DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   HD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk-55/)
-   -   Best HD-DVD's Image Wise? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk/486395-best-hd-dvds-image-wise.html)

PacMan2006 12-12-06 09:21 AM

Best HD-DVD's Image Wise?
 
What are some of the best HD-DVD's in your opinion as far as great detail and overall look of clarity and that "wow" factor when you look onto the screen?

awmurray 12-12-06 09:46 AM

Here's a thread on AVS that attempts to rank them by PQ. Of course, any list like this is subjective, but it was put together by discussions (not just one person). IMO, the rankings are accurate.

PacMan2006 12-12-06 10:16 AM

Perect. Thanks!!

The Bus 12-12-06 10:27 AM

I tried to do a thread like this here and no one participated. :(

DVD Josh 12-12-06 04:07 PM

Batman Begins and Seabuscuit are incredible.

Mr. Cinema 12-12-06 04:12 PM

#1 King Kong

the rest:
Training Day
Fast and the Furious 1, 2, 3
Chronicles of Riddick
Batman Begins
Mission: Impossible III

Nevi 12-12-06 04:32 PM

My faves, PQ wise:

1. The Corpse Bride
2. The Ant Bully
3. The Phantom Of The Opera
4. King Kong
5. Batman Begins

mdc3000 12-12-06 04:38 PM

Just finished watching Ant Bully and while I found the movie average at best, the PQ is flawless and extremely vivid.

penguin42 12-12-06 04:51 PM

My votes go to Batman Begins and Tokyo Drift.

Raul3 12-12-06 05:02 PM

Another vote for King Kong.

I also have Superman Returns, and the image is really good but not that amazing compared with KK.

I just received La Haine but haven't watched it (B/W movie from France). Also coming are: Batman Begins, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory (it should look great) and Enter the Dragon.

Hammer99 12-12-06 05:20 PM

Harry Potter & The Goblet Of Fire
King Kong (2005)
The Searchers
Ant Bully
Seabiscuit

probably my top 5 for now, seems like it changes with each new week of releases ...really depends on what I've watched last lol.

I agree with checking out that AVS thread, most of the rankings are pretty close IMO... good resource if you can't make up your mind between a couple titles.

DVD Josh 12-12-06 05:55 PM


Originally Posted by Raul3
Another vote for King Kong.

I also have Superman Returns, and the image is really good but not that amazing compared with KK.

I just received La Haine but haven't watched it (B/W movie from France). Also coming are: Batman Begins, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory (it should look great) and Enter the Dragon.

Superman Returns is an amazing transfer. It looks exactly as muted and vivid as it did on film.

Depression 12-12-06 09:33 PM


Originally Posted by DVD Josh
Superman Returns is an amazing transfer. It looks exactly as muted and vivid as it did on film.

Amazing transfer yes, but most people seem to have problems with the way the movie was actually shot giving it that so clean it almost looks fake texture.

awmurray 12-13-06 08:46 AM

I would also highly recommend King Kong. It has so many scenes that explode with detail. It even gets remarks from non-ht-type people about how clear certain scenes are when I show it.

It easily earns its #1 position on the PQ ranking thread that I posted earlier.

awmurray 12-13-06 09:11 AM

The Hulk is also getting a lot of good buzz. See the HighDefDigestReview here:


I'm tempted to give it five stars for picture quality, despite the fact that I'm sure someone will email me, complaining that I missed that one dead pixel in frame 38,394. But fuck it, I will give it five stars -- 'Hulk' is truly one of the best catalog releases I've ever seen on either next-gen format.

Presented in 1.85:1 widescreen and 1080p/VC-1 video, every element of the presentation is demo quality. The source material is pristine, and apparently Universal has been keeping 'Hulk's HD master in some sort of Fort Knox vault on the studio lot. Blacks, contrast, colors -- perfect.

Hammer99 12-13-06 10:04 AM


Originally Posted by Depression
Amazing transfer yes, but most people seem to have problems with the way the movie was actually shot giving it that so clean it almost looks fake texture.

Yep. I agree, great transfer, but the OP is looking for "great detail and overall look of clarity and that "wow" factor when you look onto the screen", & IMO you're not going to get that at all with Superman Returns.

fryinpan1 12-13-06 10:15 AM

Corpse Bride gets my vote, but I am new to the HD game and have not seen much HD.

dkny75 12-13-06 12:05 PM

I'd vote for Harry Potter and Seabiscuit.

buckee1 12-13-06 05:29 PM


Originally Posted by Hammer99
Harry Potter & The Goblet Of Fire

Where is this title available?

buckee1 12-13-06 05:45 PM

Found it.

Depression 12-13-06 06:12 PM

Out of Sight also seems to be getting a lot of praise.

Makes me anxious for Ocean's 11 to hit HD. The casino scenes should look fantastic.

Josh Z 12-13-06 06:29 PM


Originally Posted by Depression
Out of Sight also seems to be getting a lot of praise.

Makes me anxious for Ocean's 11 to hit HD. The casino scenes should look fantastic.

Ocean's 11 was shot after the start of Soderbergh's "I like everything grainy" phase. Casino is a better bet for that type of eye candy.

Hammer99 12-13-06 06:35 PM


Originally Posted by buckee1
Found it.

Cool! Worth every penny if you ask me, no telling when WB will release it here (hope it's not next week lol!)

Depression 12-13-06 06:55 PM

I wouldn't be surprised if they held on to them until Order of the Phoenix hits theaters or DVD.

Neitzl 12-13-06 10:07 PM

Hulk does look pretty damn nice. To me, it looks much better than Batman Begins. I really love when you see Hulk jumping away from the desert base and into the more colorful red mountains, those shots look pretty spectacular.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:13 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.