why were a clockwork orange and midnight cowboy both rated X?
#1
DVD Talk Hero
Thread Starter
why were a clockwork orange and midnight cowboy both rated X?
i was just wondering, i know they both have an R rating now, were these films so bad content wise that they made them rated X, or were the standards at the time diferent.
thanks for the help guys
thanks for the help guys
#2
Member
Join Date: Sep 2001
Location: glasgow
Posts: 128
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
You have to remember when these films where made, back in the 70's people led simpler live and watched movies though rose tinted glasses.
So seeing a movie like C'Orange glamorising gangs as a way of life, with house invasions, rape and murder, goverment sanctioned sterlisation via aversion therapy. It was all a bit much for joe public i guess.
It was pulled in the UK by the director himself due to copycat incidents. Always a classic way to make people want to see a movie is to tell them they cant.
So seeing a movie like C'Orange glamorising gangs as a way of life, with house invasions, rape and murder, goverment sanctioned sterlisation via aversion therapy. It was all a bit much for joe public i guess.
It was pulled in the UK by the director himself due to copycat incidents. Always a classic way to make people want to see a movie is to tell them they cant.
#3
Banned
Join Date: Jul 2002
Posts: 60
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
different standards back then:
midnight cowboy = gay = x
clockwork orange = violent, rape, etc. = x
now-a days folks don't mind that gay stuff...shoot, sometimes i even think about....oh, uh... how about KC Royals coach gettin' slammed!!!
midnight cowboy = gay = x
clockwork orange = violent, rape, etc. = x
now-a days folks don't mind that gay stuff...shoot, sometimes i even think about....oh, uh... how about KC Royals coach gettin' slammed!!!
#5
Moderator
Apparently there was some full frontal nudity during the orgy scene from "Clockwork Orange" that the MPAA at the time decided was X-rating material.
From Imdb:
A new special edition, which restores about 90 seconds of violent footage removed from most prints, was scheduled to be released on video in 1996.
In 1973, a new version of "A Clockwork Orange" was released to theaters with an MPAA rating of "R", replacing the previous "X". The new version contained approximately 31 seconds of _replacement_, less lascivious footage for two scenes: the high speed (2 frames/sec) orgy in Alex's bedroom, and the Ludovico rape scene.
Question: is there any difference between the Region 1 US edition and the UK Region 2 edition, is the UK version the complete unedited original cut of the film?
From Imdb:
A new special edition, which restores about 90 seconds of violent footage removed from most prints, was scheduled to be released on video in 1996.
In 1973, a new version of "A Clockwork Orange" was released to theaters with an MPAA rating of "R", replacing the previous "X". The new version contained approximately 31 seconds of _replacement_, less lascivious footage for two scenes: the high speed (2 frames/sec) orgy in Alex's bedroom, and the Ludovico rape scene.
Question: is there any difference between the Region 1 US edition and the UK Region 2 edition, is the UK version the complete unedited original cut of the film?
#7
DVD Talk Hero
Thread Starter
i ended up renting the restored and remastered vhs widescreen verison of a clockwork orange with a running time of 137 min. is this the original version that came in the theatres back in 71.
#10
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
The ratings system is a parent's guide to suitability for children. Always has been. Don't confuse it with a relativity scale on how explicit a film is. They made the mistake of not trademarking the "X" so it got co-opted by porn. X originally just meant "not suitable for children".
#11
DVD Talk Hero
Thread Starter
Originally posted by fiver
Rypro,
The current release of ACO is the same print that was first released (and rated X) originally.
Michael
Rypro,
The current release of ACO is the same print that was first released (and rated X) originally.
Michael
#12
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Mar 2000
Location: Where the sky is always Carolina Blue! (Currently VA - again...)
Posts: 5,167
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by caligulathegod
The ratings system is a parent's guide to suitability for children. Always has been. Don't confuse it with a relativity scale on how explicit a film is. They made the mistake of not trademarking the "X" so it got co-opted by porn. X originally just meant "not suitable for children".
The ratings system is a parent's guide to suitability for children. Always has been. Don't confuse it with a relativity scale on how explicit a film is. They made the mistake of not trademarking the "X" so it got co-opted by porn. X originally just meant "not suitable for children".
Tuan Jim
#13
Banned
Join Date: Apr 2000
Location: "Sitting on a beach, earning 20%"
Posts: 6,154
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Originally posted by Tuan Jim
That might explain the X rating for "The Long Good Friday" since that would be an easy R today.
Tuan Jim
That might explain the X rating for "The Long Good Friday" since that would be an easy R today.
Tuan Jim
#15
DVD Talk Hero
Thread Starter
i didnt like the movie at all, a little too creepy, unamusing and a little too violent for my tastes. in fact, i turned it off after a half an hour. durring the scene when the main character and some other guy end up raping a woman is when i gave up. also, i think that kubrick is a little obsesed with female nudity.
#16
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Join Date: Sep 2000
Location: Helsinki, Finland
Posts: 4,521
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
All said, though, sex in the movies was treated a lot more leniently in the '70s than it is now (in the U.S., that is - just don't mention the French ). There's no way the "Catholic High School Girls In Trouble" segment from The Kentucky Fried Movie would get away with an R in these days.
#17
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
also, i think that kubrick is a little obsesed with female nudity.
Hehehe... maybe Midnight Cowboy would be more your style...
I too agree with film is very disturbing, and I can't really watch it... but it doesn't mean it's a bad film.
Of course, ironically, neither film would get greenlighted in our present-day PG-13-all-day-for-all-time-save-the-childrens culture.