DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   HD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk-55/)
-   -   'Walking with Dinosaurs' bluray deluxe edition hints at original undubbed version (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk/617877-walking-dinosaurs-bluray-deluxe-edition-hints-original-undubbed-version.html)

Giles 02-09-14 08:14 PM

'Walking with Dinosaurs' bluray deluxe edition hints at original undubbed version
 
gathering from what was announced by Fox Home Video - there's a major catch - the original cut being billed as the 'Cretaceous Cut' is only on the 3D Deluxe edition - but not on the standard Blu-ray/DVD combo pack. There has yet to be a confirmation if the original cut is both on the 2D and the 3D blu of the deluxe edition further details TBA.


Deluxe Edition 3D Combo
Feature film in high definition, standard definition and 3D
Blu-ray Exclusive Special Features:
-Ultimate Dino Guide
-Interactive Map
-Match the Call game
-Brainosaur Trivia Track
-Cretaceous Cut (the movie in its "natural" version)
-Nickelodeon Orange Carpet Dino Rap

Blu-ray / DVD Combo edition:
Feature film in high definition and standard definition
Blu-ray Special Features
-Ultimate Dino Guide
-Interactive Map
-Match the Call game
-Brainosaur Trivia Track
-Nickelodeon Orange Carpet Dino Rap

The release will be available for purchase online and in stores across the United States on March 25th.

Rypro 525 02-09-14 09:42 PM

Re: 'Walking with Dinosaurs' minus the dumb as dirt voice-overs ... BUT
 
just like with The Wolverine. I assume the movie was made w no talking, but the studio got worried, & ended up fucking up a solid movie?

LPMA 02-09-14 10:00 PM

Re: 'Walking with Dinosaurs' minus the dumb as dirt voice-overs ... BUT
 

Originally Posted by Rypro 525 (Post 12006200)
just like with The Wolverine. I assume the movie was made w no talking, but the studio got worried, & ended up fucking up a solid movie?

From Wikipedia:


In the film, actors provide voiceovers for the main creatures. Director Barry Cook said the original plan was for the film to be without dialogue or narration. He said, "I think originally, we were looking at a film that could stand alone as a virtual silent movie... You can turn the soundtrack off and still get involved with the story and feel the emotions of the characters. In its final version, the movie has a narration and goes inside the heads of the animals, so you can hear what they're thinking."[13] Executives at 20th Century Fox, one of the film's main distributors, viewed a rough cut and thought the film needed voiceovers so children in the audience could connect to the characters.[31]
The film's character designer David Krentz said, "Although the production veered away from being very realistic, the animation still plays independently. The powers that be decided to add narration and voice-over to reach a wider audience and the characters became slightly anthropomorphized to make them more attractive to younger kids."[13] Palaeontologist Steve Brusatte responded to The Scotsman's prompt about the "danger of anthropomorphising" the dinosaurs, "The voiceovers are a bit of a compromise; the dinosaurs' lips aren't moving, they are not smiling and having human-like facial expressions or anything like that... They are only anthropomorphised to a small degree and that is necessary for a film like this."[22]

Rypro 525 02-09-14 10:19 PM

Re: 'Walking with Dinosaurs' minus the dumb as dirt voice-overs ... BUT
 
and having the dinos talk probably hurt whatever chances it had at the box office. (well tht and frozen)

RocShemp 02-09-14 10:45 PM

Re: 'Walking with Dinosaurs' minus the dumb as dirt voice-overs ... BUT
 
Well that certainly explains why the voice overs seemed tacked on during the trailers. I was hoping there'd be a voiceover-free version and am glad there is. If the price comes down enough, I'll get it.

Giles 02-09-14 11:33 PM

Re: 'Walking with Dinosaurs' minus the dumb as dirt voice-overs ... BUT
 

Originally Posted by RocShemp (Post 12006233)
Well that certainly explains why the voice overs seemed tacked on during the trailers. I was hoping there'd be a voiceover-free version and am glad there is. If the price comes down enough, I'll get it.

I remember the first batch of trailers made no hint at the voice overs - at that point of time, the decision to the do the voice work probably wasn't enacted.


Originally Posted by Rypro 525 (Post 12006215)
and having the dinos talk probably hurt whatever chances it had at the box office. (well tht and frozen)

yeah, but any kid's movie released during Frozen's theatrical run really didn't have a chance.


as for Fox's decision to enact the voice over change - well that certainly back fired and bit itself on the ass. Gathering from what was/is being said on WwD's facebook page it's a pretty divided opinion that kids under the age of 10 liked the dino's talking - but most of the adults just thought it was akin to hearing someone scratching their nails on a chalk board.

Giles 03-25-14 11:26 AM

Re: 'Walking with Dinosaurs' bluray deluxe edition hints at original undubbed version
 
some clarification of the 'Cretaceous Cut' - as noted before it's an exclusive on the 3D combo pack - it's the 75 minute version of the film - it doesn't include the human intro/ending bookend scenes of the film, and there's no end credits - unfortunately it's not in 3D - so .... win some, lose some. [sigh]

Josh Z 03-25-14 01:34 PM

Re: 'Walking with Dinosaurs' bluray deluxe edition hints at original undubbed version
 

Originally Posted by Giles (Post 12056379)
some clarification of the 'Cretaceous Cut' - as noted before it's an exclusive on the 3D combo pack - it's the 75 minute version of the film - it doesn't include the human intro/ending bookend scenes of the film, and there's no end credits - unfortunately it's not in 3D - so .... win some, lose some. [sigh]

Was the voiceover dialogue removed?

Giles 03-25-14 01:53 PM

Re: 'Walking with Dinosaurs' bluray deluxe edition hints at original undubbed version
 

Originally Posted by Josh Z (Post 12056530)
Was the voiceover dialogue removed?

yes it was. (Just sound effects and music)

the sound is lossy Dolby Digital 5.1

Arthur Dent 03-25-14 04:34 PM

Re: 'Walking with Dinosaurs' bluray deluxe edition hints at original undubbed version
 

Originally Posted by Giles (Post 12056379)
unfortunately it's not in 3D - so .... win some, lose some. [sigh]

The blu-ray.com review says otherwise. Whether that's true or not...

Giles 03-25-14 04:36 PM

Re: 'Walking with Dinosaurs' bluray deluxe edition hints at original undubbed version
 
actually I might be wrong - supposedly the Cretaceous Cut IS viewable in 3D (as denoted as such in the blu-ray.com review of the disc) - I'm just not seeing that option in the menu tab - so disregard my past comment in posting #7

EDIT:

so yes it is in 3D as well:


"When you select "Cretaceous Cut" from the Extras menu, there's a secondary menu that pops up where you can choose either 3D or 2D. If you don't have a 3D display connected to your player, you may not get that option--that's how other similarly authored discs work."

whotony 04-02-14 08:03 PM

Re: 'Walking with Dinosaurs' bluray deluxe edition hints at original undubbed version
 
Wasn't The Disney movie Dinosaurs originally going to be a no talking movie too?

Josh Z 04-03-14 01:24 PM

Re: 'Walking with Dinosaurs' bluray deluxe edition hints at original undubbed version
 

Originally Posted by whotony (Post 12065967)
Wasn't The Disney movie Dinosaurs originally going to be a no talking movie too?

Maybe in its earliest conception, but when it was actually made, the dinosaurs were animated with talking mouth movements.

The dialogue in Walking with Dinosaurs was imposed by the studio after the movie was mostly complete. The dinosaurs mouths don't move when they speak.

Giles 04-03-14 02:03 PM

Re: 'Walking with Dinosaurs' bluray deluxe edition hints at original undubbed version
 
the first trailer for Dinosaurs was the wordless opening - I remember being quite impressed - until they started talking.

rexinnih 04-03-14 03:46 PM

Re: 'Walking with Dinosaurs' bluray deluxe edition hints at original undubbed version
 
Saw this over the weekend and the dub was just insulting. My 5 and 2 1/2 year old watched the first 15 minutes and wandered off to play.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:22 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.