Lord of The Rings on Blu-Ray in 2010!
10-09-08, 10:01 PM
#76
DVD Talk Legend
Ok I think I got it now 
..........Ok one thing I want to clarify and the whole reason this all got started is? ........... Could (or will) there be a difference in sound quality between the DTS version of the LOTR trilogy I have now and IF they come out with a TrueHD or DTS-HD/MA version on BD?
..........Ok one thing I want to clarify and the whole reason this all got started is? ........... Could (or will) there be a difference in sound quality between the DTS version of the LOTR trilogy I have now and IF they come out with a TrueHD or DTS-HD/MA version on BD?
11-12-08, 10:59 AM
#78
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
I'm happy to be proved wrong, but I'll be surprised if the films debut in anything other than the Theatrical cuts. I'll bet a lot of people who say they wouldn't buy the Theatrical would cave if it was the only game in Blu town.
Then after a decent interval, they'll sell us the extended. It worked for them on DVD, and it'll work for them again on Blu. Why sell us a movie once rather than twice?
But I'll be happy to be wrong!
Then after a decent interval, they'll sell us the extended. It worked for them on DVD, and it'll work for them again on Blu. Why sell us a movie once rather than twice?
But I'll be happy to be wrong!
Originally Posted by TheDigitalBits
Finally, our industry sources have hinted to us that when Warner delivers The Lord of the Rings films on Blu-ray Disc, some time late next year, they will very likely be the original theatrical versions. But don't freak out and run off to start a petition or something. There's good reason for it: Word is that director Peter Jackson wants to save the Extended Editions for an elaborate and ultimate Blu-ray box set release closer to the debut of the new Hobbit films in theatres. This way, as was the case with the previous DVD releases, you'll eventually get both versions and the best will be saved for last.
11-12-08, 12:46 PM
#83
DVD Talk Legend
I won't even rent them. There's just no point for me anymore. The EE's are the films I love, and it would be too jarring to see the films with all that stuff cut. I haven't watched the TE's since they all came out on DVD before each respective EE.
11-12-08, 12:51 PM
#84
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Nov 2008
Posts: 1,609
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
11-12-08, 12:52 PM
#85
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Nov 2008
Posts: 1,609
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I feel the same- and I haven't watched the TE's since the theatrical first-run.
11-12-08, 12:52 PM
#86
DVD Talk Special Edition
11-12-08, 03:36 PM
#87
DVD Talk Special Edition
Blu-Ray.com is reporting
Our good friend Bill Hunt is at it again, and today he has more information regarding the upcoming release of the 'Lord of the Rings' films. This bad news is that when Warner delivers the films sometime late next year, they will be of the theatrical versions of the films. The good news is that this decision was made because director Peter Jackson wants to save the extended versions for a super Blu-ray boxset to be released near the theatrical release of 'The Hobbit'.
With the original extended cut box sets being of the utmost quality, I have high hopes that Jackson will once again produce a magnificent Blu-ray box set for the extended cuts of the film. Until then (which will be about two years if 'The Hobbit' stays on schedule, enjoy the theatricals cuts on Blu-ray sometime next year.
Our good friend Bill Hunt is at it again, and today he has more information regarding the upcoming release of the 'Lord of the Rings' films. This bad news is that when Warner delivers the films sometime late next year, they will be of the theatrical versions of the films. The good news is that this decision was made because director Peter Jackson wants to save the extended versions for a super Blu-ray boxset to be released near the theatrical release of 'The Hobbit'.
With the original extended cut box sets being of the utmost quality, I have high hopes that Jackson will once again produce a magnificent Blu-ray box set for the extended cuts of the film. Until then (which will be about two years if 'The Hobbit' stays on schedule, enjoy the theatricals cuts on Blu-ray sometime next year.
11-12-08, 04:02 PM
#89
DVD Talk Limited Edition
HD is nice, but I'd prefer the DVD EEs over a shiny blu-ray Theatricals. Humbug!!!
11-12-08, 04:56 PM
#90
Banned by request
Am I alone in preferring the theatrical cuts of Fellowship and Return? I'll buy all three theatricals and all three extended cuts when they come out on Blu-ray. It's Lord of the Rings.
11-12-08, 05:04 PM
#91
DVD Talk Legend
Yes you might be right be of what I've heard on my system it sounds better(IE: compared Batman Begins)........But I do kind agree with of some of it........ but I think alot has to do with the transfer.........for example IMO I am hard-pressed to find a movie tranfer better than LOTR Trilogy especially Fellowship of the Rings(in DTS of course ) also I think Titanic is a reference disc also....The audio and video transfer on these are excellent! Fellowship will rival any TrueHD I have ...only way to compare is if they come out with it in TrueHD or MA then I could compare ......
Well for me there aren't many movies I would re-buy on BD especially at the prices they sell them for now!
I haven't even bought a BD player yet. There is no movie I have to see that bad to pay $299! for a player(stand alone for me). I am looking to try to take advantage of the Sony CC offer($150 off) and get the 350 for $150 That I can handle
To each their own.........I like the audio portion of these movies and would love to here LOTR in 7.1 (true 7.1)
) also I think Titanic is a reference disc also....The audio and video transfer on these are excellent! Fellowship will rival any TrueHD I have ...only way to compare is if they come out with it in TrueHD or MA then I could compare ...... Well for me there aren't many movies I would re-buy on BD especially at the prices they sell them for now!
I haven't even bought a BD player yet. There is no movie I have to see that bad to pay $299! for a player(stand alone for me). I am looking to try to take advantage of the Sony CC offer($150 off) and get the 350 for $150
That I can handle To each their own.........I like the audio portion of these movies and would love to here LOTR in 7.1
(true 7.1)
11-12-08, 07:46 PM
#93
DVD Talk Reviewer
I hope nobody in here complains. We got the theatricals well in advance on DVD before the extendeds, but it was cool they let us know what was coming. Now again, they are letting us know the extendeds are coming eventually... so make your choice, and nobody can complain later on that they had no idea the extended cuts were going to eventually come.
I'm disappointed I can't get them off the bat but, at least this information is up front here and now.
I'm disappointed I can't get them off the bat but, at least this information is up front here and now.
11-12-08, 09:01 PM
#95
DVD Talk Legend
I hope nobody in here complains. We got the theatricals well in advance on DVD before the extendeds, but it was cool they let us know what was coming. Now again, they are letting us know the extendeds are coming eventually... so make your choice, and nobody can complain later on that they had no idea the extended cuts were going to eventually come.
I'm disappointed I can't get them off the bat but, at least this information is up front here and now.
I'm disappointed I can't get them off the bat but, at least this information is up front here and now.
11-12-08, 09:49 PM
#97
DVD Talk Legend
I hope nobody in here complains. We got the theatricals well in advance on DVD before the extendeds, but it was cool they let us know what was coming. Now again, they are letting us know the extendeds are coming eventually... so make your choice, and nobody can complain later on that they had no idea the extended cuts were going to eventually come.
I'm disappointed I can't get them off the bat but, at least this information is up front here and now.
I'm disappointed I can't get them off the bat but, at least this information is up front here and now.
Also, I wouldn't say three months (seven for ROTK) was well in advance - just my opinion.
FOTR and TTT TE's came out in late August, followed by their respective EE's in November of the same year. ROTK TE came out in May but the EE wasn't until December. We're talking about a much longer wait until the Blu EE's.
11-13-08, 09:14 AM
#100
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Join Date: Jun 2002
Posts: 8,487
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts