Knocked Up disappointment and combo discs in general....
#1
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2001
Location: Midlothian, VA
Posts: 2,659
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Knocked Up disappointment and combo discs in general....
WTF Universal? Why must you ruin the high-def release of one of the funniest movies this year? Plus it won't even have all the bonus features of the 2-disc standard def release?
Anyone else like me who will just not buy HD/DVD combo releases? Besides the higher MSRPs and all their reported compatibility problems (not to mention lack of artwork), I have to question who exactly are these releases targeting? The way I see it, if you are buying an HD disc, you don't have any desire for a standard def version.....
With the uncertainty about the long term prospects for either or both competing formats, I can't see someone who does not yet have an HD-DVD player buying a disc today that costs twice as much as the standard def release "in case I decide to pick up an HD-DVD player later on if/when they become cheaper/the winning format"...I mean, as we have all seen with regular DVD, over time the prices come down on just about all titles....so why pay double today for a disc you may or may not ever use the other side of later on when by the time you do finally go HD, it will probably cost less to rebuy in HD than the premium you paid for it over the regular DVD today?
(Edited to add [before any accusations of format bias]: dual format supporter here: PS3 purchased in July, and HD-A2 bought in August)
Anyone else like me who will just not buy HD/DVD combo releases? Besides the higher MSRPs and all their reported compatibility problems (not to mention lack of artwork), I have to question who exactly are these releases targeting? The way I see it, if you are buying an HD disc, you don't have any desire for a standard def version.....
With the uncertainty about the long term prospects for either or both competing formats, I can't see someone who does not yet have an HD-DVD player buying a disc today that costs twice as much as the standard def release "in case I decide to pick up an HD-DVD player later on if/when they become cheaper/the winning format"...I mean, as we have all seen with regular DVD, over time the prices come down on just about all titles....so why pay double today for a disc you may or may not ever use the other side of later on when by the time you do finally go HD, it will probably cost less to rebuy in HD than the premium you paid for it over the regular DVD today?
(Edited to add [before any accusations of format bias]: dual format supporter here: PS3 purchased in July, and HD-A2 bought in August)
Last edited by WMAangel; 09-02-07 at 01:21 AM.
#3
I don't understand all the hate about combos. Am I the only that doesn't give an F about artwork on the disc? I open the case and then the disc goes into the player. I see the lack of artwork for about 4 seconds.
It definitely sucks that they charge more money. WTF is that all about?
It definitely sucks that they charge more money. WTF is that all about?
#4
Member
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: London
Posts: 136
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by PopcornTreeCt
Am I the only that doesn't give an F about artwork on the disc? I open the case and then the disc goes into the player. I see the lack of artwork for about 4 seconds.
#5
Member
Join Date: May 2006
Posts: 131
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I like art on a disc just as much as most people...but I also buy new editions when they come out...I definitely double dip a little to much. Anyway...I really enjoy combo discs...we don't have a HD player in our room so if we want to watch a flick...it has to be dvd!
Matt
Matt
#6
Banned by request
If lack of art on the disc was the only problem with combos, I probably wouldn't mind. But when you add in the extra price, plus the failure rate, it just seems like a bad idea.
#7
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2001
Location: Midlothian, VA
Posts: 2,659
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Suprmallet
Aside from the lack of extras, what specifically about Knocked Up is a disappointment? Just that it's a combo?
Extras on an Apatow comedy are gold (as they are on a Kevin Smith film)....I love all the alternate and uncut footage on the 40-Year-Old Virgin...and there's going to be hours of that stuff missing from the HD release...
If Universal HAD to put a DVD side to it, I'd much rather it have been the 2nd disc of the standard def special edition....that way you'd get the best of both worlds (HD movie and all the extras)....
#8
DVD Talk Reviewer
Combo's are nice for me because I like a SD copy of a film still in case a format goes belly up and in the distant future I can't find any players for the HD format. My DVD collection itself will still be complete. Bring on the combo's.
#9
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2001
Location: Midlothian, VA
Posts: 2,659
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Suprmallet
If lack of art on the disc was the only problem with combos, I probably wouldn't mind. But when you add in the extra price, plus the failure rate, it just seems like a bad idea.
Hell, here we are, a decade into the life of standard def DVD and sometimes there are STILL issues with double sided dual-layered DVD-18s!
Plus, like you said, the extra price...why should I have to spend at least an extra $5 more to buy an HD title (that is already more expensive then its DVD counterpart to begin with) for a standard def side I won't use?
#10
DVD Talk Hero
I like Combo discs, having the ability to watch it on a standard def player in the bed room is great, but where was it announced that the HD version would be stripped of extras? (URL?)
Last edited by RichC2; 09-02-07 at 08:57 AM.
#11
The "artwork" on the HD DVDs cases can be printed up for a person's own tastes. In fact, I would imagine we have some custom covers out there already.
#12
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Sep 1999
Location: Orlando, FL
Posts: 1,742
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by RichC2
I like Combo discs, but where was it announced that the HD version would be stripped of extras?
#13
Suspended
Join Date: Mar 2007
Posts: 538
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Combo discs are going away, they're even reissuing the titles out on combo discs now on HD only discs. That means they'll probably sell whatever stock they have of the combo version for Knocked Up before announcing the HD only version. But they probably won't say a word until then, especially if they redo the later release to include all the bonus materials.
link
Part of it might be the possible threat of a recall/extended warranty with the HD-A1 (ala XBox 360) if all future combo discs don't play on 100% of their players, even with firmware updates. It'd be hard to get away from that with national exposure, and it may be cheaper to just replace a few discs with the new HD only version to keep HD-A1 owners happy instead of spending money trying to fix the problem.
Some like the combo discs as they don't have/need an HD-DVD player in the bedroom or basement for a smaller TV that may not be HD (or even widescreen). People with in-car DVD systems and portable players also have the option to use the SD side if they'd like to.
link
Part of it might be the possible threat of a recall/extended warranty with the HD-A1 (ala XBox 360) if all future combo discs don't play on 100% of their players, even with firmware updates. It'd be hard to get away from that with national exposure, and it may be cheaper to just replace a few discs with the new HD only version to keep HD-A1 owners happy instead of spending money trying to fix the problem.
Some like the combo discs as they don't have/need an HD-DVD player in the bedroom or basement for a smaller TV that may not be HD (or even widescreen). People with in-car DVD systems and portable players also have the option to use the SD side if they'd like to.
Last edited by Dignam; 09-02-07 at 09:11 AM.
#16
DVD Talk Legend
Again, combos don't cost extra money. It's just that all new releases are combos, and new releases carry a high price tag. But the combo releases from Universal are the same price as new releases from Paramount, Fox, and $1 more than new releases from Sony.
Combos aren't priced high. New releases are priced high. It just happens that new releases are also combos.
Combos aren't priced high. New releases are priced high. It just happens that new releases are also combos.
#17
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally Posted by Jericho
Again, combos don't cost extra money. It's just that all new releases are combos, and new releases carry a high price tag. But the combo releases from Universal are the same price as new releases from Paramount, Fox, and $1 more than new releases from Sony.
Combos aren't priced high. New releases are priced high. It just happens that new releases are also combos.
Combos aren't priced high. New releases are priced high. It just happens that new releases are also combos.
#18
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by flashburn
That isn't completely true. All Warner Bros new releases that are HD DVD combo's are $5 more than the Blu-ray release. You can't say for certain that Universal wouldn't be charging less for their new releases if they weren't combos.
Last edited by Jericho; 09-02-07 at 12:12 PM.
#19
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by Dignam
Combo discs are going away, they're even reissuing the titles out on combo discs now on HD only discs. That means they'll probably sell whatever stock they have of the combo version for Knocked Up before announcing the HD only version. But they probably won't say a word until then, especially if they redo the later release to include all the bonus materials.
link
link
#20
Suspended
I have never had an issue with combos and the $5 more will not kill me or make me eat Top Ramen for a week. I assume anyone who has either an HD DVD or Blu-ray Player is not poor and can afford the extra price of these discs. Its amazing how many people will complain about a $30 Universal Combo disc but will happily buy a $40 Fox Blu-ray movie with a 'theatrical trailer and TV Spot' as extras.
#21
DVD Talk Godfather
Originally Posted by Jericho
Again, combos don't cost extra money. It's just that all new releases are combos, and new releases carry a high price tag.
#22
DVD Talk Godfather
Originally Posted by GizmoDVD
I have never had an issue with combos and the $5 more will not kill me or make me eat Top Ramen for a week. I assume anyone who has either an HD DVD or Blu-ray Player is not poor and can afford the extra price of these discs. Its amazing how many people will complain about a $30 Universal Combo disc but will happily buy a $40 Fox Blu-ray movie with a 'theatrical trailer and TV Spot' as extras.
Both are overpriced, and if anything, the Fox Blu-Rays are more likely to be cheaper in B&M stores.
#23
Suspended
Originally Posted by The Bus
Fox Blu-Ray MSRPs are $39.99. Combo MSRPs are $39.99.
Both are overpriced, and if anything, the Fox Blu-Rays are more likely to be cheaper in B&M stores.
Both are overpriced, and if anything, the Fox Blu-Rays are more likely to be cheaper in B&M stores.
However I see Combos at $28-$30 at stores while Fox Blu-rays are still $34.99.
At least I am getting the SD version and extras for the same price though.
#24
Suspended
Join Date: Mar 2007
Posts: 538
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Jericho
I'm not sure if this is true at all. That article you linked to is from April, and here we are five months later still releasing combos. Not to mention, only WB (not Universal) is re-releasing non-combo versions of some of their films.
#25
Premium Member
Join Date: Jan 2000
Location: Grazing in a field somewhere...
Posts: 23,515
Received 676 Likes
on
456 Posts
Originally Posted by GizmoDVD
I have never had an issue with combos and the $5 more will not kill me or make me eat Top Ramen for a week. I assume anyone who has either an HD DVD or Blu-ray Player is not poor and can afford the extra price of these discs. Its amazing how many people will complain about a $30 Universal Combo disc but will happily buy a $40 Fox Blu-ray movie with a 'theatrical trailer and TV Spot' as extras.
Combos would be fine, if they offered a non-combo version as well. I can see the need, but I can also see the other side where people are paying extra for something they will never use.