DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   Movies that have scenes sort of copied from another movie (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/286565-movies-have-scenes-sort-copied-another-movie.html)

Rypro 525 04-16-03 05:32 PM

Movies that have scenes sort of copied from another movie
 
Since you probably have no idea what i am saying, here is an example. The movie The Transporter, the ending car chase is almost a direct ripoff/omage to Raiders of the Lost Arc. Another one is in Batman Mask of the Phantasm, Bruce runs up to a bike, and kicks the biker in slow motion. This is also a copy/omage to Akira.

MurraySiskind 04-16-03 05:49 PM

In Swingers when they walk out to their cars, Reservoir Dogs style. Of course it's done on purpose, as an homage.

Chad 04-16-03 05:50 PM

Many scenes from John Carpenter's Assault From Precinct 13. John Carpenter has said in the commentary that it's basically a modern day western, and is an homage to Rio Bravo...it's essentially a remake.

And obviously the scene where the gang attacks the police station closely resembles "Night Of The Living Dead".

Of course everything nowadays copies from "The Matrix".

Iron Chef 04-16-03 05:56 PM

Vanilla Sky scene by scene.

BoatDrinks 04-16-03 06:07 PM

movies that have scenes copied from another movie
 
A large majority of films done by filmmakers who arrived on the scene after 1990 have "copied" scenes...

Filmmakers raised on videos often don't have as interesting or unique imaginations as filmmakers that were raised on books.

The filmmakers of yesterday had to create images in their heads - 'today's' directors have seen hundreds of more films than 'yesterday's' and I think it shows in the work. They have not had to create from scratch like the old guys did. All the images are there in front of them. That is why there are very few directors from the last 10 years that I'd say stand up to most guys from before that time.

Rarely do you hear a 'new' director talk about reading books. Soderberg is the only one that comes to mind right now.
Today's guys see some obscure or not-so-obscure film on video or DVD and that inspires them and they almost subconsciously copy things. This didn't not happen nearly as much before the video boom.

jmho.

SunMonkey 04-17-03 04:06 PM

Deep Blue Sea - many, many scenes, along with the same death sequences for the three respective sharks, from Jaws 1-3. I don't see this as copying, though. It is more paying homage to the original films.

Mondo Kane 04-17-03 04:58 PM

I dont know if these are ripoffs or homages but:

The Untouchables using the baby carriage's spiral down the steps. First seen in Potemkin.

Final shoot-out in Extreme Prejudice looks mighty simliar to the climax of The Wild Bunch.

Craig Wasson witnessing some strange "going-ons" in Body Double just like Jimmy Stewart did in Rear Window.

Robert 04-17-03 05:01 PM

There is a scene in <b>Pearl Harbor</b> that is virtually identical to a scene in <b>Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade</b>

That scene is where the German fighter plane is chasing Indy and his father while they are driving Sallah's brother-in-law's car. This scene is practically replicated in Michael Bay's <b>Pearl Harbor</b>. The Japanese Zero is chasing the guys in the car as they are driving to the airfield.

Pants 04-17-03 05:43 PM


Originally posted by Robert
while they are driving Sallah's brother-in-law's car.
:whofart:

Robert 04-17-03 05:50 PM


Originally posted by Pants
:whofart:
Don't you remember the line: "That car belonged to my brother-in-law!"

Filmmaker 04-17-03 05:55 PM

CHASING AMY's blatant, but loving, homage to JAWS comes screaming to mind...

Pants 04-17-03 06:14 PM


Originally posted by Robert
Don't you remember the line: "That car belonged to my brother-in-law!"
Don't they steal that car from a guy changing a flat tire?

Venom 04-17-03 07:06 PM

just saw shogun assassin and it seemed the three storms in big trouble in little china were directly inspired by the 3 masters of death. not exactly a copied scene but i found it interesting.

Robert 04-18-03 12:58 AM


Originally posted by Pants
Don't they steal that car from a guy changing a flat tire?
Yeah, that guy must be his brother-in-law.

MrPeanut 04-18-03 01:16 AM

I always found the Requiem for a Dream/Perfect Blue bathtub scene to be interesting.

Numskull 04-18-03 02:22 AM

The wedding procession scene and the treetop fight in Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon were copied from a 1996 Hong Kong movie called The Hero of Swallow. Ang Lee has said that CTHD is a sort of homage to the kung fu movies he watched as a kid, but he wasn't "a kid" in '96, and more importantly, he did not "pay homage" to The Hero of Swallow; he merely stole from it.

zero 04-18-03 02:49 AM

[sarcasm]Bullet-Proof Monk, it TOTALLY rips off the Matrix[/sarcasm]

Jazzbutcher 04-18-03 07:40 AM

Spielberg blatantly ripped off two scenes from Journey to the Center of the Earth (1959) for Raiders of the Lost Ark (1981)

1. The giant rolling boulder scene

2. Sun shining to show the way to start the journey

Just picked JTCE on DVD-an great bargain!

Chipmaker 04-18-03 09:56 AM

Monsters, Inc. did a good riff on the swagger-down-the-hallway scene from The Right Stuff.

The second Bill & Ted film played on original series Star Trek in parts, using the same big rock (on the Paramount backlot, I suppose) as a set a few times.

Filmmaker 04-18-03 12:35 PM

Originally posted by Chipmaker:
using the same big rock (on the Paramount backlot, I suppose)

Actually, this is no backlot--it is a real location not far outside of L.A. called the Vasquez Rocks...we now return to our regularly scheduled programming...

Alien Redrum 04-18-03 12:35 PM

There was a scene from Not Another Teen Movie that was a blatent rip off of The Breakfast Club.

Rypro 525 04-18-03 12:42 PM


Originally posted by Alien Redrum
There was a scene from Not Another Teen Movie that was a blatent rip off of The Breakfast Club.
I think that was supposed to be a spoof, if you watched it more closely, you'll see that it copies basiclly most teen movies.

Groucho 04-18-03 12:48 PM


Originally posted by Rypro 525
I think that was supposed to be a spoof, if you watched it more closely, you'll see that it copies basiclly most teen movies.
The humor in the film is quite subtle, but now that I think about it you might be right.

Goat3001 04-18-03 12:54 PM


Originally posted by Rypro 525
I think that was supposed to be a spoof, if you watched it more closely, you'll see that it copies basiclly most teen movies.
You serious? -eek-

I better go re-watch Not Another Teen Movie right away.

Alien Redrum 04-18-03 12:57 PM


Originally posted by Rypro 525
I think that was supposed to be a spoof, if you watched it more closely, you'll see that it copies basiclly most teen movies.
What?!?!?

;)


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:55 AM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.