With all due respect, and I don't want to come off sounding like Al Gore, but how the blazes can "Gladiator" win the category for Best Isolated Score? As previously pointed out, by myself and others:

THE GLADIATOR DVD DOES NOT EVEN HAVE AN ISOLATED SCORE!!!

Who voted for this DVD--confused, elderly residents of Florida?!? Did people think they were voting for Best Score, or Pat Buchanan?!? This is like voting a pan & scan VHS tape "DVD of the Year." It just doesn't make sense. It's just plain WRONG. Not to mention embarassing to the DVD Talk community. What's next: we vote "Best Commentary" to a disc that doesn't HAVE a commentary?

Could you at least reveal what came in second place--so we'll know who SHOULD have won?

To preserve the dignity and integrity of the DVD Talkie Awards, I must demand a recount of the Best Isolated Score category, on the grounds that the winner is completely unqualified to even compete in the category.

Yeah, I know this isn't that big a deal, but I think this is a mistake that can be easily corrected. Admit we goofed, and give the award to the second-highest vote getter.

Thank you for your consideration of this issue. :)

2nd place was Pee Wee's Big Adventure.

Egg on face.

Will Fix

G

You should've fixed it when the contest was going on!

Robert.

Yeah I should have.... But I can only do what I can do.. OK

Ease up, buddy! I have a feeling that Geoff does more work on this site in one day than most of the members here do in a month. This is hardly a big issue.

Geoff--

THANK YOU!!

I agree, this was not a big deal--except to fans of isolated scores (like me). I guarantee, if JAWS had been voted Best Director's Commentary, you would've heard a huge cry from the masses about that!

*cough* *cough* get a life *cough* *cough*

2nd

Do you feel disenfranchised? ;)

My vote for Best Commentary has to go to Major League... The play by play commentary that Bob Uecker gives during the game is the best I have ever heard.

Oh, except that movie isn't out on DVD yet, but should be...

I think it should still win.
:)