DVD Talk Forum - My A35 is now basically a paperweight

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)

- HD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk-55/)

- - My A35 is now basically a paperweight (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk/535920-my-a35-now-basically-paperweight.html)

That's cool, at least you're getting a new one. Doing the FW update is easy as pie. Just pop the disc in, let it do it's thing then power it on.

Quote:

Originally Posted by alan smithee (Post 8889671)

bourne identity may be the equivalent of the atari <s>"combat"</s> <b>"pac-man"</b> cartridge.

:up:

Quote:

Originally Posted by bunkaroo (Post 8864108)

IMO most LD players were likely built better than the A2's and A3's that would be most common on Ebay and such. That's why I made sure I got my hands on an XA2.

My experience with Toshiba player models originally priced under $300 (both HD DVD and non-HD DVD) has been less than stellar. No way I'd rely on a third-party used or refurb A2 or A3 for my collection. My retired A1 probably has a better shot at longevity given the build quality.

I was looking at picking up an A35 or XA2. You can save a little money by getting the A35 but is the build quality far superior on the XA2? I just want to get on that will last if possible.

Quote:

Originally Posted by brianluvdvd (Post 8916237)

I was looking at picking up an A35 or XA2. You can save a little money by getting the A35 but is the build quality far superior on the XA2? I just want to get on that will last if possible.

I have to tell you my personal recollection is I've read more negative than positive things about all the 3rd-gen boxes WRT disc read issues.

Besides the XA2 having what is considered by many as one of the best upconversion processes, the thing is built very well. You can't really tell from the photos. I have an A20 which feels like a toy, and at first glance in pics the XA2 looks very similar. But the XA2 has some real heft to it. Not the heavier equals better mind you :), but it feels more durable, that's for sure.

Even though I have an A20 and A1 in the proverbial "closet", if my XA2 goes down I will still try and seek another one out, as I would hate to rely on the A20 or A1 long-term. As far as the A2 or A3, I'll just say IMO you get what you pay for.

My XA2 ia up for sale if anyone is interested.

Quote:

Originally Posted by gizmodvd (Post 8916535)

my xa2 ia up for sale if anyone is interested.

ygm

Quote:

Originally Posted by GizmoDVD (Post 8916535)

My XA2 ia up for sale if anyone is interested.

What changed your mind about keeping it?

I have two LG 200's. Kinda promised the wife I would get rid of the XA2 if she bought me a second LG 200 (and she did!) for the bedroom. Yeah, I compromised :lol: . The upconversion between the two is minor, though the Reon still looks nicer and I liked the remote better.

Regardless, I still have like a dozen other HD DVD players so it's no huge deal.

Ahh OK - just surprised at the XA2 being replaced by the 200, but it does make sense from a convenience standpoint.

Well I'll give Toshiba kudos. Although it took awhile to get things squared away with customer service, a new A35 showed up via FedEx today. It was brand new in a retail box complete with remote, manuals and 2 free movies (I already have them so they're for trade). So hopefully this one will be better with those pesky combo discs. I still have my A3 which I am going to put in the bedroom with a as yet unpurchased HDTV and now I picked up that Venturer for $60 from BUY.com which I'll throw in the closet as a back-up.