DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   HD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk-55/)
-   -   Waiting to support might be bad? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk/460449-waiting-support-might-bad.html)

OliverB 04-17-06 08:51 PM

Everyone's talking about storage capacity being worthless with BR... when's the last time you've purchased a 6-disc season set of your favorite tv show?

mbs 04-17-06 08:54 PM


Originally Posted by OliverB
Everyone's talking about storage capacity being worthless with BR... when's the last time you've purchased a 6-disc season set of your favorite tv show?

I doubt that will change too much. There will still be multi-disc releases of Blu-Ray (and HD-DVD), because comsumers perceive (right or wrong) that more discs = getting more for the money. There are plenty of SD-DVD multi-disc releases that could easily fit on a DVD-9.

darkside 04-17-06 09:11 PM

I have several multi disc sets that were stretched by using single layered DVDs instead of DVD 9s. Various Adult Swim sets and the most recent Family Guy come to mind. I don't think number of discs will be a factor as long as an entire movie fits on one disc.

The PC arena is where the storage of Blu Ray will be a big deal.

Coral 04-17-06 09:40 PM

I agree with darkside... the studio's will still do multi-disc releases as it looks to be a better value. I have a few sets that were on 3 or more discs that could've easily fit on 1 or 2 discs without any extra compression. I even have a few 2-disc releases that could've fit easily on 1 disc (ie. Punch-Drunk Love)

The studio's love to put things on 2 or more discs... it allows them to price higher and it draws the customer in.

kvrdave 04-18-06 01:38 AM


Originally Posted by OliverB
Everyone's talking about storage capacity being worthless with BR... when's the last time you've purchased a 6-disc season set of your favorite tv show?

Put a 6 disc season set next to a 1 disc season set of the same show at any store and see which sells more.

OliverB 04-18-06 06:35 AM

I for one, welcome the day when I can have my entire home video library neatly lined up in matching slimcases along my shelves.


Assuming the quality of playback is equalled and the catalogue titles are handeled competently amongst both parties, give me the more convenient format with higher storage capacity and potential for easier integated 'upgrade' in future do to extra accommodation any day...


If every single title ever issued on DVD saw re-release in a high-def format with vastly superior quality and hopefully minus some of the early flaws seen relating to transfer and aspect ratios etc... and was offered each in individual slimcase packaging with full-sized original artwork to conveniently line-up on shelves - that would be my HT dream fullfilled.

darkside 04-18-06 07:11 AM

I would love for everything to be slim cases as well as I definitely have space issues. However, I don't think the studios have any intention of doing this. If anything the packaging is just getting tackier with HD DVD and Blu-ray.

kvrdave 04-18-06 10:10 AM


Originally Posted by OliverB
I for one, welcome the day when I can have my entire home video library neatly lined up in matching slimcases along my shelves.


Assuming the quality of playback is equalled and the catalogue titles are handeled competently amongst both parties, give me the more convenient format with higher storage capacity and potential for easier integated 'upgrade' in future do to extra accommodation any day...


If every single title ever issued on DVD saw re-release in a high-def format with vastly superior quality and hopefully minus some of the early flaws seen relating to transfer and aspect ratios etc... and was offered each in individual slimcase packaging with full-sized original artwork to conveniently line-up on shelves - that would be my HT dream fullfilled.

I agree, but I don't think the majority of people will do that. They have already trained people to pay more for the special 2 disc edition, and I would be that most Joe Six Pack guys don't ever watch the second disc. And if they have a 1 BR disc edition but then want to add more, they aren't just going to have a new and improved single disc edition and get people to pay more for it.

digitalfreaknyc 04-18-06 10:16 AM

Well...because HD-DVD has a smaller storage capacity, those 2 disc sets will come eventually. ;)


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:10 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.