DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   International DVD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/international-dvd-talk-12/)
-   -   Polanski Triple Disc Set (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/international-dvd-talk/278141-polanski-triple-disc-set.html)

RichDB10 07-30-03 02:01 PM


Originally posted by djtoell
......in addition to the DD/DTS 5.1 tracks listed, since AB UK's remixes are generally unlistenable to me (and I don't consider myself to have the most critical of ears).

Yes..and in the case of 'Wings Of Desire' which was released by AB here in the UK literally 'unlistenable' as the 5.1 track suffered a 10min drop-out....i'm just hoping that these releases are going to be satisfactorily 'problem-free'....anyway by nature of the esteem these films are regarded in, there are those who will undoubtedly find faults no matter what Anchor Bay do...but yes..it would be nice to have the mono tracks.

WillyShatsWig 08-10-03 01:18 PM

There are no mono mixes in this set... all three movies have D2.0, DTS and DD5.1 audio. No mono.

We have just had the box set sent to us and have had a little look. The transfers look amazing from what we've seen.

Check out the menu shots here.

djtoell 08-10-03 02:28 PM

A 2.0 track can still be "mono" by having the same signal sent to both channels. Most DVD mono tracks are encoded in this fashion. Further, AB UK has listed 2.0 mono tracks incorrectly as "2.0 stereo" in the past. For example their Paris, Texas disc lists "Dolby Stereo" on the menu, but it's actually a mono track. In order to figure out if AB UK has done the same again, someone would need to engage DPL on their receiver to see if the sound collapses to the center channel (and, if it does, it's mono). I'm still hopeful that they're just continuing their clueless ways of making menus and have given us mono tracks...

If you get a chance, please pop the discs in with the Dolby Stereo tracks and DPL engaged on your receiver and see if the sound collapses to the center channel or spreads out to all of the channels.

DJ

WillyShatsWig 08-10-03 03:45 PM

just checked... the sound does indeed collapse to the centre channel. No need to threat, Anchor Bay UK have made a mistake and have labelled the menus as DD2.0 when in fact they are Mono.

djtoell 08-11-03 12:53 AM

Very cool. You're my personal hero for the month of August, and I'm not kidding. :D

RichDB10 08-17-03 06:02 AM

Judging by these two reviews this set is going to be fantastic!!

Repulsion:

http://www.dvdtimes.co.uk/index.cgi?...619&story=5053


Knife In The Water:

http://www.dvdtimes.co.uk/index.cgi?...618&story=5052

WillyShatsWig 08-24-03 01:40 PM

We've got the whole set done now... check the full review here.

Tony Block 09-01-03 12:39 AM

My copy arrived in the mail on Wednesday and the CUL-DE-SAC & REPULSION transfers are both gorgeous (Haven't had time to see the two other discs yet). the twenty minute docs on CUL-DE-SAC & REPULSION are well-made!


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:31 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.