DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   HD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk-55/)
-   -   Wall-E 11/18! (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk/537889-wall-e-11-18-a.html)

ASAPadam 11-13-08 07:56 AM

Is it weird that High-Def Digest's review doesn't mention "The Pixar Story" being included?

http://bluray.highdefdigest.com/1729/walle.html

Vipper II 11-13-08 09:02 AM


Originally Posted by ASAPadam (Post 9069513)
Is it weird that High-Def Digest's review doesn't mention "The Pixar Story" being included?

http://bluray.highdefdigest.com/1729/walle.html

HDD's reviews aren't usually a model of accuracy, unless Zyber is the reviewer.

Gizmo 11-13-08 10:02 AM

Justin over at HDDNews can't find the feature either


This does not contain “The Pixar Story” like the DVD 3-Disc release does. I’ve looked endlessly all over Disc 1 and Disc 2 of this and it’s nowhere to be found despite the back of the box claiming it is included. Thank goodness for this containing BD-Live so they can add it maybe later this year. This is a MUST-SEE featurette and should have been included here. It runs well over an hour in length.
As for the HDD Review...that reviewer is known to gloss over features or review things not even on the disc.

Giles 11-13-08 10:11 AM

that's very odd, since the dvdbeaver review says it's on Disc 2, I hope it isn't a 3-disc edition exclusive. It's too bad the 'Presto' short isn't in HiDef.

applesandrice 11-13-08 10:14 AM


Originally Posted by Giles (Post 9069766)
It's too bad the 'Presto' short isn't in HiDef.

Ralph Potts at AVS lists it as being HD . . .

Giles 11-13-08 10:24 AM


Originally Posted by applesandrice (Post 9069769)
Ralph Potts at AVS lists it as being HD . . .


seems to be a bit of misinformation (or the lackthereof) on some of these online reviews... -ohbfrank-

Gizmo 11-13-08 10:47 AM


Originally Posted by Giles (Post 9069766)
that's very odd, since the dvdbeaver review says it's on Disc 2, I hope it isn't a 3-disc edition exclusive. It's too bad the 'Presto' short isn't in HiDef.

The 3 disc set is the only version being sent out to reviewers...but the 2 disc should be identical except its missing disc 3 (Digital Copy) and slip cover. It is possible the feature is on Disc 3 (like how the DC copy of Hellboy II has features). I'll check this out tonight when I go home.

ASAPadam 11-13-08 08:00 PM


Originally Posted by ASAPadam (Post 9069513)
Is it weird that High-Def Digest's review doesn't mention "The Pixar Story" being included?

http://bluray.highdefdigest.com/1729/walle.html

The review has been updated to add "The Pixar Story"! Turns out the reviewer overlooked it.

Mr. Cinema 11-14-08 08:18 AM

My Amazon.com order status has changed to "shipping soon". :thumbsup: Looks like I'll have this on release day.

aktick 11-14-08 09:13 AM


Originally Posted by Mr. Cinema (Post 9071796)
My Amazon.com order status has changed to "shipping soon". :thumbsup: Looks like I'll have this on release day.

Mine just shipped. :) Expected to arrive here Wednesday, which is fine with me.

rexinnih 11-14-08 02:43 PM


Originally Posted by GizmoDVD (Post 9069845)
The 3 disc set is the only version being sent out to reviewers...but the 2 disc should be identical except its missing disc 3 (Digital Copy) and slip cover. It is possible the feature is on Disc 3 (like how the DC copy of Hellboy II has features). I'll check this out tonight when I go home.

Gizmo,

Please confirm this for us when you get a chance. I definately want the Pixar story and want to make sure I order the right (2 disc vs. 3 disc) set. Thanks!

Drexl 11-14-08 02:49 PM

Wait a minute though. The digital copy must be on a DVD, because they figure that few people have BD-ROM drives to use to get the DC. If The Pixar Story is in HD, it must be on a BD.

Gizmo 11-14-08 03:40 PM


Originally Posted by rexinnih (Post 9072763)
Gizmo,

Please confirm this for us when you get a chance. I definately want the Pixar story and want to make sure I order the right (2 disc vs. 3 disc) set. Thanks!

Ill check tonight when I get home. Plan on finally sitting down to watch this one.

rexinnih 11-14-08 05:55 PM


Originally Posted by GizmoDVD (Post 9072900)
Ill check tonight when I get home. Plan on finally sitting down to watch this one.

Thanks! I'll have to live vicariously through you until I can pick mine up. C'mon Tuesday! :)

Supermallet 11-14-08 08:47 PM

Mine shipped today from Amazon. Maybe by some miracle it'll show up tomorrow, but more likely on Monday.

Gizmo 11-14-08 10:29 PM


Originally Posted by rexinnih (Post 9073179)
Thanks! I'll have to live vicariously through you until I can pick mine up. C'mon Tuesday! :)

Its on Disc 2 in HD.

When you select "Humans" and scroll all the way down you will see it. Its an Hour and 28 Minutes...not bad.

Gizmo 11-14-08 10:30 PM


Originally Posted by Suprmallet (Post 9073424)
Mine shipped today from Amazon. Maybe by some miracle it'll show up tomorrow, but more likely on Monday.

How is that even possible for Amazon? Ive never once had them ship a Tuesday BD release on Friday (its always ships Monday for me). Is this date being pushed up? Did you select Overnight or standard Prime?

Supermallet 11-14-08 10:54 PM

How is that possible? No idea. I have the regular Prime 2-day shipping.

fumanstan 11-14-08 11:11 PM

Mine shipped from Amazon too. Scheduled date is Tuesday though.

MichaelMeyers 11-14-08 11:49 PM

Mine shipped from Amazon today as well too. Can't wait to check this one out as I missed it in the theater.

kms_md 11-15-08 07:44 AM

mine shipped as well - if usual shipping times apply, i should have it by tuesday.

Gizmo 11-15-08 10:56 AM

Wow...wonder if Amazon is working on getting Day and Dates to people by release date for now on.

Mr. Cinema 11-15-08 11:07 AM

I also received a shipping notice yesterday.

XavierMike 11-15-08 01:57 PM

Ditto

Hammer99 11-15-08 02:04 PM

Mine didn't ship yet, maybe because I'm getting the 2-disc version?


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:46 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.