DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   HD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk-55/)
-   -   Could Batman TAS Ever Be Released on Blu Ray? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk/610177-could-batman-tas-ever-released-blu-ray.html)

PatD 04-20-13 11:31 PM

Could Batman TAS Ever Be Released on Blu Ray?
 
I'm not certain if this is even possible or if it's as good as it's going to get for that particular series image-wise (was it animated on film?). But, I'm not certain whether to shell out for the out-of-print box set of Batman TAS, or wait either for some "remastered" re-issue on DVD or even Blu Ray. But, I have to ask if it is even possible.

The Man with the Golden Doujinshi 04-21-13 11:33 AM

Re: Could Batman TAS Ever Be Released on Blu Ray?
 
Sure. Why not? All it takes is money and a company that wants to do it.

Gizmo 04-21-13 11:39 AM

Re: Could Batman TAS Ever Be Released on Blu Ray?
 
Considering catalog TV on Blu-ray is pretty rare...this doesn't have much of a chance.

Mike86 04-21-13 12:31 PM

Re: Could Batman TAS Ever Be Released on Blu Ray?
 
It would be great and I'd buy it in an instant but I sort of doubt it'll happen. Warner hasn't even given us the complete run of Justice League yet (well at least they haven't given us Justice League Unlimited which is essentially seasons three and four of Justice Leage). I think at most we'll possibly see the movies from Batman: The Animated Series (Mask of thePhantasm and Sub-Zero) eventually since we already got Mystery of the Batwoman in March.

PatD 04-21-13 12:39 PM

Re: Could Batman TAS Ever Be Released on Blu Ray?
 

Originally Posted by GizmoDVD (Post 11661594)
Considering catalog TV on Blu-ray is pretty rare...this doesn't have much of a chance.

The first part is definitely true. However, this isn't AfterM*A*S*H. This is the frickin' Batman! If Star Trek: Enterprise is worthy of a BD release...

Gizmo 04-21-13 01:35 PM

Re: Could Batman TAS Ever Be Released on Blu Ray?
 

Originally Posted by PatD (Post 11661656)
The first part is definitely true. However, this isn't AfterM*A*S*H. This is the frickin' Batman! If Star Trek: Enterprise is worthy of a BD release...

It's a cartoon.

Mike86 04-21-13 02:07 PM

Re: Could Batman TAS Ever Be Released on Blu Ray?
 

Originally Posted by GizmoDVD (Post 11661687)
It's a cartoon.

Your point being? Batman is a very popular character and sells a ton of merchandise for Warner. Look at all the animated film titles Batman has out in comparison to other DC characters. Just because it's a cartoon doesn't make it a lesser product. It's more just a matter of if they think that it's worth going back to putting in time and effort to restore the show and re-release it when it's already on DVD and aside from the die hard fans it might not meet their expectations for how well it will sell.

Solid Snake 04-21-13 02:07 PM

Re: Could Batman TAS Ever Be Released on Blu Ray?
 

Originally Posted by Mister Peepers (Post 11661590)
Sure. Why not? All it takes is money and a company that wants to do it.

This.

We've 2 seasons of the JL cartoon on BD. How long that 2nd one take to get?

Gizmo 04-21-13 02:12 PM

Re: Could Batman TAS Ever Be Released on Blu Ray?
 

Originally Posted by Mike86 (Post 11661714)
Your point being? Batman is a very popular character and sells a ton of merchandise for Warner. Look at all the animated film titles Batman has out in comparison to other DC characters. Just because it's a cartoon doesn't make it a lesser product. It's more just a matter of if they think that it's worth going back to putting in time and effort to restore the show and re-release it when it's already on DVD and aside from the die hard fans it might not meet their expectations for how well it will sell.

He was comparing Star Trek to a kids cartoon. They are not the same.

TV on Blu-ray already sells poorly. TV Catalog on Blu-ray is even worse.

I really didn't follow this show, but isn't it Warner? That up's it chances slightly as Warner is one of the few studios that supports catalog on Blu-ray, but still, the chance of this are so damn impossible. The Justice League took years for a second season to get released, and there no plans for the rest.

PhantomStranger 04-21-13 02:34 PM

Re: Could Batman TAS Ever Be Released on Blu Ray?
 
This would have already seen a Blu-ray release, if it had been made in the digital masters era at Warner Animation (anything after 2001).

It didn't look that great on DVD (the animation quality was pretty cheap and rushed for its era) and would look even worse on Blu-ray. This is a case where improved resolution would simply point out more obvious flaws in the animation. I don't believe Warner will ever release it on Blu-ray.

The Man with the Golden Doujinshi 04-21-13 02:59 PM

Re: Could Batman TAS Ever Be Released on Blu Ray?
 

Originally Posted by GizmoDVD (Post 11661725)
I really didn't follow this show

It was fairly popular and still holds up well, unlike a lot of other TV shows and cartoons. Plus it's Batman and plus it WB.

I'm not a comic book nerd and I don't care for the other superhero cartoons but this one was actually good.

wahlers 04-21-13 09:40 PM

Re: Could Batman TAS Ever Be Released on Blu Ray?
 
If WB had available HD masters I would have thought they would have used them for the episodes included as extras on the Gotham Knight and Year One blu-rays.

If they don't have existing HD masters then given the age of the series and the number of episodes I sincerely doubt WB will put in the work to put it on blu-ray. Sorry.

bluetoast 04-21-13 10:06 PM

Re: Could Batman TAS Ever Be Released on Blu Ray?
 
It would probably make more sense to put it on a streaming site. Cheers is one of the biggest catalog shows in the business and is available in HD on Amazon Instant, but realistically it's not coming to BD anytime soon. Hell even Seinfeld is available in HD but that's nowhere to be seen on the home market.

Xiroteus 04-21-13 10:13 PM

Re: Could Batman TAS Ever Be Released on Blu Ray?
 
If it could be done I would buy it, it is Batman - The Animated Series, this ranks within the couple dozen series I wish to own.

Supermallet 04-22-13 03:06 AM

Re: Could Batman TAS Ever Be Released on Blu Ray?
 
Other than Looney Tunes, I can't think of a non-feature length animated property that could come close in popularity (and willingness of the fanbase to spend too much money) to Star Trek.

Pokemon, maybe?

Xiroteus 04-22-13 08:27 AM

Re: Could Batman TAS Ever Be Released on Blu Ray?
 

Originally Posted by Supermallet (Post 11662295)
Other than Looney Tunes, I can't think of a non-feature length animated property that could come close in popularity (and willingness of the fanbase to spend too much money) to Star Trek.

Pokemon, maybe?

Likely not much since the Star Trek fan base is rather large.

banthafett 04-22-13 08:33 AM

Re: Could Batman TAS Ever Be Released on Blu Ray?
 
I would love for this to come out. I'm afraid to buy the big box set because of all the bootlegs out there.

The Man with the Golden Doujinshi 04-22-13 09:55 AM

Re: Could Batman TAS Ever Be Released on Blu Ray?
 

Originally Posted by PhantomStranger (Post 11661740)
the animation quality was pretty cheap and rushed for its era

Actually it was praised for it's animation style of light colors on dark paper to give it a noir look. Industry standard was dark colors on white paper.

It won for emmys, so if any cartoon would make it's way to blu-ray, it would have to be this one.

Gizmo 04-22-13 10:00 AM

Re: Could Batman TAS Ever Be Released on Blu Ray?
 

Originally Posted by Mister Peepers (Post 11662470)
Actually it was praised for it's animation style of light colors on dark paper to give it a noir look. Industry standard was dark colors on white paper.

It won for emmys, so if any cartoon would make it's way to blu-ray, it would have to be this one.

You're trying to make a case for a title that will never hit Blu-ray.

Films that won many awards are now shuttled off to no-name studios to be limited to 3,000 copies sold at $35 each.

This isn't going to happen. A show that currently airs on TV is far more likely.

bluetoast 04-22-13 10:47 AM

Re: Could Batman TAS Ever Be Released on Blu Ray?
 
Yeah. Not even The Sopranos could sell that well. Granted it was when BD wasn't as big, but the show is still a huge draw.

The Man with the Golden Doujinshi 04-22-13 01:11 PM

Re: Could Batman TAS Ever Be Released on Blu Ray?
 

Originally Posted by GizmoDVD (Post 11662478)
You're trying to make a case for a title that will never hit Blu-ray.

Films that won many awards are now shuttled off to no-name studios to be limited to 3,000 copies sold at $35 each.

This isn't going to happen. A show that currently airs on TV is far more likely.

You were giving your opinion to a show you knew nothing about. At least I have some knowledge of it.

edit: Not denying you may or may not be correct but at least dig up some info on a show you know nothing about before basing opinions on it. I've just seem you say other things that ended up being completely off-base.

PhantomStranger 04-22-13 02:11 PM

Re: Could Batman TAS Ever Be Released on Blu Ray?
 

Originally Posted by Mister Peepers (Post 11662470)
Actually it was praised for it's animation style of light colors on dark paper to give it a noir look. Industry standard was dark colors on white paper.

It won for emmys, so if any cartoon would make it's way to blu-ray, it would have to be this one.

Stylish animation for a kids series but very, very cheaply done. Timm has even talked about that in recent years. There are tons of animation errors in it that would need to be digitally corrected today.

The Man with the Golden Doujinshi 04-22-13 06:56 PM

Re: Could Batman TAS Ever Be Released on Blu Ray?
 
At least it isn't the animation I grew up with, like He-Man and Spider-Man. Constant reuse of animation. Spider-Man was the worst in the end of it's run.

Xiroteus 04-22-13 06:56 PM

Re: Could Batman TAS Ever Be Released on Blu Ray?
 

Originally Posted by PhantomStranger (Post 11662832)
Stylish animation for a kids series but very, very cheaply done. Timm has even talked about that in recent years. There are tons of animation errors in it that would need to be digitally corrected today.

If it was in high definition I also wonder about the grain and dust on the animations cells which he talked about. It may be one of those shows that is just going to look a bit older and not as shinny as Justice League and so forth.

Gizmo 04-22-13 10:03 PM

Re: Could Batman TAS Ever Be Released on Blu Ray?
 

Originally Posted by Mister Peepers (Post 11662731)
You were giving your opinion to a show you knew nothing about. At least I have some knowledge of it.

edit: Not denying you may or may not be correct but at least dig up some info on a show you know nothing about before basing opinions on it. I've just seem you say other things that ended up being completely off-base.

If it's the cartoon version from the mid 90's, I've seen some of it. It was cheap and poorly done back then and I'm sure it won't hold up today. Warner would be better off releasing more of the Looney Tunes sets (which I don't think even sold that well to begin with), instead of something that a couple thousand (at best) people would buy over a lifetime.

No matter what, it's a cartoon and it's not going to get a Blu-ray release. I don't need to know jack on it to tell you that a 20 year old kids cartoon series isn't going to get a Blu-ray release.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:53 AM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.