DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   HD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk-55/)
-   -   Scream Blu Ray: AMAZING TRANSFER (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk/567704-scream-blu-ray-amazing-transfer.html)

indiansbsa 01-08-10 09:15 PM

Scream Blu Ray: AMAZING TRANSFER
 
The transfer for Scream on blu ray is fantastic. You can get it at amazon; its the australian release but it plays on our U.S. players. Not the unrated version, sadly, but thats only a second or two different of footage and not worth passing this up for. I got it for less than $25 from one of the marketplace sellers.

It could be a couple years till we get a U.S. release when Scream 4 comes out and this transfer is as good as it gets for this title in my opinion. DTS-HD 5.1 is a nice track too. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.

Surfinhank 01-09-10 01:13 AM

Re: Scream Blu Ray: AMAZING TRANSFER
 
Can I ask which seller you got it from? The cheapest at the moment is westendentertainment, but some of their feedback is questionable.

TheBigDave 01-09-10 01:56 AM

Re: Scream Blu Ray: AMAZING TRANSFER
 
I ordered from "blowitoutahere" because I wanted a US seller (westendentertainment is located in Australia). It arrived quickly and in excellent (NEW) condition, so I'd recommend them.

I'm happy with the blu-ray, but I wouldn't call it an amazing transfer. I don't think the print has been remastered in years. There was some noticeable dirt and damage on a few scenes, and I'm not one that usually notices that stuff. The blu-ray video is better than any DVD version currently out there, but I hope the eventual US release is better.

The disc is barebones. They could have at least ported over the commentary track. And it's the theatrical cut. I've seen the missing 10 seconds of footage, and it's not worth making a big deal over. But I'm glad to have a relatively good-looking anamorphic version.

asianxcore 01-09-10 05:51 AM

Re: Scream Blu Ray: AMAZING TRANSFER
 

Originally Posted by Surfinhank (Post 9932728)
Can I ask which seller you got it from? The cheapest at the moment is westendentertainment, but some of their feedback is questionable.

DiabolikDVD is a U.S company and is carrying the disc:

http://diabolikdvd.com/category/Horr...Region%29.html

indiansbsa 01-09-10 08:02 AM

Re: Scream Blu Ray: AMAZING TRANSFER
 

Originally Posted by TheBigDave (Post 9932749)
I ordered from "blowitoutahere" because I wanted a US seller (westendentertainment is located in Australia). It arrived quickly and in excellent (NEW) condition, so I'd recommend them.

I'm happy with the blu-ray, but I wouldn't call it an amazing transfer. I don't think the print has been remastered in years. There was some noticeable dirt and damage on a few scenes, and I'm not one that usually notices that stuff. The blu-ray video is better than any DVD version currently out there, but I hope the eventual US release is better.

The disc is barebones. They could have at least ported over the commentary track. And it's the theatrical cut. I've seen the missing 10 seconds of footage, and it's not worth making a big deal over. But I'm glad to have a relatively good-looking anamorphic version.

By SCREAM's standards, I thought it looked pretty fantastic- the dvd looked awful and I felt like 99.99% of the film looked like a new film on blu ray, which to me was just awesome. Ive seen the uncut footage too, its basically a few gorier seconds of Casey's boyfriend's guts spilling out. Not that important. On blu-ray.com a couple of members have reviewed it also- gave it a 4 out of 5 in terms of review on the video- so I think they agree (based on SCREAM's standards anyway). I used the outta here seller too and got very fast shipping from them- ie it delivered in less than a week. Obviously the lack of any extras is disappointing, but I'm okay rebuying the US release eventually if its done better at that point but it could be a couple years till Scream 4 and the domestic blu ray release of scream..

slimdude 01-09-10 09:15 AM

Re: Scream Blu Ray: AMAZING TRANSFER
 

Originally Posted by indiansbsa (Post 9932864)
By SCREAM's standards, I thought it looked pretty fantastic- the dvd looked awful and I felt like 99.99% of the film looked like a new film on blu ray, which to me was just awesome.

Scream was never released with a anamorphic transfer on DVD, so the Blu-ray will be worth the upgrade, considering that fact itself, including its High Definition A/V presentation. I'll wait for the U.S release of this title because, it's going to be quite expensive to have it imported from another country with additional surcharges to the actual item as well.

GenPion 01-09-10 01:33 PM

Re: Scream Blu Ray: AMAZING TRANSFER
 
I want this, but am wondering what the resale value will look like if a U.S. trilogy set comes out eventually. This is one of my favorite movies and the DVD is crap (which is why I never purchased it). I mean, come on... non-anamorphic for one of the greatest horror films of all time?

I may have to get this when I get some more "funds".

HumanMedia 01-09-10 07:38 PM

Re: Scream Blu Ray: AMAZING TRANSFER
 

Originally Posted by slimdude (Post 9932926)
Scream was never released with a anamorphic transfer on DVD, so the Blu-ray will be worth the upgrade, considering that fact itself, including its High Definition A/V presentation. I'll wait for the U.S release of this title because, it's going to be quite expensive to have it imported from another country with additional surcharges to the actual item as well.

Never in anamorphic in the USA.

The German DVD is very good, anamorphic with some good extras.

AmityBoatTours 01-09-10 09:02 PM

Re: Scream Blu Ray: AMAZING TRANSFER
 
its actually readily availble in the us, you can order it from bestbuy.com or amazon.com/ I preorderd it from bestbuy.com back in November when they had those really good 30 % off all bluray sales. i picked it up from them for 20.99 plus 2.99 for shipping. amazon at one point had it for 22.49 though its now on there for 33.99 and bestbuy.com(not instore) its currently 34.99
http://www.bestbuy.com/site/Scream+-...7342&st=scream


Originally Posted by slimdude (Post 9932926)
Scream was never released with a anamorphic transfer on DVD, so the Blu-ray will be worth the upgrade, considering that fact itself, including its High Definition A/V presentation. I'll wait for the U.S release of this title because, it's going to be quite expensive to have it imported from another country with additional surcharges to the actual item as well.


slimdude 01-09-10 09:41 PM

Re: Scream Blu Ray: AMAZING TRANSFER
 

Originally Posted by HumanMedia (Post 9933782)
Never in anamorphic in the USA.

The German DVD is very good, anamorphic with some good extras.

I don't have a Region Free DVD Player, so generally I don't keep up with international DVD releases.

RickWJ324 01-10-10 08:57 AM

Re: Scream Blu Ray: AMAZING TRANSFER
 
I ordered the Scream Trilogy (from Austria) on Blu-ray recently. Just waiting for it to arrive. Can't wait to watch these flicks again. It's been a while.

Rick

BankytheHack 01-10-10 11:12 AM

Re: Scream Blu Ray: AMAZING TRANSFER
 
I wasn't terribly impressed with this BD release of SCREAM. PQ was ok, but there was quite a bit of dirt present. I also felt that the DTS-MA track was very lacking. It was all over the place. Music surrounds were pretty good, but other times the sound was very low, or "hollow" (such as the part when the porch chair crashes through the glass doors). Maybe it was just my receiver (which doesn't decode DTS-MA anyhow), but I'm doubting it.

GenPion 01-10-10 11:21 AM

Re: Scream Blu Ray: AMAZING TRANSFER
 
How much is the set? Are they all region free? I want the details...

RickWJ324 01-10-10 02:35 PM

Re: Scream Blu Ray: AMAZING TRANSFER
 

Originally Posted by GenPion (Post 9934573)
How much is the set? Are they all region free? I want the details...

Yes.. they are region free. I don't have them yet, but they have shipped. Will post the specs on them once I've had a chance to review. I've read some reviews that state SCREAM 1 in the Austrian release is theatrical, while others have claimed its the directors cut.

Importing the set isn't cheap. I think it cost me around 80 bucks for the set of 3 movies. More than I would normally spend on blu's, but I really wanted to check this set out.

TheBigDave 01-10-10 03:04 PM

Re: Scream Blu Ray: AMAZING TRANSFER
 
Here's a review of the Kinowelt box set.

http://www.cinefacts.de/blu-ray-revi...-trilogie.html

If you don't speak German you'll need the Babelfish translation:

http://babelfish.yahoo.com/translate...rUrl=Translate

It says that Scream 2 is cropped from 2.35:1 to 1.78:1.

GenPion 01-10-10 04:28 PM

Re: Scream Blu Ray: AMAZING TRANSFER
 
Wow... cropped. That sucks. I am definitely not interested in the set if that's the case. Scream being anamorphic and in the correct ratio, with the same cut as the U.S. theatrical will make it worthwhile though.

Josh-da-man 01-11-10 05:51 AM

Re: Scream Blu Ray: AMAZING TRANSFER
 
Am I holding out too much hope for Disney/Miramax/Dimension to release the unrated cut on Blu?

indiansbsa 01-11-10 08:35 AM

Re: Scream Blu Ray: AMAZING TRANSFER
 

Originally Posted by Josh-da-man (Post 9936180)
Am I holding out too much hope for Disney/Miramax/Dimension to release the unrated cut on Blu?

Yep.

The Monkees 01-11-10 01:09 PM

Re: Scream Blu Ray: AMAZING TRANSFER
 

Originally Posted by TheBigDave (Post 9935070)
]It says that Scream 2 is cropped from 2.35:1 to 1.78:1.

Well there goes my interest :mad2:

Giles 01-11-10 02:15 PM

Re: Scream Blu Ray: AMAZING TRANSFER
 

Originally Posted by indiansbsa (Post 9936298)
Yep.

me too since it'd be nice to have the commentary track too.

Surfinhank 01-22-10 12:07 AM

Re: Scream Blu Ray: AMAZING TRANSFER
 
I got my copy of Scream today and just finished watching it. I know PAL speed-up is supposedly no longer an issue with Blu-ray, but didn't anybody notice that the audio is off on this release? The pitch is too high. Everyone sounds a little like Mickey Mouse. It's the same problem as the UK release of The Fog. When I first got that one someone suggested it might be an up-scaled PAL master, but the U.S. DVD stays in perfect sync with the Blu-ray. It sounds like PAL speed-up even though it isn't. Does anybody have any insight as to what causes this to happen?

The Monkees 01-22-10 01:28 PM

Re: Scream Blu Ray: AMAZING TRANSFER
 

Originally Posted by Surfinhank (Post 9956723)
I got my copy of Scream today and just finished watching it. I know PAL speed-up is supposedly no longer an issue with Blu-ray, but didn't anybody notice that the audio is off on this release? The pitch is too high. Everyone sounds a little like Mickey Mouse. It's the same problem as the UK release of The Fog. When I first got that one someone suggested it might be an up-scaled PAL master, but the U.S. DVD stays in perfect sync with the Blu-ray. It sounds like PAL speed-up even though it isn't. Does anybody have any insight as to what causes this to happen?

Well that makes me wanted it even LESS

Eric D. 01-22-10 04:16 PM

Re: Scream Blu Ray: AMAZING TRANSFER
 
I hope that PAL speed-up thing isn't true considering I have a copy on the way. Does anybody else have the same problem?

bunkaroo 01-22-10 04:45 PM

Re: Scream Blu Ray: AMAZING TRANSFER
 
I got a couple Blu-ray's from France last year that had the correct length but still sounded pitched up. It's almost as if it was done deliberately.

GenPion 01-22-10 07:36 PM

Re: Scream Blu Ray: AMAZING TRANSFER
 
Well, forget it then... I'll just wait for a U.S. release. Total bummer.

Darth Maher 01-22-10 09:13 PM

Re: Scream Blu Ray: AMAZING TRANSFER
 
They are probably trying to capitalize on the success of the Chipmunks sequel.

Surfinhank 01-22-10 09:27 PM

Re: Scream Blu Ray: AMAZING TRANSFER
 

Originally Posted by bunkaroo (Post 9957941)
I got a couple Blu-ray's from France last year that had the correct length but still sounded pitched up. It's almost as if it was done deliberately.

Now see, why would they do that? It has to be some error in the transfer, right?

Paul Arnette 01-22-10 11:00 PM

Re: Scream Blu Ray: AMAZING TRANSFER
 
I just finished watching this. While I can't say for certain there's a pitch issue, I can tell you my copy has what appears to be an encoding error at around 1:37.21. For about a second, there was a black and white checkerboard pattern, and it was repeatable.

Between the potential pitch issue and this, I can't recommend this disc even though aside the possible encoding problem and some print damage the transfer is quite strong.

RickWJ324 01-24-10 07:05 AM

Re: Scream Blu Ray: AMAZING TRANSFER
 
I can't speak for the Australian release, but my trilogy set from Austria does not have the "pal speedup" issue. Also, from what I've read, there are two different boxed sets and they contain two different versions of Scream 1. One is the true Theatrical Cut and the other is an 'Edited Theatrical Cut'. Mine is definitely the full theatrical cut... no edits. Picture looks great and there are no sound issues.

Scream 2 is definitely cropped to 1.78:1. However, when I watched it I didn't feel distracted by it. It was a very nice transfer of the film. I hadn't seen that one is so long I had forgotten who the killer(s) were, so it was nice to watch it again. :)

I haven't watched Part 3 yet from the set. As far as I know it is in the proper aspect ratio. I'm sure it will look as good as the first two.

Of course if a proper US release is made, I'll buy them. Until then, this is a great set to watch. I own the dvd's, including the Unrated Director's Cut of the first one, but the blu-rays are a definite improvement over the dvd's, especially considering Scream 1 on dvd isn't anamorphic!!

Rick


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:47 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.