DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   HD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk-55/)
-   -   questions regarding blu ray for my presentation (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk/528907-questions-regarding-blu-ray-my-presentation.html)

technewb 04-05-08 04:28 PM

questions regarding blu ray for my presentation
 
Ok. I am completely new to the blue ray technology and I know that all the information i possibly need is all here, but I am in a very bad time crunch. The questions im about to ask are very repetitive im sure but I have a presentation coming up and I dont really have time to weed through all the scattered information. If you could answer any of my questions or have any input, it would be greatly appreciated.

I am doing a presentation on an article about toshiba surrending hd-dvd and blu-ray coming out on top. This is for my strategic management class (business mgt. major) and I will be using Porter's five forces as a base for my presentation. A few questions I had are....

1) Time Warner switched to support blu ray, which was the main reason for toshiba dropping hd-dvd. What are the main causes for blu-ray to get such great support? I am only aware that the only major difference was the size of the dvds were larger with blu ray. I read that it might be because of royalties and blu ray has much better security features that will prevent china from illegally distributing. Is that true?

2) Can you burn blu ray dvds? What kind of security features does blu ray have?

3) Why did blu ray come out on top? Anything to do with marketing? It seems to me that blu ray and hd dvd were on level playing fields.

4)Why are people shelling out the money for blue ray? You can get an upconverter for under 100 bucks and it seems that the difference in quality is minimal. Do all dvds upconvert?

5) Blu ray defeated hd dvd. What now? What else are they competing against? Upconverters? Cable/satellite are showing movies in high def and i think some websites are going to directly stream movies in high def. Is this true?

6) Does blu ray now have a monopoly? I read that there are 10 companies producing blu ray but a month after tobshiba dropped out, blu ray prices increased 10%.

7) technology is changing so fast, do you think majority of people will switch over to blu ray? Many people are waiting for the right price but do you think something better could come out and take out blu ray? How long do you think blu ray will have this technological advantage?

Please answer the questions from a business stand point. I am not here to take sides or anything. ( im actually looking to purchase a blu ray player for my dads birthday to put into his media room) Im looking for unbiased answers. Any extra input or important things that I might add in to my presentation; feel free to throw out there.

PopcornTreeCt 04-05-08 04:55 PM


Originally Posted by technewb
1) Time Warner switched to support blu ray, which was the main reason for toshiba dropping hd-dvd. What are the main causes for blu-ray to get such great support? I am only aware that the only major difference was the size of the dvds were larger with blu ray. I read that it might be because of royalties and blu ray has much better security features that will prevent china from illegally distributing. Is that true?

Blu-ray won because it sold more Blu-ray players and software. Blu-ray discs have more space but that's almost a non-factor because studios love doubling up on discs anyway.

2) Can you burn blu ray dvds? What kind of security features does blu ray have?

I read recently that blu-ray security has been hacked. You can/will be able to burn blu-ray discs.

3) Why did blu ray come out on top? Anything to do with marketing? It seems to me that blu ray and hd dvd were on level playing fields.

Blu-ray won because of the PS3. They also had better marketing but HD DVD had the name recognition advantage. Seriously, what the hell does the term "blu-ray" have anything to do with High Definition?

4)Why are people shelling out the money for blue ray? You can get an upconverter for under 100 bucks and it seems that the difference in quality is minimal. Do all dvds upconvert?

The difference in quality is not minimal. If you own a 1080i/1080p HD TV the difference is huge. People are shelling out money for blu-ray because it's the only option at this point even though since the war blu-ray players have gone up in price. Yes, all official non-bootleg dvds upconvert.

5) Blu ray defeated hd dvd. What now? What else are they competing against? Upconverters? Cable/satellite are showing movies in high def and i think some websites are going to directly stream movies in high def. Is this true?

DVD is the biggest competitor to Blu-ray. HD download movies are a ways off before they catch on but they will certainly be fierce competition when they become the norm.

6) Does blu ray now have a monopoly? I read that there are 10 companies producing blu ray but a month after tobshiba dropped out, blu ray prices increased 10%.

Blu-ray has a monopoly on high definition physical media. But I can still download HD movies. It's a monopoly in a sense but certainly not like Microsoft or anything.

7) technology is changing so fast, do you think majority of people will switch over to blu ray? Many people are waiting for the right price but do you think something better could come out and take out blu ray? How long do you think blu ray will have this technological advantage?

No, I don't think the majority of people will switch over to Blu-ray. Yes, Blu-rays can look significantly better than upgraded DVDs but not enough for most to drop $400 on it and rebuy all their favorite movies.

Please answer the questions from a business stand point. I am not here to take sides or anything. ( im actually looking to purchase a blu ray player for my dads birthday to put into his media room) Im looking for unbiased answers. Any extra input or important things that I might add in to my presentation; feel free to throw out there.

Other things I might add is about the studio support and the bidding wars that Toshiba and Sony both had fighting over the studios. If you have a HD TV then Blu-ray is the way to go. Gotta get the PS3 though.

technewb 04-05-08 05:09 PM


Originally Posted by PopcornTreeCt
Other things I might add is about the studio support and the bidding wars that Toshiba and Sony both had fighting over the studios. If you have a HD TV then Blu-ray is the way to go. Gotta get the PS3 though.

great point. I will difinitely look into the bidding wars, that is a key point. Thank you.

Josh Z 04-05-08 05:09 PM


Originally Posted by technewb
1) Time Warner switched to support blu ray, which was the main reason for toshiba dropping hd-dvd. What are the main causes for blu-ray to get such great support? I am only aware that the only major difference was the size of the dvds were larger with blu ray. I read that it might be because of royalties and blu ray has much better security features that will prevent china from illegally distributing. Is that true?

The Blu-ray Disc Association spent more money to secure exclusivity agreements from more of the major Hollywood movie studios than the HD DVD Promotional Group did. They also spent more money securing exclusivity agreements from more retailers than the HD DVD PRG did. Once Warner Bros had left, followed by Netflix, Blockbuster, and Walmart, that put HD DVD into an untenable position. Toshiba had no choice but to concede defeat. They had less content to sell and fewer places to sell it at.


3) Why did blu ray come out on top? Anything to do with marketing? It seems to me that blu ray and hd dvd were on level playing fields.
It was all about marketing. The two formats were virtually indistinguishable in terms of video, audio, and bonus content, but the BDA did a better job promoting their format.


4)Why are people shelling out the money for blue ray? You can get an upconverter for under 100 bucks and it seems that the difference in quality is minimal.
The difference is not minimal. High Definition has 6x the resolution of DVD.


Do all dvds upconvert?
Upconversion is not magic. If picture detail isn't present on the disc, it won't be present on your screen. All upconversion does is fill in the empty spaces between pixels by copying parts of those pixels. It cannot create real detail.

Take a high-resolution digital photo. In Photoshop, scale it down to 1/6 of its original resolution, then scale that back up. Compare your new picture to the original and see which looks better.


5) Blu ray defeated hd dvd. What now? What else are they competing against? Upconverters? Cable/satellite are showing movies in high def and i think some websites are going to directly stream movies in high def. Is this true?
Blu-ray now must compete against DVD, cable, Video-on-Demand, and downloading.


6) Does blu ray now have a monopoly? I read that there are 10 companies producing blu ray but a month after tobshiba dropped out, blu ray prices increased 10%.
Blu-ray only has a monopoly on pre-recorded High Definition media. It must still compete against all of the forces listed in the last question. If it wants to survive, it must remain competitive.


7) technology is changing so fast, do you think majority of people will switch over to blu ray? Many people are waiting for the right price but do you think something better could come out and take out blu ray? How long do you think blu ray will have this technological advantage?
In time, all video will eventually be High Definition, but that does not necessarily mean Blu-ray. I doubt that the majority of people will ever adopt Blu-ray, but hopefully it can carve out a big enough piece of the market to be profitable.

technewb 04-05-08 05:57 PM

great input Josh, that is a huge help. Thank you!


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:12 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.