DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   HD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk-55/)
-   -   Superman Returns - HD DVD combo & BD 11/28 (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk/478379-superman-returns-hd-dvd-combo-bd-11-28-a.html)

digitalfreaknyc 09-21-06 04:26 PM

Superman Returns - HD DVD combo & BD 11/28
 
On Nov. 28, the studio will release its $197 million-grossing Superman Returns as an HD DVD Combo disc (which has HD DVD on one side of the disc and standard-def on the other) priced at $39.99 and on Blu-ray Disc with a list price of $34.99.

http://www.videobusiness.com/article/CA6374288.html

joshd2012 09-21-06 04:33 PM

I didn't have a chance to see this in the theaters. Might have to rent.

Giles 09-21-06 04:34 PM

a combo, hmmmm I might bite...

digitalfreaknyc 09-21-06 04:38 PM

Updated for price changes... :(

Doughboy 09-21-06 05:05 PM

I'm really getting sick of these combos. The only reason to even have a SD-DVD side is if they're gonna stick the deleted scenes and documentary on there. If that turns out to be the case, then WB is forgiven. Otherwise, this is a sham. $39.99 list price for a bare bones disc?!

MBoyd 09-21-06 05:08 PM

Combo . . . well that sucks, but at least it is coming. Please let Superman I and II come out as well WB and I will forgive you!!!

darkside 09-21-06 05:11 PM

Well, considering how good the discounts are at Amazon I don't mind the combos. I have already gotten use out of GNGL and Animal House as regular DVDs. It does come in handy.

digitalfreaknyc 09-21-06 05:14 PM


Originally Posted by Doughboy
I'm really getting sick of these combos. The only reason to even have a SD-DVD side is if they're gonna stick the deleted scenes and documentary on there. If that turns out to be the case, then WB is forgiven. Otherwise, this is a sham. $39.99 list price for a bare bones disc?!

They've gotten 30/9 discs working so it could be dual-layer HD/SD. I'm betting that's what it is.

Vipper II 09-21-06 06:20 PM


Originally Posted by digitalfreaknyc
They've gotten 30/9 discs working so it could be dual-layer HD/SD. I'm betting that's what it is.

For a 2+ hour movie, I would hope they'd put it on a DL.

Artman 09-21-06 06:39 PM

So where does the three hr doc go? :hscratch:

I assume the SD DVD side is going to be disc one of that set, and they can't fit a 2 1/2 hr HDmovie and a SD three hr doc on 30gigs can they?

Hope it's two discs...

As much as I don't care for combos (slightly higher price, and the ugly black banner) this is one that definitely makes sense. It very likely will be my first HD purchase...

joshd2012 09-21-06 07:19 PM

HighDefDigest has confirmed that this title will be BD-50! This will be Warner's first BD-50 title.

Mr. Cinema 09-21-06 08:33 PM

Nooooooooooooooooooooooo............not a freakin' combo for Supes. Damn it! I DONT....WANT....THE.....DVD......VERSION....DON'T....MAKE.....ME....PAY....MORE....FOR.....A......SI DE....I'LL....NEVER.....WATCH....

At least it appears King Kong won't be a combo. That along with this title are 1, 2 on my wishlist.

Supermallet 09-21-06 09:26 PM

Digital Bits says all the 2-disc features from the SD DVD will be on the HD DVD. So that's the good news.

The bad news is EVERYTHING FUCKING ELSE ABOUT THIS RELEASE.

A) A combo, with pricing to match
B) No TrueHD
C) That cover

I am ready to kill somebody over this. You can make Animal House a combo, whatever. You can even make The Thing a combo. But you DON'T MAKE SUPERMAN A FUCKING COMBO!

Also I haven't found any place that's confirming any kind of HD extras for the HD DVD.

digitalfreaknyc 09-21-06 09:36 PM


Originally Posted by joshd2012
HighDefDigest has confirmed that this title will be BD-50! This will be Warner's first BD-50 title.

I'll believe it when i see....errrr...hear about it.

I guess it's possible the 3 hour documentary could fit on 1 DL HD disc. That would be, at most, 8.5gb...and they still have another 22 to play with the movie and the IME track.

DthRdrX 09-21-06 09:37 PM


Originally Posted by joshd2012
HighDefDigest has confirmed that this title will be BD-50! This will be Warner's first BD-50 title.

i'm interested but curious. They also say it will have the same extras. Are they using only 30gbs of space on the bd50????

digitalfreaknyc 09-21-06 09:38 PM


Originally Posted by DthRdrX
i'm interested but curious. They also say it will have the same extras. Are they using only 30gbs of space on the bd50????

probably.

digitalfreaknyc 09-21-06 09:55 PM

http://www.dvdtown.com/media/coverart/big/20001.jpg

Supermallet 09-21-06 09:58 PM


Originally Posted by digitalfreaknyc

Yes, the awful cover I complained about. Even the combo stripe on it looks ugly as hell.

Commander Dan 09-22-06 12:18 AM

Glad this is coming before year's end. I will definitely be picking this up (on HD-DVD), though I also am not a fan of the combo discs.

Just who makes these "brilliant" marketing decisions, and what are they thinking?

Supermallet 09-22-06 12:28 AM

I think after this holiday season someone on the "Superman team" should be fired.

Eric D. 09-22-06 01:03 AM

At this point, I am desentized to combos. The Thing was what broke me. Now I just don't care anymore because there is no sign of the combos stopping...ever. I fully expect every major HD DVD release to be a combo now. What bothers me more than the combo is that there is not going to be a HD DVD Superman mega box like SD DVD is getting. WTF is up with that?

Supermallet 09-22-06 01:05 AM

I'm still holding out hope for a box set. If I can't have Nuclear Man in HD, no one can!

ShagMan 09-22-06 07:43 AM

oh my god that cover is horrible.

Oliver Clothesoff 09-22-06 07:54 AM

Horrible cover. But I'm stoked for this release. The combo issue doesn't bother me anymore (provided it's dual-layered on the HD side); I can get this for close to the same price as the 2-disc SE from Amazon, so the cost becomes a nonfactor, really.

bboisvert 09-22-06 08:17 AM

I can understand Warner not wanting to bother doing HD DVDs for Superman III and IV (I suppose).

But, if they were really clever, they'd do a version of the 14-disc standard DVD tin for HD DVD owners. Include all of the content, but switch out the standard versions of Superman I, II, Donner, and Returns for HD DVDs.

It's not going to happen, but it would make me happy. :)


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:50 AM.


Copyright 2018 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.