Blu-ray Disc Player Thread
#926
New Member
Join Date: May 2009
Location: Shenandoah Valley
Posts: 18
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Blu-ray Disc Player Thread
I concur w/ Dining Dead in that I'm looking for a BR player w/ maximum upcoverting capability.
One item that may or may not have been discussed here previously is that the Criterion Collection uses the PS3 as their "reference" BR player. How this came about I don't know, but I doubt that Criterion would endorse an inferior player when their rep is built on high-quality A/V restoration.
So if PS3 is good enough for CC, why would anyone buy a stand-alone BR player...?
One item that may or may not have been discussed here previously is that the Criterion Collection uses the PS3 as their "reference" BR player. How this came about I don't know, but I doubt that Criterion would endorse an inferior player when their rep is built on high-quality A/V restoration.
So if PS3 is good enough for CC, why would anyone buy a stand-alone BR player...?
Seeing that blu-rays are nearing the same prices as standard, I think I'll finally break down and get a blu-ray player.
My television is a 40" Samsung LN40A550.
I'm not as concerned with Wi-Fi, Netflix, and a lot of other special features. I just want a player that has outstanding image and sound quality. Especially important to me is a player that does an excellent job of upconverting standard dvds.
I've heard good things about Panasonic's DMP-BD60 picture and sound on blu-rays. Is this machine also good with upconverting? I just have so many standard dvds that it is crucial that it is.
Any suggestions?
My television is a 40" Samsung LN40A550.
I'm not as concerned with Wi-Fi, Netflix, and a lot of other special features. I just want a player that has outstanding image and sound quality. Especially important to me is a player that does an excellent job of upconverting standard dvds.
I've heard good things about Panasonic's DMP-BD60 picture and sound on blu-rays. Is this machine also good with upconverting? I just have so many standard dvds that it is crucial that it is.
Any suggestions?
#927
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Blu-ray Disc Player Thread
I concur w/ Dining Dead in that I'm looking for a BR player w/ maximum upcoverting capability.
One item that may or may not have been discussed here previously is that the Criterion Collection uses the PS3 as their "reference" BR player. How this came about I don't know, but I doubt that Criterion would endorse an inferior player when their rep is built on high-quality A/V restoration.
So if PS3 is good enough for CC, why would anyone buy a stand-alone BR player...?
One item that may or may not have been discussed here previously is that the Criterion Collection uses the PS3 as their "reference" BR player. How this came about I don't know, but I doubt that Criterion would endorse an inferior player when their rep is built on high-quality A/V restoration.
So if PS3 is good enough for CC, why would anyone buy a stand-alone BR player...?
1. When Criterion jumped into Blu-ray, the PS3 was still pretty much the best all-around Blu-ray player, so their decision to use the PS3 as a reference player made sense. Since then, a number of other excellent players have been released, many of which would be viable "reference" players, so using Criterion's choice as a current standard is potentially flawed.
2. It all depends on the features you want/need. Criterion doesn't use the PS3 to upscale standard DVDs - they use it to test their BDs, so their choice of the PS3 isn't necessarily relevant if upscaling quality is important to you. Additionally, if you need analog outs for audio, the PS3 isn't a viable choice. If power consumption is important to you, the PS3 is not the best choice. Etc, etc.
All that said, the PS3 is my personal BD player of choice. I just recognize there are many practical reasons to choose something else.
#928
New Member
Join Date: May 2009
Location: Shenandoah Valley
Posts: 18
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Blu-ray Disc Player Thread
Kevin,
Many thanks for clearing some things up for me re the PS3 and CC. By "upscaling" I assume you mean "upconverting," which as I'd said is of fundamental importance to me given my large SDVD collection. If the PS3 isn't a good upconverter it's not the right choice for me; realizing that you are using a PS3, would you or anyone else on the forum recommend any specific BD players based on upconverting capability (and sorry if this has been mentioned already)?
Many thanks for clearing some things up for me re the PS3 and CC. By "upscaling" I assume you mean "upconverting," which as I'd said is of fundamental importance to me given my large SDVD collection. If the PS3 isn't a good upconverter it's not the right choice for me; realizing that you are using a PS3, would you or anyone else on the forum recommend any specific BD players based on upconverting capability (and sorry if this has been mentioned already)?
Two things to consider:
1. When Criterion jumped into Blu-ray, the PS3 was still pretty much the best all-around Blu-ray player, so their decision to use the PS3 as a reference player made sense. Since then, a number of other excellent players have been released, many of which would be viable "reference" players, so using Criterion's choice as a current standard is potentially flawed.
2. It all depends on the features you want/need. Criterion doesn't use the PS3 to upscale standard DVDs - they use it to test their BDs, so their choice of the PS3 isn't necessarily relevant if upscaling quality is important to you. Additionally, if you need analog outs for audio, the PS3 isn't a viable choice. If power consumption is important to you, the PS3 is not the best choice. Etc, etc.
All that said, the PS3 is my personal BD player of choice. I just recognize there are many practical reasons to choose something else.
1. When Criterion jumped into Blu-ray, the PS3 was still pretty much the best all-around Blu-ray player, so their decision to use the PS3 as a reference player made sense. Since then, a number of other excellent players have been released, many of which would be viable "reference" players, so using Criterion's choice as a current standard is potentially flawed.
2. It all depends on the features you want/need. Criterion doesn't use the PS3 to upscale standard DVDs - they use it to test their BDs, so their choice of the PS3 isn't necessarily relevant if upscaling quality is important to you. Additionally, if you need analog outs for audio, the PS3 isn't a viable choice. If power consumption is important to you, the PS3 is not the best choice. Etc, etc.
All that said, the PS3 is my personal BD player of choice. I just recognize there are many practical reasons to choose something else.
#929
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Blu-ray Disc Player Thread
I concur w/ Dining Dead in that I'm looking for a BR player w/ maximum upcoverting capability.
One item that may or may not have been discussed here previously is that the Criterion Collection uses the PS3 as their "reference" BR player. How this came about I don't know, but I doubt that Criterion would endorse an inferior player when their rep is built on high-quality A/V restoration.
So if PS3 is good enough for CC, why would anyone buy a stand-alone BR player...?
One item that may or may not have been discussed here previously is that the Criterion Collection uses the PS3 as their "reference" BR player. How this came about I don't know, but I doubt that Criterion would endorse an inferior player when their rep is built on high-quality A/V restoration.
So if PS3 is good enough for CC, why would anyone buy a stand-alone BR player...?
By "reference," I also took that to mean it's their test player, not necessarily what they think is the best quality.
#930
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2001
Posts: 310
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Blu-ray Disc Player Thread
The Sony S550 has new firmware out that adds both slow and freeze frame functions to the player. I know this is of importance to a few people. I have this player and love it. Very solid.
#932
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Blu-ray Disc Player Thread
Kevin,
Many thanks for clearing some things up for me re the PS3 and CC. By "upscaling" I assume you mean "upconverting," which as I'd said is of fundamental importance to me given my large SDVD collection. If the PS3 isn't a good upconverter it's not the right choice for me; realizing that you are using a PS3, would you or anyone else on the forum recommend any specific BD players based on upconverting capability (and sorry if this has been mentioned already)?
Many thanks for clearing some things up for me re the PS3 and CC. By "upscaling" I assume you mean "upconverting," which as I'd said is of fundamental importance to me given my large SDVD collection. If the PS3 isn't a good upconverter it's not the right choice for me; realizing that you are using a PS3, would you or anyone else on the forum recommend any specific BD players based on upconverting capability (and sorry if this has been mentioned already)?
In the under $500 category, the Oppo is probably king when it comes to upconverting, based on reviews at least.
#933
Member
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: SHADO HQ
Posts: 143
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Blu-ray Disc Player Thread
Speaking for myself as a non-gamer, I just can't rationalize buying a device where I would be using only 50% (if that) of its capabilities, even if it is priced competitively with some quality stand-alone players. Additionally, the PS3 has a reputation of running hot & noisy, and is said to be a power hog even in standby mode. Plus there's the remote control issue that was mentioned earlier. Any or all of those drawbacks might be tolerable to someone who was using it for both gaming & BD viewing, but in my view they're hard to justify if you're only watching BDs.
#934
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
#935
Re: Blu-ray Disc Player Thread
Could someone with both a PS3 and a standalone player (preferably a quality brand: Sony, Panasonic) tell if a stand alone would perform better than a PS3 just strictly on the PQ?
I'm only a PS3 owner but in the back of my mind,I always felt a stand-alone player would perform better visually. I mean back in the DVDs days, a quality standalone player would crush the XBOX or PS2's DVD performance,no doubt and that has sort of carried on with my thinking.
Edit to add: I'm also not that impress with the PS3's DVD upconverting abilities. I mean it's decent and serviceble but my HD-A2,HD-XA2 and Oppo 981 beats it quite handily imo.
I'm only a PS3 owner but in the back of my mind,I always felt a stand-alone player would perform better visually. I mean back in the DVDs days, a quality standalone player would crush the XBOX or PS2's DVD performance,no doubt and that has sort of carried on with my thinking.
Edit to add: I'm also not that impress with the PS3's DVD upconverting abilities. I mean it's decent and serviceble but my HD-A2,HD-XA2 and Oppo 981 beats it quite handily imo.
Last edited by davidlynchfan; 11-16-09 at 09:34 PM.
#936
Suspended
Re: Blu-ray Disc Player Thread
I won't own a PS3 as a Blu-ray player (again) because the remote sucked (a $25 add-on) and I wanted an actual Display to see runtime etc. I'm very happy with my BD390.
#937
Member
Join Date: Nov 2009
Posts: 129
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Blu-ray Disc Player Thread
Does anyone own a Panasonic DMP-BD60? How good is it at upconverting? I heard that it's comparable to LG BD390. However, the Panasonic is only $130 on Amazon while the LG is $274. What justifies the $144 price difference?
#938
Suspended
Re: Blu-ray Disc Player Thread
The BD390 was $230 for a while on Amazon. It'll drop soon enough. The only difference I know if is the BD390 can play any movie format via USB, has Netflix, VuDu and a few other things. Don't know about Upconverting though I remember the Panasonic 30 being poor. The BD390 seems pretty good to me...but I honestly don't watch many DVDs anymore so its kind of a moot point for me.
#939
Member
Join Date: Nov 2009
Posts: 129
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Blu-ray Disc Player Thread
The BD390 was $230 for a while on Amazon. It'll drop soon enough. The only difference I know if is the BD390 can play any movie format via USB, has Netflix, VuDu and a few other things. Don't know about Upconverting though I remember the Panasonic 30 being poor. The BD390 seems pretty good to me...but I honestly don't watch many DVDs anymore so its kind of a moot point for me.
I own over 500 standard dvds so great upconverting potential is paramount. So many of my favorite movies are still not available in blu-ray (Lost in Translation, Sunset Blvd., Chinatown, the list goes on).
#940
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Blu-ray Disc Player Thread
The BD390 was $230 for a while on Amazon. It'll drop soon enough. The only difference I know if is the BD390 can play any movie format via USB, has Netflix, VuDu and a few other things. Don't know about Upconverting though I remember the Panasonic 30 being poor. The BD390 seems pretty good to me...but I honestly don't watch many DVDs anymore so its kind of a moot point for me.
#941
Suspended
Re: Blu-ray Disc Player Thread
#942
Member
Join Date: Nov 2009
Posts: 129
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Blu-ray Disc Player Thread
I think I'll go with the Panasonic.
#943
Suspended
#944
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Thread Starter
I can't address the upscaling because I use my HD-A1 for upscaling DVDs (and I watch more DVDs than BDs because much of my viewing is TV on DVD). I've never put a DVD in my BD80.
#945
Member
Join Date: Nov 2009
Posts: 129
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Blu-ray Disc Player Thread
30 seconds is probably overstating it. The Panny is a pretty quick third generation player, just not as fast to load Java-laden BDs as the PS3 or LG390.
I can't address the upscaling because I use my HD-A1 for upscaling DVDs (and I watch more DVDs than BDs because much of my viewing is TV on DVD). I've never put a DVD in my BD80.
I can't address the upscaling because I use my HD-A1 for upscaling DVDs (and I watch more DVDs than BDs because much of my viewing is TV on DVD). I've never put a DVD in my BD80.
#946
Member
Join Date: Nov 2009
Posts: 129
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Blu-ray Disc Player Thread
I didn't realize that my crappy Samsung LN40A550 does not have 24p. So, basically, I guess the Panasonic DMP-BD60 upconverting feature would be pretty much useless to me. Why did I have to go with Samsung? My next tv will be a Sony.
#947
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Blu-ray Disc Player Thread
The only reliability issue I've heard about for the LG BD390 is a possible lip sync issue, but it's been difficult to get accurate information about that.
#948
Member
Join Date: Nov 2009
Posts: 129
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Blu-ray Disc Player Thread
For what it's worth, there is a known issue with the Panasonic BD60 and BD80 that causes intermittent, random freezes for 5 to 10 seconds during BD playback. The frequency and length of the freezes seem to vary significantly, but it's a widespread problem reported by many owners of those players and has been acknowledged by Panasonic. As yet, Panasonic has no fix for this problem.
The only reliability issue I've heard about for the LG BD390 is a possible lip sync issue, but it's been difficult to get accurate information about that.
The only reliability issue I've heard about for the LG BD390 is a possible lip sync issue, but it's been difficult to get accurate information about that.
#949
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Thread Starter
For what it's worth, there is a known issue with the Panasonic BD60 and BD80 that causes intermittent, random freezes for 5 to 10 seconds during BD playback. The frequency and length of the freezes seem to vary significantly, but it's a widespread problem reported by many owners of those players and has been acknowledged by Panasonic. As yet, Panasonic has no fix for this problem.
The only reliability issue I've heard about for the LG BD390 is a possible lip sync issue, but it's been difficult to get accurate information about that.
The only reliability issue I've heard about for the LG BD390 is a possible lip sync issue, but it's been difficult to get accurate information about that.
If the freeze issue is off-putting to a potential buyer of a Panny BD60, the Sony S360 is an equivalent name-brand player at a modest price. And Sony recently added freeze frame/slow motion to its players via firmware update, as mentioned upthread, a notable lack before.
#950
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Thread Starter
I am unable to use my BD player for DVDs because I have it on component inputs (my HD-A1 has the DVI port, long story). My display is now too old and primitive (CRT rear-projection) to really give useful information about how players upscale. Sorry. While I would like to upgrade my display to an LED lit one, the main thing holding me back is that I wouldn't know what to do with my old display; there is no market for them where I live, so far as I know.
Longtime posters here will be aware that I am not a fan of the PS3 for a variety of reasons (listed in early pages of this thread), most notably that it is an enormous power hog, whereas the Panny players draw ~25 watts. If you are not a gamer, the PS3 is not the best Blu-ray Disc player.