Walt Disney Animated Classics 2019 Blu-ray releases
#51
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Walt Disney Animated Classics 2019 Blu-ray releases

I liked it the first time and maybe the second but now it is kind of boring
It is probably not good enough or the interest there to make a 3rd movie and Cage does not have the box office power he had in the early 2000's.
Maybe it would have been the closest thing for Cage to have his own franchise like Cruise has with MI where Cruise can sustain a career with those movies while all of his other projects tank or bomb at the box office.
#52
Cool New Member
Join Date: Jul 2019
Posts: 47
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Walt Disney Animated Classics 2019 Blu-ray releases
Is it just me, or is anyone else highly suspicious of classic animation on Blu-ray? I'm almost certain all of these types of releases are poor upscales. The editors may not have access to any decent masters in the first place.
And 4K upscaling? That's just overkill. Unless these films are entirely re-drawn from scratch, then the practice of HD upconversion is rather pointless.
And 4K upscaling? That's just overkill. Unless these films are entirely re-drawn from scratch, then the practice of HD upconversion is rather pointless.
#54
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Walt Disney Animated Classics 2019 Blu-ray releases
Most classic animation were made using cel animation, which come from actual film masters. It's the cheaper animation titles made in the 1980s and later for lower-budget fare that are more or less stuck at a certain resolution.
#55
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Walt Disney Animated Classics 2019 Blu-ray releases

I liked it the first time and maybe the second but now it is kind of boring
It is probably not good enough or the interest there to make a 3rd movie and Cage does not have the box office power he had in the early 2000's.
Maybe it would have been the closest thing for Cage to have his own franchise like Cruise has with MI where Cruise can sustain a career with those movies while all of his other projects tank or bomb at the box office.
#57
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Walt Disney Animated Classics 2019 Blu-ray releases
Is it just me, or is anyone else highly suspicious of classic animation on Blu-ray? I'm almost certain all of these types of releases are poor upscales. The editors may not have access to any decent masters in the first place.
And 4K upscaling? That's just overkill. Unless these films are entirely re-drawn from scratch, then the practice of HD upconversion is rather pointless.
And 4K upscaling? That's just overkill. Unless these films are entirely re-drawn from scratch, then the practice of HD upconversion is rather pointless.
That said, Disney has a poor track record of overly processing its animated classics with DNR, grain removal, sharpening, and digital recoloring. I've been rewatching a number of the these movies on Blu-ray with my kids and many of them look kind of terrible. I would like to hope that remastering the movies in 4k will give Disney an excuse to do proper restorations that look more like film, but I'm not sure I trust the studio that much.
#58
Cool New Member
Join Date: Jul 2019
Posts: 47
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Walt Disney Animated Classics 2019 Blu-ray releases
#59
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Walt Disney Animated Classics 2019 Blu-ray releases
That's the DNR, which is unfortunately pretty aggressive on most of these movies. It not only takes away the grain, but wipes out fine line detail in the animation, leaving the images texture-less.
#60
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Walt Disney Animated Classics 2019 Blu-ray releases
Hand-drawn cel animation was photographed onto film stock. There's no reason that the camera negative couldn't be scanned at a higher resolution, the same as any other movie that originated on film. That's not an "upscale."
That said, Disney has a poor track record of overly processing its animated classics with DNR, grain removal, sharpening, and digital recoloring. I've been rewatching a number of the these movies on Blu-ray with my kids and many of them look kind of terrible. I would like to hope that remastering the movies in 4k will give Disney an excuse to do proper restorations that look more like film, but I'm not sure I trust the studio that much.
That said, Disney has a poor track record of overly processing its animated classics with DNR, grain removal, sharpening, and digital recoloring. I've been rewatching a number of the these movies on Blu-ray with my kids and many of them look kind of terrible. I would like to hope that remastering the movies in 4k will give Disney an excuse to do proper restorations that look more like film, but I'm not sure I trust the studio that much.
#61
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Walt Disney Animated Classics 2019 Blu-ray releases
#62
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Walt Disney Animated Classics 2019 Blu-ray releases
I might be tempted to buy the 4K Aladdin Blu-ray
#63
Banned by request
Re: Walt Disney Animated Classics 2019 Blu-ray releases
#64
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Walt Disney Animated Classics 2019 Blu-ray releases
Diane Krueger was stunning in those movies
#65
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Thread Starter
Re: Walt Disney Animated Classics 2019 Blu-ray releases
So, Disney is dumping 2 Signature Collection titles on Sept. 24. 101 Dalmatians and Sleeping Beauty (to coincide with the Maleficent 4K release).
If ever there were a classic animation title to give a 4K release, I'd think Sleeping Beauty should be it, but nope. No details on the contents of these releases yet, but given the way they're dumping them, I expect them to be retreads of the Diamond editions with maybe 1 or 2 new and worthless bonus features.


Best Buy steelbooks:

If ever there were a classic animation title to give a 4K release, I'd think Sleeping Beauty should be it, but nope. No details on the contents of these releases yet, but given the way they're dumping them, I expect them to be retreads of the Diamond editions with maybe 1 or 2 new and worthless bonus features.


Best Buy steelbooks:


Last edited by TheBang; 08-13-19 at 05:46 AM.
#67
DVD Talk Godfather & 2020 TOTY Winner
Re: Walt Disney Animated Classics 2019 Blu-ray releases
Those are pretty but certainly not enough to make me rebuy two movies I already own in two formats (BR, Digital HD) I already have them in.
#68
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Walt Disney Animated Classics 2019 Blu-ray releases
The Sleeping Beauty artwork is awful
I don't get the connection between Maleficent and 101 Dalmatians.
I don't get the connection between Maleficent and 101 Dalmatians.
#70
Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Connecticut
Posts: 323
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Walt Disney Animated Classics 2019 Blu-ray releases
That's probable, but I think it's more likely just because they are just trying to dump the remaining Signature titles on disc before Disney+ launches in November. I bet they'll keep them in print too.
#71
Re: Walt Disney Animated Classics 2019 Blu-ray releases
I like your avatar. This looks to be the season that makes or breaks the Harbaugh legacy. With Meyer gone, he better beat OSU or there will be an uproar in Ann Arbor not seen since the Moeller incident.
#73
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Walt Disney Animated Classics 2019 Blu-ray releases
I’d like the Steelbook for 101 Dalmatians better if the front wasn’t overtaken completely by Cruella. I’d rather the pups be on front. I’ll buy probably just the standard release. Could care less about Sleeping Beauty.
#74
DVD Talk Legend & 2021 TOTY Winner
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Detroit - Formerly known as Obi-Wan Jabroni
Posts: 12,086
Received 570 Likes
on
268 Posts
Re: Walt Disney Animated Classics 2019 Blu-ray releases
Thanks, and personally I agree, but I don't think the athletic department has the balls to hold him to that standard. He will be at UM until he doesn't want to be.
#75
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Walt Disney Animated Classics 2019 Blu-ray releases