DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   HD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk-55/)
-   -   Life of Brian (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk/523848-life-brian.html)

MikeShaynePI 01-29-08 05:25 PM

Life of Brian
 
Anyone seen any reviews on the new Blu-Ray release? Wondering if it'll be worth upgrading on technical circumstances?

E Unit 01-29-08 05:29 PM

Sounds like a no brainer to me. I guess I need to leave work and pick it up.

http://bluray.highdefdigest.com/1100...feofbrian.html

tonymontana313 01-29-08 05:42 PM

I think this is my best BD purchase so far since it is one my favorite movies of all time.

cardaway 01-29-08 05:48 PM

Looks tempting, but given the still far from impressive video and audio (especially audio) I'll likely stick with the Criterion. If I only had the Anchor Bay disc this would be an easy decision.

It doesn't say so, but I suspect much of the two "different" docs contain the same behind the scenes stuff. I'm sure the interviews are new, but is there really more vintage doc footage?

bunkaroo 01-29-08 05:56 PM

My copy is going to be delivered tomorrow. Can't wait. I've been singing the theme song since Sunday.

For those one fence, I'm sure it will be in one of the next BOGO's.

darkside 01-29-08 06:27 PM


Originally Posted by bunkaroo
My copy is going to be delivered tomorrow. Can't wait. I've been singing the theme song since Sunday.

For those one fence, I'm sure it will be in one of the next BOGO's.

It was thankfully part of the December 07 BOGO sale so I have it and 20 Million Miles to Earth on the way this week.

dsa_shea 01-29-08 07:30 PM

For some reason I thought this was advertised as a two disc set. I know the SD version is 2 disc but I thought that the BD was also two disc. To my surprise when I opened it there was only 1 disc inside. I would rather have only one disc in this case but I thought it was a bit strange. It is definitely worth the upgrade in my opinion.

Edit: Amazon is the one advertising it as a 2 disc set but unless I got ripped it is only 1 disc.

dvdirv 01-29-08 09:28 PM

Great transfer!
 
I watched BRIAN tonight and was blown away by the video transfer.

It doesn't look like an almost 30-year old movie! Most of the Monty Python features had a really grainy look.

But Brian on HD just looks stunning! :)

MikeShaynePI 01-29-08 11:31 PM

It's funny. When this whole high-def thing started I looked at my thousand plus DVD collection and said "there's no way I'm replacing these. I'll only buy new titles. How much better could they possibly make some of these older movies look." I've kind of stuck with that. If a title is re-released and it has been made better and it's out in both regular and blu-ray I'll buy the blu-ray to replace as I would have bought the regular one anyway. I've done this now with the Kubrick titles and Close Encounters. The one that I replaced and it wasn't a dual release was Blazing Saddles, and that's only because it came in that Blu-Ray boxset. I have Superman, Goodfellas, and Blade Runner on Blu-Ray, but I still have the same titles on regular DVD. With Life of Brian, I'll definitely be keeping the Criterion, so that's like those.

RobLutter 01-30-08 01:37 AM

It'll be interesting to see this transfer as I was highly unimpressed by a newly-struck 35mm print I saw a couple years back.

Guessing they did some restoration work because both the theatrical and DVD presentation (Criterion) were as grainy as the Sahara.

Doughboy 01-30-08 08:49 AM

Mine's on the way from Amazon. The Criterion transfer wasn't all that great and even had "cigarette burns" if I recall correctly. So I'll be glad to upgrade it. Hopefully this is a sign that Sony's willing to release more pre-1990 titles.

dsa_shea 01-30-08 08:52 AM


Originally Posted by RobLutter
It'll be interesting to see this transfer as I was highly unimpressed by a newly-struck 35mm print I saw a couple years back.

Guessing they did some restoration work because both the theatrical and DVD presentation (Criterion) were as grainy as the Sahara.

You will be impressed by this transfer. It has a few faults but overall it shimmers like the light of Brian.

tonymontana313 01-30-08 10:20 AM


Originally Posted by dsa_shea
You will be impressed by this transfer. It has a few faults but overall it shimmers like the light of Brian.

Totally agree with you man. I was just amazed at the clarity and I think I spent more time just in awe of the transfer rather than paying attention to the movie.

rexinnih 01-30-08 10:33 AM

Mine's on the way from Amazon. Last delivery from the BOGO's.

tylergfoster 01-30-08 10:46 AM

I didn't see it in hi-def and I just posted this in the other forum but I was also very, very happy with the transfer. I started with the cruddy Anchor Bay version that had scratch marks all over the place and kinda looked a little like it was underwater, and then there was the Criterion which was better, but it was still grainy and dark and had scratches and was fuzzy. I wasn't expecting much out of this. I thought, 'hey, how good can they make such an old low-budget movie look?' But Brian looks amazing. Colors pop, the detail is far beyond what I'd have thought one could wring from the negative and it looks like it was shot yesterday.

bunkaroo 01-30-08 11:01 AM

You guys aren't making it any easier for me to wait through my workday so I can watch it tonight...

BSTNFAN 01-30-08 03:27 PM


Originally Posted by bunkaroo
You guys aren't making it any easier for me to wait through my workday so I can watch it tonight...

Well...Get off the internet, get your work done, and go home early! :)

bunkaroo 01-30-08 03:46 PM


Originally Posted by BSTNFAN
Well...Get off the internet, get your work done, and go home early! :)

One hour and counting.

With my luck UPS won't deliver it until 7pm.

Supermallet 02-02-08 05:24 AM

http://www.dvdtalk.com/reviews/read.php?ID=32217

jackson walker 02-02-08 06:17 AM

I, too, am amazed at the transfer. It has always looked a little "dark" to me in previous releases, but the blu-ray is simply stunning. The audio is a little "compressed" but I believe it was recorded that way.

Solid Snake 01-20-14 03:39 PM

Re: Life of Brian
 
So wtf is going on here? Is this thing OOP now or what? Was thinking about buying it but nada.

maxfisher 01-21-14 05:59 AM

Re: Life of Brian
 

Originally Posted by Solid Snake (Post 11984309)
So wtf is going on here? Is this thing OOP now or what? Was thinking about buying it but nada.

Looks like it's available on Amazon for ~$20 and Half for about the same, after shipping.

Solid Snake 01-21-14 08:45 AM

Re: Life of Brian
 
But the Amazon ones are from sellers. Target.com shows nothing for it in avaliability. Jesus. Somebody is selling BD $117 on Amazon.

bunkaroo 01-21-14 09:50 AM

Re: Life of Brian
 
Do we dare to dream Criterion has gotten the rights back?

Guru Askew 01-28-14 04:30 PM

Re: Life of Brian
 

Originally Posted by Solid Snake (Post 11984309)
So wtf is going on here? Is this thing OOP now or what? Was thinking about buying it but nada.

Check your PM.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:28 PM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.