DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   HD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk-55/)
-   -   The Good The Bad And The Weird -- 8/17/10 (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk/574334-good-bad-weird-8-17-10-a.html)

riotinmyskull 05-26-10 04:45 PM

The Good The Bad The Weird -- 8/17/10
 
http://i46.tinypic.com/1z3b9nb.jpg

http://www.amazon.com/Good-Weird-Blu...dp/B003NLE5J0/

Solid Snake 05-26-10 05:09 PM

Re: The Good The Bad And The Weird -- 8/17/10
 
mediocre cover hopefully it gets pretty good features.

Eric F 05-26-10 05:28 PM

Re: The Good The Bad And The Weird -- 8/17/10
 
It looks almost the same cover as the R2 release. At least it will be cheaper than importing it, which I was going to do anyways. I guess I'll wait now.

RocShemp 05-26-10 05:45 PM

Re: The Good The Bad And The Weird -- 8/17/10
 
Sweet. This'll be a blind buy for sure.

gryffinmaster 05-26-10 06:02 PM

Re: The Good The Bad And The Weird -- 8/17/10
 
I kept dodging a purchase for the Korean Blu-ray, so I suppose I'll just keep holding off until August for this one. Exciting!

Sessa17 05-26-10 06:14 PM

Re: The Good The Bad And The Weird -- 8/17/10
 
Hope it gets good PQ reviews. Been wanting to import this for a while & have been holding off.

Drav3n 05-26-10 07:07 PM

Re: The Good The Bad And The Weird -- 8/17/10
 
Im a fan of Song Kang-ho, so Ill probably pick this up...if it gets good reviews.

tylergfoster 05-26-10 11:19 PM

Re: The Good The Bad And The Weird -- 8/17/10
 
To be honest, I was pretty disappointed in this one. I was supposed to review it and didn't.

The action scenes are pretty good, but it just drags on and on. The final scene was just excruciating, as opposed to its namesake's excruciating tension.

Yavin 05-27-10 12:27 AM

Re: The Good The Bad And The Weird -- 8/17/10
 
This is awesome news. I saw this at the Toronto International Film Festival a couple of years ago, and the director did a Q&A session afterwards. Loved this film right away and have been waiting forever for a North American release. I thought it struck just the right balance between humor and action. I saw Sukiyaki Western Django a couple of months later, but didn't like it as much as this one. Hopefully Amazon.ca will be importing this.

nitin77 05-31-10 07:10 AM

Re: The Good The Bad And The Weird -- 8/17/10
 
hopefully this also has korean cut via seamless branching?

RocShemp 05-31-10 11:56 AM

Re: The Good The Bad And The Weird -- 8/17/10
 

Originally Posted by nitin77 (Post 10186753)
hopefully this also has korean cut via seamless branching?

I didn't know it was cut down in the US.


Originally Posted by manicsounds (Post 10186694)

I want that poster.

doctorthodt 05-31-10 06:07 PM

Re: The Good The Bad And The Weird -- 8/17/10
 
Gah. I paid $35 each for the Korean imports of this and Mother, and now they're both being released here.

Solid Snake 05-31-10 06:38 PM

Re: The Good The Bad And The Weird -- 8/17/10
 

Originally Posted by RocShemp (Post 10186973)
I didn't know it was cut down in the US.

Nor did I...now....I want this BD cautiously now...hrm....

nitin77 06-01-10 05:47 AM

Re: The Good The Bad And The Weird -- 8/17/10
 
Rocshemp,

there is an international version about 6-8 min shorter than the official korean version. AFAIK, the korean version is only available along with the international version on the 3 disc korean dvd (what I have) or on the japanese blu ray.

The korean blu and the UK blu are both the international version (although the UK is cut a little more for horse fall scenes).

Yavin 06-07-10 11:39 PM

Re: The Good The Bad And The Weird -- 8/17/10
 
Listings for this release (on Amazon and DVDEmpire) are giving it a runtime of 130 minutes, so it looks like this is the Korean version.

nitin77 06-08-10 04:44 AM

Re: The Good The Bad And The Weird -- 8/17/10
 
korean cut is approx 135 min I think. International cut is 130 min.

RocShemp 06-08-10 07:55 AM

Re: The Good The Bad And The Weird -- 8/17/10
 
Hmm. That blows. I guess I better google the Korean BD, just in case, to see if it's region A and has English subtitles.

manicsounds 06-08-10 08:32 AM

Re: The Good The Bad And The Weird -- 8/17/10
 

Originally Posted by RocShemp (Post 10200198)
Hmm. That blows. I guess I better google the Korean BD, just in case, to see if it's region A and has English subtitles.

Region free, and English subtitles for the main feature, but only includes the 129 minute version (Saving you from Googling...)

http://www.blu-ray.com/movies/The-Go...y/8476/#Review

Yavin 06-08-10 08:42 AM

Re: The Good The Bad And The Weird -- 8/17/10
 

Originally Posted by nitin77 (Post 10200095)
korean cut is approx 135 min I think. International cut is 130 min.

Sorry, I thought there were only two cuts, but actually it looks like there are three main ones:

Cannes Film Festival: 120 min
South Korea: 139 min
International: 130 min

I guess it could be worse. We could be getting the 120 min version. Does the International cut include the same ending as the Korean version?

Solid Snake 06-08-10 10:08 AM

Re: The Good The Bad And The Weird -- 8/17/10
 
So what was cut out and why? is this approved and/or preferred by the director?

manicsounds 06-08-10 08:32 PM

Re: The Good The Bad And The Weird -- 8/17/10
 
The Korean and International versions are both director approved. I personally like the Korean cut better as there are 2 scenes I like that were cut (The drug scene and the final explosion scene) and there are minor editing differences here and there.

Also, the Korean version has Korean titles and end credits while the International cut has English.

The ending itself is the same in both, but there are 4 alternate endings. (I liked the middle-finger one)

Solid Snake 06-08-10 09:24 PM

Re: The Good The Bad And The Weird -- 8/17/10
 
interesante...

nitin77 06-09-10 04:15 AM

Re: The Good The Bad And The Weird -- 8/17/10
 
quite a few cut bits in the international version, apparently they were deemed too "korean" for anyone else to notice or care. Personally, there is only omission of note which is towards the end (as manicsounds also alludes to).

I just dont understand why the option cant be presented via seamless branching like on the japanese BD

Boba Fett 06-20-10 12:03 AM

Re: The Good The Bad And The Weird -- 8/17/10
 
Just saw it tonight. One of the most boring, pointless, and sloppy action films I've ever seen.

nitin77 06-20-10 12:20 AM

Re: The Good The Bad And The Weird -- 8/17/10
 
I would disagree. Whilst I think it is only above average as an overall film, the (numerous) action scenes are filmed with more energy, verve and thrill than any action scenes that have come out of hollywood for quite some time.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:54 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.