DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   HD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk-55/)
-   -   How Do You Usually Watch 4:3 Material On Your 16:9 Display? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk/498147-how-do-you-usually-watch-4-3-material-your-16-9-display.html)

JimRochester 03-08-13 03:49 PM

Re: How Do You Usually Watch 4:3 Material On Your 16:9 Display?
 
My first WS TV was a RPTV Mitsubishi which had a stretch mode where just the sides were stretched to fill the screen so the middle looked fine. On my Panasonic I just watch it with the pillars. I'm a little worried about burn-in but I don't watch enough of it to matter

Larry C. 03-08-13 04:11 PM

Re: How Do You Usually Watch 4:3 Material On Your 16:9 Display?
 

Originally Posted by Jay G. (Post 11606658)
Isn't it still possible to zoom in 4:3 material in HD?

Also, while I try to watch everything in HD if possible, some very good stuff simply isn't HD. I recently got the Get A Life DVD boxset, which is a great show not available in HD.

On TV, some channels aren't available in HD by my provider, so shows on those are watched in HD. And some HD TV channels stretch SD shows, making the SD option more palatable.

I understand I have DirecTv so all of the channels I'm interested in are in HD. So it's rather easy for me never to watch SD.

Jay G. 03-08-13 04:12 PM

Re: How Do You Usually Watch 4:3 Material On Your 16:9 Display?
 

Originally Posted by JimRochester (Post 11607307)
My first WS TV was a RPTV Mitsubishi which had a stretch mode where just the sides were stretched to fill the screen so the middle looked fine.

That non-linear stretching has been called Flexview by at least one network that uses it for SD material on their HD channels, although it's been also called Stretch-O-Vision and fisheye stretching by others.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stretch-o-Vision
http://www.tivocommunity.com/tivo-vb...d.php?t=414079

My wife finds this type of stretch disconcerting when the camera pans, even getting a little dizzy. I just dislike it a lot. The last time I saw it was a special airing of the classic Doctor Who serial "Tomb of the Cybermen" on BBCA HD. I ended up turning it off and watching the serial on Amazon Prime, where it was properly pillarboxed.

Jay G. 03-08-13 04:13 PM

Re: How Do You Usually Watch 4:3 Material On Your 16:9 Display?
 

Originally Posted by Larry C. (Post 11607338)
I understand I have DirecTv so all of the channels I'm interested in are in HD. So it's rather easy for me never to watch SD.

You may still be watching SD material, just SD material upconverted to HD on those channels (and possibly stretched).

Mabuse 03-08-13 04:19 PM

Re: How Do You Usually Watch 4:3 Material On Your 16:9 Display?
 

Originally Posted by Alan Smithee (Post 11604815)
I've been to MANY restaurants that show ESPN on widescreen TVs, coming from a standard 4x3 source with the picture letterboxed- they feed that to the TVs and then STRETCH that so you have a super-wide picture with the "dreaded black bars" on top and bottom. I never leave a tip if I eat anyplace that does that.

This by far is the biggest fuck head thing and I see it all the time.

bluetoast 03-08-13 06:45 PM

Re: How Do You Usually Watch 4:3 Material On Your 16:9 Display?
 
Always OAR.

Alan Smithee 03-09-13 05:10 PM

Re: How Do You Usually Watch 4:3 Material On Your 16:9 Display?
 
Did I mention that I didn't even GET a widescreen TV until 2010, one main reason being that I was waiting for one that could still show 4x3 material PROPERLY??? (I refused to tolerate grey side bars, those are annoying as hell. If forced to choose between stretching or zooming, I'd pick zooming since at least everything stays properly proportioned- I don't know why more people don't do that instead of stretch, but it seems most TVs default to that. I had to manually set all my standard-def sources on my current TV to not be stretched. Also, all my analog video sources like VHS and LD go through my receiver, which upscales them to 1080P with black side bars, and sends that to the TV thru HDMI.)

Dusty Bottoms 03-09-13 06:15 PM

Re: How Do You Usually Watch 4:3 Material On Your 16:9 Display?
 
For those of you who stretch/zoom 4:3 because of the fear of burn-in, do you do the same with 2.35:1 content? I have a current generation Panasonic plasma, and it's OAR all the way for me.

Jay G. 03-09-13 07:00 PM

Re: How Do You Usually Watch 4:3 Material On Your 16:9 Display?
 

Originally Posted by Alan Smithee (Post 11608248)
Did I mention that I didn't even GET a widescreen TV until 2010, one main reason being that I was waiting for one that could still show 4x3 material PROPERLY??? (I refused to tolerate grey side bars, those are annoying as hell.

I've had LCD TVs for a decade now that show black bars on the sides.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:38 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.