DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   HD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk-55/)
-   -   E.T. coming Fall 2012 (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk/601963-e-t-coming-fall-2012-a.html)

BuckNaked2k 08-16-12 03:41 PM

Re: E.T. coming Fall 2012
 
^ This is a Target exclusive. I've only seen that "preorder" trick played by BB.

Spottedfeather 08-16-12 08:26 PM

Re: E.T. coming Fall 2012
 
Does the steelbook have the movie or not ?

OldBoy 08-16-12 09:42 PM

Re: E.T. coming Fall 2012
 

Originally Posted by Spottedfeather (Post 11349545)
Does the steelbook have the movie or not ?

2k answered the question.

Spottedfeather 08-16-12 09:47 PM

Re: E.T. coming Fall 2012
 
Did not. They just said something about a preorder exclusive.

BuckNaked2k 08-16-12 09:57 PM

Re: E.T. coming Fall 2012
 
The Target exclusive contains the movie.

Spottedfeather 08-17-12 04:01 PM

Re: E.T. coming Fall 2012
 
Finally......

kenbenobi 08-18-12 01:47 AM

Re: E.T. coming Fall 2012
 

Originally Posted by Spottedfeather (Post 11349260)
This may be a dumb question, but I haven't been able to find anything about it anywhere else. Does the E.T. steelbook come with the movie inside it, or is it like Snow White and Beauty And The Beast, where the case is empty when you buy it ?

The picture shows it comes with BD + DVD + DC + Ultraviolet:
http://www.target.com/p/e-t-steelboo..._page.banner_1

Spottedfeather 08-19-12 04:28 AM

Re: E.T. coming Fall 2012
 
I just preordered the steelbook. E.T. is one of those strange movies for me. On one hand, I really love the movie. Everything about it just screams early 80s to me. And I LOVE 80s movies. Especially fantasy movies like this. But on the other hand, E.T. is really sad at the end when he says goodbye to everyone. I love the movie, but I don't like to watch it that much because of the ending.

OldBoy 09-18-12 05:46 AM

Re: E.T. coming Fall 2012
 
Blu-ray.com
Movie: http://www.dvdtalk.com/reviews/images/4.5.gif
Video: http://www.dvdtalk.com/reviews/images/4.5.gif
Audio: http://www.dvdtalk.com/reviews/images/4.5.gif
Extras: http://www.dvdtalk.com/reviews/images/4.gif
Overall: http://www.dvdtalk.com/reviews/images/4.5.gif

OldBoy 09-18-12 08:30 PM

Re: E.T. coming Fall 2012
 

Originally Posted by kenbenobi (Post 11351014)
The picture shows it comes with BD + DVD + DC + Ultraviolet:
http://www.target.com/p/e-t-steelboo..._page.banner_1

this will be sold in Target stores, right? says "not sold in stores" but that can't be...

Fok 09-19-12 03:28 PM

Re: E.T. coming Fall 2012
 
Haven't had a chance to read through all the posts. Should I keep my 2 disk DVD set? Or has everything been ported over to the Blu Ray?

The Man with the Golden Doujinshi 09-19-12 04:04 PM

Re: E.T. coming Fall 2012
 
Not everything has been ported over.

Spottedfeather 09-19-12 04:28 PM

Re: E.T. coming Fall 2012
 
The only thing from the Ultimate Collector's Set that I'm going to miss is the live score conducted by John Williams. It was only on the 2002 Walkie-Talkie cut.

Fok 09-20-12 11:46 AM

Re: E.T. coming Fall 2012
 

Originally Posted by Mister Peepers (Post 11391387)
Not everything has been ported over.


Guess I'll be keeping my DVD set then

wahlers 09-20-12 07:21 PM

Re: E.T. coming Fall 2012
 
Spielberg drives me crazy with his no-backbone attitude.

First he does the 2002 version, which according to his intro fixes his pet peeves from the past 20 years (at that time) that made him cringe. Then people bitched about it, especially the walkie-talkie thing (which, if they had been in the original version, would have never even been a big deal) so he included both versions on the dvds. It was the right thing to do but it still felt more like he was more worried about negative feedback or impacted sales rather than any artistic integrity.

So then people continued to bitch so now he disowns it?

I personally thought that all of the enhanced E.T. stuff was a vast improvement and will miss it on the blu-ray. And while I thought the bathtub scene was too long, I will miss the extra halloween bit being in the film. Drew's hilariously bad acting is so charming.

I guess we're just supposed to accept that everything he said in the 2002 intro was a lie to sell more copies.

He could have at least let somebody have a limited Digibook with both versions. I'm thinking it's also possible that the CG enhancements weren't stored or kept in HD so they'd have to start from scratch and that's too expensive, but they just don't want to tell us that.

Regardless, Lucas may piss people off, but at least he has the balls to stand by what he says are improvements regardless of what other people say. Spielberg is just spineless.

I bet if Lucas hadn't have been involved we could have bullied Spielberg into making a good Indiana Jones 4.

ScissorPuppy 09-20-12 07:47 PM

Re: E.T. coming Fall 2012
 
The 2002 version of E.T. was a theatrical release, film prints were made. The digital effects were probably done in at least 2k rez, so them not being in HD isn't the issue.

With that said, I don't see the problem with offering the previous special edition as a bonus. He did it with Close Encounters.

Doctorossi 09-20-12 10:32 PM

Re: E.T. coming Fall 2012
 

Originally Posted by wahlers (Post 11393126)
I guess we're just supposed to accept that everything he said in the 2002 intro was a lie to sell more copies.

Yes, because people are not capable of ever changing their minds.

bluetoast 09-21-12 02:08 AM

Re: E.T. coming Fall 2012
 
I can bet you they'll use quotes from this in the Digibook (same interview that was cited in the Jaws one), and he talks about his thoughts on alterations:

http://www.aintitcool.com/node/49921

wahlers 09-21-12 11:12 AM

Re: E.T. coming Fall 2012
 
It's not that people can't change their minds, it just seems like he either overstated his excitement at the time to sell the product or he backed down now because of popular opinion.

Either way I don't feel like he a very consistant or trustworthy person.

Shannon Nutt 09-21-12 01:39 PM

Re: E.T. coming Fall 2012
 

Originally Posted by wahlers (Post 11393802)
It's not that people can't change their minds, it just seems like he either overstated his excitement at the time to sell the product or he backed down now because of popular opinion.

Either way I don't feel like he a very consistant or trustworthy person.

I'll take Speilberg any day over Lucas. Speilberg tried something, got a lot of criticism about it and recanted. Lucas tries something, gets a lot of criticism and responds by doing more of it.

Oliver Clothesoff 09-21-12 03:25 PM

Re: E.T. coming Fall 2012
 
Exactly. I see it more of Speilberg finally seeing the error of his ways and backtracking to make things right. He did the same with Raiders.

Spiderbite 09-21-12 03:55 PM

Re: E.T. coming Fall 2012
 

Originally Posted by wahlers (Post 11393126)
Spielberg drives me crazy with his no-backbone attitude.

First he does the 2002 version, which according to his intro fixes his pet peeves from the past 20 years (at that time) that made him cringe. Then people bitched about it, especially the walkie-talkie thing (which, if they had been in the original version, would have never even been a big deal) so he included both versions on the dvds. It was the right thing to do but it still felt more like he was more worried about negative feedback or impacted sales rather than any artistic integrity.

So then people continued to bitch so now he disowns it?

I personally thought that all of the enhanced E.T. stuff was a vast improvement and will miss it on the blu-ray. And while I thought the bathtub scene was too long, I will miss the extra halloween bit being in the film. Drew's hilariously bad acting is so charming.

I guess we're just supposed to accept that everything he said in the 2002 intro was a lie to sell more copies.

He could have at least let somebody have a limited Digibook with both versions. I'm thinking it's also possible that the CG enhancements weren't stored or kept in HD so they'd have to start from scratch and that's too expensive, but they just don't want to tell us that.

Regardless, Lucas may piss people off, but at least he has the balls to stand by what he says are improvements regardless of what other people say. Spielberg is just spineless.

I bet if Lucas hadn't have been involved we could have bullied Spielberg into making a good Indiana Jones 4.

Spielberg gives us the original version. Lucas doesn't. 'Nuff said.

Mike86 09-21-12 05:15 PM

Re: E.T. coming Fall 2012
 

Originally Posted by wahlers (Post 11393802)
It's not that people can't change their minds, it just seems like he either overstated his excitement at the time to sell the product or he backed down now because of popular opinion.

Either way I don't feel like he a very consistant or trustworthy person.

This doesn't really make sense to me at all. He made changes, the vast majority of people didn't like them, so he goes back and gives us the original film again. I see no problem with that. At least he's not an asshole about it like Lucas is with Star Wars who seems to just like aggravating his fanbase.

It maybe would've been nice if Spielberg had included the altered version of E.T. for people who really wanted it but I believe the DVD is still fairly easy to find so while it's not high definition at least it's available if someone really wants it.

OldBoy 09-21-12 06:09 PM

Re: E.T. coming Fall 2012
 
Spielberg and Lucas both raped my childhood.

wahlers 09-21-12 08:09 PM

Re: E.T. coming Fall 2012
 

Originally Posted by Mike86 (Post 11394315)
It maybe would've been nice if Spielberg had included the altered version of E.T. for people who really wanted it but I believe the DVD is still fairly easy to find so while it's not high definition at least it's available if someone really wants it.

That's all I'm saying, just include a copy of the 2002 version in a limited release for people who like it.

The funny part is that after years of bitching, when Lucas gave people the dvds of the original versions of Star Wars, the fans immediately starting pestering him about when they would be on blu-ray. And people wonder why he hates his fans.

Oh, and for the record, I'm part of the original fan base for all of these films (born in 1974) and was a rabid fan of the films and toys of Star Wars, Indiana Jones and E.T. as a kid, watched them all hundreds and hundreds of times, and am now an artist and film buff, but easily prefer the modified versions of all of them. It happens.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:55 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.