![]() |
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
I just finished watching THE 400 BLOWS. This was either my second or third time seeing it, but it's been so long since my last viewing that I'd forgotten most of the plot. It reaffirms my love of Truffaut, but I still have to say (and this may be seen as heresy by some) that, while I really like THE 400 BLOWS, it's still not quite up to the level of STOLEN KISSES, which I guess that I saw for the first time at exactly the right moment in my life.
My favorite moment in THE 400 BLOWS (out of many great moments) is when Rene's father, admonishing him for throwing clothes on the stuffed horse and smoking cigars, looks down and sees Antoine's feet...and continues as if he HASN'T just seen Antoine hiding on the other side of the bed. |
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
Originally Posted by rbrown498
(Post 11843169)
I watched THE MAGICIAN this afternoon. It didn't disappoint me; I was expecting something a lot heavier than what I got, and I really enjoyed Bergman in a relatively playful mood. I've found that, so far at least, I haven't met a Bergman film that I didn't like.
I will say, though, that of the Bergman films I've seen to date, my personal pick as the single best representative of his filmography that I loved and would point Bergman newbies toward is Gycklarnas afton [Sawdust and Tinsel]. It wound up being my highest-ranked first-time viewing of 2012. Here's what I wrote of it last year in my Letterboxd diary: ***SPOILER ALERT FOR ANYONE READING EMAIL*** Spoiler:
|
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
Originally Posted by shadokitty
(Post 11843213)
I didn't know Jason and the Argonauts was eligible. I own that and never got around to watching it in either the Sci Fi Challenge or the Animation Challenge.
|
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
Originally Posted by rbrown498
(Post 11843276)
I just finished watching THE 400 BLOWS. This was either my second or third time seeing it, but it's been so long since my last viewing that I'd forgotten most of the plot. It reaffirms my love of Truffaut, but I still have to say (and this may be seen as heresy by some) that, while I really like THE 400 BLOWS, it's still not quite up to the level of STOLEN KISSES, which I guess that I saw for the first time at exactly the right moment in my life.
My favorite moment in THE 400 BLOWS (out of many great moments) is when Rene's father, admonishing him for throwing clothes on the stuffed horse and smoking cigars, looks down and sees Antoine's feet...and continues as if he HASN'T just seen Antoine hiding on the other side of the bed. |
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
I finished out my Saturday by watching INSOMNIA, a first-time watch. I haven't seen the remake, so I went into it not knowing squat about it. I dug it pretty hard, even though I was a bit confused for a while about the circumstances involving the first major plot twist. Once I got further confirmation from the film that what I thought had happened did indeed happen, things got real interesting real quick.
Anybody know where to find a download of the song that plays over the end credits (and behind the disc menu)? |
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
Originally Posted by pacaway
(Post 11843158)
What perfect timing for the Calgary International Film Festival to show Jason and the Argonauts (LD #160) this morning! So awesome to get to see this on the big screen!
|
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
Since I've been transitioning to a new job, I haven't had much time for movies (thought I did watch the third season of Downton Abbey). Yesterday, I watched Five Easy Pieces which was a most perplexing film. The film follows Bobby, a pianist turned oil worker with a waitress girlfriend and a big dose of dissatisfaction. There are some incredibly witty conversations and scenes, including a funny diner scene where Bobby just wants a side of toast. Jack Nicholson plays Bobby and oscillates between sneering contempt and vulnerable uncertainty. Karen Black plays Rayette the waitress, and I find that I love her more and more each time I see her in a film. (Got to get Nashville on BD.) However, the high point for me was Lois Smith playing Bobby's sister, a neurotic pianist who you can tell has been worn down by her family. She's one of those people that isn't quite repressed but has definitely been at home too long.
Today, I finally watched Nanook of the North, a film I've had on my Criterion shelf for years. I know this makes me sound a bit uncultured, but I don't typically seek out documentaries unless they are about nature or something in which I am very interested. Anyway, it was time to finally get this out of my unwatched pile, and I am so glad I watched it. The film is a charming look at an Eskimo family traveling to the seals' breeding grounds to hunt. I really enjoyed it and want to build my own igloo (hard to do in the middle of Oklahoma). |
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
In case no one has mentioned this, Wizard of Oz 3D qualifies as a Criterion movie not released on DVD. It is LD # 059
|
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
I had a productive Criterion watching day for a change. First, I watched all of the supplemental interviews included on the Seconds disc. Then, I watched the film again with the John Frankenheimer commentary which completed my "watch the entire disc" part of the challenge.
In the evening, I watched the Safety Last! disc and one of the included supplemental short films, His Royal Slyness. I am not adverse to silent films in general, but I have to admit that I do find silent comedies to be a bit of a challenge for me to get into other than some Buster Keaton stuff. This followed the normal pattern for me of being entertaining enough but feeling kinda average to me overall. Since a lot of people I talk with seemed to love it, I always wonder what I am missing. Oh well, I will keep giving them a shot. |
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
I missed a couple days but have watched a few today to make up for it. Watched The Life Aquatic with Steve Zissou, The Devil and Daniel Webster and Robinson Crusoe on Mars. Well, the first is the only one I've watched before. I didn't enjoy it the first time. This time, I found more moments that I enjoyed (like the underwater parts) but overall, I don't think it'll ever be one that I want to watch. The Devil and Daniel Webster was ok. Not my favorite, but it was watchable. A little preachy, I thought.
The final one, Robinson Crusoe on Mars was my favorite of the three. A fairly good sci-fi film, a bit slow paced, but not too bad. Nothing like I was expecting. A few things that bugged me, though, Spoiler:
Spoiler:
Oh, I just needed to add, that it was the fakest snow ever, right at the end, that Mona was covered in. I'd watch this one again, though. |
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
I've fallen a bit behind on the discussion thread, it seems. On Saturday, I got together with a friend and we watched 12 Angry Men. We discussed that pretty thoroughly during last year's challenge, and so much has been said of it in general that I really don't have much to add so I'm not bothering to share my Letterboxd diary entry.
I do, however, want to bring up this essay written by Thane Rosenbaum for Criterion's 2011 edition of the film. I wonder: Am I alone in not particularly caring for this one? I can't quite articulate what my problem with this one is, except that I feel like it's trying too hard. For instance, there's the very first line: 12 Angry Men (1957), the first feature film directed by the legendary Sidney Lumet, is a Hollywood classic that, ironically, helped to define an era of filmmaking grounded in the gritty realism and frenetic energy of urban New York. Later, Rosenbaum writes: It is not surprising that Lumet, whose lifetime coincided with so many of the injustices of the twentieth century—from the Holocaust to the Hollywood blacklist—would choose as the subject of his first feature a story painted in the gray brushstrokes of prejudice. I had some other issues, but I'll leave it there. It just really stood out to me because it's the first essay I've read during this year's challenge where I became annoyed. Also, I finally saw The Curious Case of Benjamin Button a few hours ago. I'm still organizing my thoughts on that one. |
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
Oh! I forgot to mention it, but a few days ago I read in a New York Times piece on Pope Francis that his favorite film is apparently La strada. I saw that for the first time last year. I'm still getting a sense of who Francis is, but I can easily see the appeal of Fellini's film for someone as dedicated to humility and consideration as Francis seems to be.
|
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
12 Angry Men (1957), the first feature film directed by the legendary Sidney Lumet, is a Hollywood classic that, ironically, helped to define an era of filmmaking grounded in the gritty realism and frenetic energy of urban New York. |
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
Originally Posted by Ash Ketchum
(Post 11845881)
Travis, allow me to comment on this quote you took from that essay. 12 ANGRY MEN takes place entirely inside a jurors' room recreated in a studio. Not much in the way of "gritty realism and frenetic energy of urban New York."
In short: I see nothing about this specific film that is "ironically" related to making gritty films in New York City. Would we say there's anything "ironic" about Terminator 2: Judgment Day preceding the last 20+ years of CGI-heavy films, or anything "ironic" about Star Wars: Episode II - Attack of the Clones preceding a decade's worth of movies shot digitally instead of on film? |
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
Paid a visit to my local buy/trade store earlier. Criterions are extremely rare there and I wasn't expecting to find anything other than the usual stuff like Life Aquatic/Royal Tenembaums (In butchered-to-hell packaging to boot)
But wow. There was the Hulot trilogy! All under $5! Went ahead and blind-bought Trafic. Now I must admit that I thought each of Tati's films that I've seen in the Criterion Collection got progressively aggrivating to me (Which kinda explains why the previous owner gave these up) but even if I end up disliking this movie, at least it contains multiple documentaries about Tati whom I'm curious to know more about (Didn't even know that this was a 2-Disc til I brought it up to the counter, btw) |
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
Originally Posted by Mondo Kane
(Post 11846709)
Paid a visit to my local buy/trade store earlier. Criterions are extremely rare there and I wasn't expecting to find anything other than the usual stuff like Life Aquatic/Royal Tenembaums (In butchered-to-hell packaging to boot)
But wow. There was the Hulot trilogy! All under $5! Went ahead and blind-bought Trafic. Now I must admit that I thought each of Tati's films that I've seen in the Criterion Collection got progressively aggrivating to me (Which kinda explains why the previous owner gave these up) but even if I end up disliking this movie, at least it contains multiple documentaries about Tati whom I'm curious to know more about (Didn't even know that this was a 2-Disc til I brought it up to the counter, btw) |
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
Holiday was the only one that I've liked. But I thought Jour de fête and even Illusionist were wonderful. So maybe I just perfer Tati when he's not Hulot. But we'll see how this one goes...
|
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
I've been away for about a week for a whole bunch of reasons, but I'm getting back into the swing of things. I blind bought Red Desert last year and finally got around to watching it. It really reflects the things that I love about Antonioni, there is an emptiness and isolation to his work, but I also think that Red Desert offers moments of hope throughout.
I should be more available for the final week of the challenge and already have a few titles planned out for the Horror Challenge crossover. |
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
I just watched a behind the scenes bonus feature on my Halloween DVD and found an interesting bit of trivia. The Michael Myers mask was actually a William Shatner mask.
|
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
Originally Posted by pacaway
(Post 11845010)
In case no one has mentioned this, Wizard of Oz 3D qualifies as a Criterion movie not released on DVD. It is LD # 059
|
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
Originally Posted by Giles
(Post 11847578)
which I saw yesterday - recommended, just for the fact that it's always a treat to resee this classic film on the big screen.
|
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
We have one IMAX theater in Louisville. It *was* a Rave theater, but then Rave sold to Cinemark and then the feds wouldn't let Cinemark keep this specific theater because of anti-trust regulations so it wound up being sold to Carmike. When I checked a few weeks ago, Louisville wasn't listed as an exhibiting city for The Wizard of Oz. I learned a couple days ago, though, that this theater is showing it. I was excited to take my niece to see it.
However, they charge $13.75 per child and up to $16.75 per adult. I know, some of you are used to prices like that even for movies that aren't in IMAX 3D, but I just can't do it. Maybe Cinemark will screen it in their Classic Series in 2D at some point and I can take her to that. |
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
$19.99 up here in Canada at Cineplex for IMAX 3D. It would hurt to pay cash for it, but I have enough club points for free tickets.
Can I count watching it again while listening to Dark Side of the Moon as a commentary track? :) |
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
Originally Posted by pacaway
(Post 11847654)
Yes, agreed! now to see it again before the weekend with the iPod playing Dark Side of the Moon!
I had accrued AMC stubs 'money' that I was able to use - so $3 out of pocket for the IMAX experience wasn't so bad. |
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
Originally Posted by Travis McClain
(Post 11847678)
We have one IMAX theater in Louisville. It *was* a Rave theater, but then Rave sold to Cinemark and then the feds wouldn't let Cinemark keep this specific theater because of anti-trust regulations so it wound up being sold to Carmike. When I checked a few weeks ago, Louisville wasn't listed as an exhibiting city for The Wizard of Oz. I learned a couple days ago, though, that this theater is showing it. I was excited to take my niece to see it.
However, they charge $13.75 per child and up to $16.75 per adult. I know, some of you are used to prices like that even for movies that aren't in IMAX 3D, but I just can't do it. Maybe Cinemark will screen it in their Classic Series in 2D at some point and I can take her to that. |
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
Back at the beginning of the challenge, I put in a couple of Inter-Library Loan requests so that I could complete Susie Bright's Top 10 list. They just came in last night! Not knowing whether they would turn up at all, or in time, I've done a less than stellar job working through the others on the list. It's still doable, but it will require some cramming and for me to be kind of light on my reviewing from here on out. (My standard review process takes about an hour per film, including ranking on Flickchart and adding the review remarks/link to various lists including the challenge list, the Rank 'Em list, My Criterion list, and two Letterboxd lists.)
Originally Posted by Giles
(Post 11848976)
well I hope you hadn't promised your niece a day out to the movies to see this, because I would have been P-O'd (for her sake)
|
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
I've had an interesting past few days so I haven't had much energy to watch anything (or much time either). I am down to one check for the list, already have the movie picked out, just have to watch it. I got Monsoon Wedding from the library and hope to watch it in the next day or two. I guess I could have squeezed it in, but I want to go through this release as much as I can and it contains, from my understanding, at least 2 short films. I could be wrong; it's been a few days since I have gone through the bonus features.
|
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
Criterion just uploaded a new Top 10 - the 100th, by my count. Might wanna check what you've watched this month against it.
Donald Fagen's Top 10 --- 8½ --- Juliet of the Spirits --- My Man Godfrey --- Billy Liar --- Fanny and Alexander — The Theatrical Version --- Day of Wrath --- On the Waterfront --- The Third Man --- Topsy-Turvy --- Withnail and I |
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
Originally Posted by Travis McClain
(Post 11849482)
Criterion just uploaded a new Top 10 - the 100th, by my count. Might wanna check what you've watched this month against it.
Donald Fagen's Top 10 --- 8½ --- Juliet of the Spirits --- My Man Godfrey --- Billy Liar --- Fanny and Alexander — The Theatrical Version --- Day of Wrath --- On the Waterfront --- The Third Man --- Topsy-Turvy --- Withnail and I |
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
Originally Posted by shadokitty
(Post 11849489)
While admittedly, I haven't watched much this month, I've watched a total of 1 on this list.
|
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
Originally Posted by Travis McClain
(Post 11849580)
Me, too (My Man Godfrey), though I have previously seen 8½.
|
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
Finally saw my first Spike Lee joint: Do the Right Thing. From my Letterboxd diary:
***SPOILER ALERT FOR ANYONE READING EMAIL*** Spoiler:
Do the Right Thing -X- 1980 (1989) -X- 051-100 (#97) -X- Language: English -X- Theme: Great Soundtracks -X- Theme: New York Stories -X- Essay: Do the Right Thing by Roger Ebert 1/10 List: Miguel Arteta's Top 10 1/10 List: Alec Baldwin's Top 10 1/10 List: Diablo Cody's Top 10 1/10 List: Matt Dentler's Top 10 1/10 List: Flying Lotus's Top 10 1/10 List: Dennis LeHane's Top 10 |
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
Originally Posted by Travis McClain
(Post 11849482)
Criterion just uploaded a new Top 10 - the 100th, by my count. Might wanna check what you've watched this month against it.
Donald Fagen's Top 10 --- 8½ --- Juliet of the Spirits --- My Man Godfrey --- Billy Liar --- Fanny and Alexander — The Theatrical Version --- Day of Wrath --- On the Waterfront --- The Third Man --- Topsy-Turvy --- Withnail and I
Originally Posted by shadokitty
(Post 11849671)
Mine was On the Waterfront, also a first time view.
Just finished Monsoon Wedding. This was a blind choice, but I'm so glad I rented it. I've a special spot for India in my heart and this movie really kind of showcases a lot of the reasons I do. It was even filmed around the time I visited, so a lot of the scenes in Delhi were similar to what I saw. It is now on my to buy list, though I see the DVD version must be out of print-glad they have a BR available! |
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
Originally Posted by LJG765
(Post 11850098)
Just finished Monsoon Wedding. This was a blind choice, but I'm so glad I rented it. I've a special spot for India in my heart and this movie really kind of showcases a lot of the reasons I do. It was even filmed around the time I visited, so a lot of the scenes in Delhi were similar to what I saw. It is now on my to buy list, though I see the DVD version must be out of print-glad they have a BR available!
|
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
This is odd. A few days ago I got an email saying my Hulu Plus sub was on hold, as I had used a gift card to pay for the sub. I got to look today to see if there were any Criterions I could find that were available without Hulu Plus, and even though the bar on top of Hulu says Your Hulu Plus subscription is on hold, I still seem to be able to watch Criterion movies. I thought when Hulu put it on hold, you lost all access to watching Hulu Plus content.
|
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
Originally Posted by Travis McClain
(Post 11849931)
Finally saw my first Spike Lee joint: Do the Right Thing...
|
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
I watched The Great Dictator this afternoon and finished off Kagemusha tonight which I had started watching last night. These two finished off my checklist for the Challenge. I seem to have inadvertently hit upon the theme of identity with the films I watched this month having watched The Face of Another, Seconds, and now Kagemusha. All of them were fascinating character studies that I would rate very highly. Although I am sure I will probably watch another film or two, it has been a fun month of digging into my disc backlog of Criterion stuff that I had lying around waiting to be watched. There were lots of great first time watches that I am sure I will revisit often. I have also enjoyed reading the discussion in the thread even if I wish I had as much time as I would like to do in depth reviews for the stuff I watched.
|
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
Since we're getting near the end (And since I felt my picks for foreign-dramas had peaked with Kid with a bike) I felt like closing out this challenge only with documentaries (Gray Gardens), action films (I got one more Zatoichi film to go) and.....Comedies. And earlier, I just saw Zazie dans le métro, which just might be the most insane thing I've ever seen from France. At least the movie gave my most favorite image of this whole marathon:
http://31.media.tumblr.com/a55c9b089...wn4oo1_250.gif |
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
I've been enjoying some of the Calgary International Film Festival this week, which has cut into my home viewing time. As I mentioned earlier, I was able to see Jason and the Argonauts and now I see that they screened Amarcord a few days back. 40th anniversary, I guess. I've never seen it either. Bummer!
One of the theatres they use is about two blocks from work and the other is about eight. It's been fun. |
Re: 5th Annual Criterion Challenge - Discussion Thread
Just took a road trip down Two-Lane Blacktop. From my Letterboxd diary:
Spoiler:
Two-Lane Blacktop -X- 1970 (1971) -X- 401-450 (#414) -X- Language: English -X- Theme: America, America -X- Theme: Cult Movies -X- Theme: New American Cinema -X- Theme: Road Trips -X- Essay: Two-Lane Blacktop: Slow Ride by Kent Jones 1/11 List: Michael Atkinson's Top 10 1/10 List: Susie Bright's Top 10 1/10 List: Georgia Hubley's Top 10 1/10 List: Joe Swanberg's Top 10 1/11 List: Edgar Wright's Top 10 |
| All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:23 AM. |
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.