!" If you tell them that he says "Carrie!" beforehand, then that's what they hear.

Kind of like the whole "Take off your clothes" thing in Aladdin.

I will have to agree with Groucho here. that "Hey" sounds like there is a "Ca" sound infront of it.

Then again some of you take this a bit to seriously. We all know how indepth lucas is with his mistakes as we can see the great detail they explain the Holiday Special on the Official Website... riiiight?

Sabrina29D 04-26-04 03:03 PM

All i can say is... I wonder how many people popped out their DVD after reading this and scanned the scene listing just to see for them selves.

Jackskeleton 04-26-04 03:26 PM

ages ago.

dom56 04-26-04 03:36 PM

I loved the boob shot on ROTJ. :D


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:22 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.