DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   HD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk-55/)
-   -   Justice League Season Two - July 26th (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk/589455-justice-league-season-two-july-26th.html)

Jedi Master 33 04-09-11 12:27 AM

Justice League Season Two - July 26th
 
http://www.blu-ray.com/news/?id=6153

A admin over at Toonzone also confirmed that this will be 16x9.

milo bloom 04-09-11 11:20 AM

Re: Justice League Season Two - July 26th
 
Until they fix season one in 16x9 widescreen, I'm not interested.

TheMovieman 04-09-11 11:23 AM

Re: Justice League Season Two - July 26th
 
^ Well, that won't likely happen.

Anyway, I'm in.

davidh777 04-09-11 11:33 AM

Re: Justice League Season Two - July 26th
 
I thought with season 2 we might escape the endless WS/FS debate. I guess not.

milo bloom 04-09-11 12:40 PM

Re: Justice League Season Two - July 26th
 

Originally Posted by davidh777 (Post 10717500)
I thought with season 2 we might escape the endless WS/FS debate. I guess not.

Not until they fix the damn problem :brickwl:

Seriously, there's no point in me buying the rest of the series until the whole thing is properly presented.

Jedi Master 33 04-10-11 06:28 AM

Re: Justice League Season Two - July 26th
 
You guys do know what 16x9 is, don't you?;)


Update (7:30pm ET): A representative for Warner Home Video has just confirmed that the aspect ratio for the "Justice League: Season Two" Blu-ray release will be 16x9.
http://www.worldsfinestonline.com/ne...llnews&id=1006

RickWJ324 04-10-11 08:01 AM

Re: Justice League Season Two - July 26th
 
Great news! Been waiting/hoping for them to continue with the series on blu. Now if we can get them to finish releasing other DC Comics shows on dvd such as Legion of Superheroes, Static Shock, and Zeta Project I'd be happy!!

GenPion 04-10-11 10:47 AM

Re: Justice League Season Two - July 26th
 
I'm definitely going to get this. I had actually lost a lot of hope in seeing this find a release. Just the other day I was talking about the series and the lack of a S2 Blu-ray release with my sister.

Surfinhank 04-10-11 07:58 PM

Re: Justice League Season Two - July 26th
 

Originally Posted by milo bloom (Post 10717486)
Until they fix season one in 16x9 widescreen, I'm not interested.

Uh.. season one wasn't broadcast 16x9, it was 4x3......

GenPion 04-10-11 08:28 PM

Re: Justice League Season Two - July 26th
 

Originally Posted by Surfinhank (Post 10718882)
Uh.. season one wasn't broadcast 16x9, it was 4x3......

Season 1 was framed with a widescreen presentation in mind, and to my recollection Cartoon Network aired it in both full frame and widescreen at different times. However, an anamorphic presentation was never produced and both the original DVD release and Blu-ray release were presented in full frame only. Technically, both presentations are the correct OAR but the intended ratio was always Widescreen.

milo bloom 04-10-11 10:22 PM

Re: Justice League Season Two - July 26th
 

Originally Posted by Surfinhank (Post 10718882)
Uh.. season one wasn't broadcast 16x9, it was 4x3......

I've had to keep this link in my bookmarks for several years now.
http://jl.toonzone.net/widescreen/widescreen.htm

It clearly shows how the show was meant to be. The 4x3 presentation was always a compromise by the creators to the network hesitant to go widescreen. The WS repeats did such good numbers that season 2 and on were produced widescreen only. I have no doubt WB will produce 16x9 transfers of the season 1 eps when they absolutely have to have them for future syndication or whatever, so I'm content to wait until that happens.

Surfinhank 04-13-11 01:38 AM

Re: Justice League Season Two - July 26th
 
That's a cool article. I'm a widescreen supporter all the way, but I kinda agree with this guy's opinion in this case:

"...others (like myself) found the widescreen versions to be distracting, as the black bars omitted almost a quarter of the screen...material that my mind knew was there in the standard edition (I know that the storyboard artists kept the top and bottom of each shot free of important information, but it still bugged me)"

I love this show and I think season 1 looks amazing on Blu-ray. I can't imagine waiting for how ever many years it might take for them to release a widescreen version, especially when you do have to consider the fact that they may never release it.

milo bloom 04-13-11 02:27 PM

Re: Justice League Season Two - July 26th
 
Sorry, I look at those 4x3 images and I see a lot of sky and feet. The widescreen matting pushes your focus on eyelines of the characters and tightens the staging of action scenes. They knew what they were doing, WB doesn't.

fumanstan 04-13-11 03:34 PM

Re: Justice League Season Two - July 26th
 

Originally Posted by milo bloom (Post 10723385)
Sorry, I look at those 4x3 images and I see a lot of sky and feet. The widescreen matting pushes your focus on eyelines of the characters and tightens the staging of action scenes. They knew what they were doing, WB doesn't.

For Season 1? I see some heads being cut off in some shots.

milo bloom 04-14-11 10:55 AM

Re: Justice League Season Two - July 26th
 

Originally Posted by fumanstan (Post 10723507)
For Season 1? I see some heads being cut off in some shots.

Do you mean the screenshots in the link I posted? Mostly foreheads from what I'm seeing, plus, these are still frames of dynamic shots.

The best example is that second shot from the left, the one with all the heroes standing in a line. Seriously, look at the shot, then hold some pieces of paper or something to your screen to matte off the top and bottom and tell me that doesn't go from "tv" to "cinema" just like that.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:55 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.