DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   DVD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk-3/)
-   -   So apparently there IS a regular Simpson S11 box (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk/541132-so-apparently-there-regular-simpson-s11-box.html)

Darknite39 10-08-08 12:46 AM

The apparent lack of a "regular" box for this set kept me from preordering (as I've done for just about every season from the get-go), but after this mess I'm glad I didn't bother.

Alan Smithee 10-08-08 04:21 AM

Yep, this packaging is pretty bad. To make matters even worse, once again they shipped these to stores with NO shrinkwrap over the plastic slipcover. I went to Best Buy first today but didn't buy it there because they all had price tags on the slipcovers. Had to go to Target to get a clean one. Why the fuck do they keep doing this??? They did it with "Joy Ride 2" also, which I thought about picking up but didn't mostly because of the store putting their price tag on the cardboard slipcover.

basaro 10-08-08 08:47 AM

I was gonna get this, but now I am not. Cardboard sleeves for disc storage - stupid assholes! Fox is getting hate mail from me. I was planning on getting all the future seasons, no matter how bad some of them get, but this changes everything. :wtf:

Adiras 10-08-08 11:59 AM

I'm still going to pick this up, but it is odd how they keep changing the packaging for the Simpsons.

slop101 10-08-08 08:02 PM

Ha! Soon as I opened the dvd I just knew the people here would absolutley hate the packaging.

The Krusty head is fun though superfluous (like his third nipple), but you can take it off easy enough. And the rest of the package is great - it's super compact, visually appealing and has a great booklet insert - so aside from the small hassle of removing the discs, I give this packaging a big thumbs up!

mzupeman2 10-08-08 08:18 PM

Aside from the hassle of removing discs? How about the hassle of providing packaging that's going to get those things scuffed no matter how careful you are for years with this thing? They're bound to get scuffs and scrapes, no matter how nice you take care of them.

DeanoBKN 10-08-08 08:26 PM


Originally Posted by Alan Smithee (Post 8991133)
Yep, this packaging is pretty bad. To make matters even worse, once again they shipped these to stores with NO shrinkwrap over the plastic slipcover. I went to Best Buy first today but didn't buy it there because they all had price tags on the slipcovers. Had to go to Target to get a clean one. Why the fuck do they keep doing this??? They did it with "Joy Ride 2" also, which I thought about picking up but didn't mostly because of the store putting their price tag on the cardboard slipcover.

That's my biggest pet peeve of DVD collecting.

slop101 10-08-08 08:45 PM


Originally Posted by mzupeman2 (Post 8992856)
Aside from the hassle of removing discs? How about the hassle of providing packaging that's going to get those things scuffed no matter how careful you are for years with this thing? They're bound to get scuffs and scrapes, no matter how nice you take care of them.

I've already taken the first disc in and out a few time and I have no scuffs or scrapes - and I'm not taking exceptional care removing them either - it's slick paper - it's not gonna scratch shit. Really? Are people scraping their discs as if the sleeves were sandpaper?

slop101 10-08-08 08:48 PM


Originally Posted by Alan Smithee (Post 8991133)
Yep, this packaging is pretty bad. To make matters even worse, once again they shipped these to stores with NO shrinkwrap over the plastic slipcover. I went to Best Buy first today but didn't buy it there because they all had price tags on the slipcovers. Had to go to Target to get a clean one. Why the fuck do they keep doing this???

You're kidding right? I mean, I saw the plastic slipcover as being the same thing as a shrinkwrap - I tossed it. After you take off the Krusty face, what do you need the slipcover for? It's just there to protect the face during transit.

Alan Smithee 10-09-08 04:12 AM

It has the title on the front- the ones for the previous 5 heads are needed more so because they have titles on the spines. This might not be such a big deal, but it REALLY pisses me off when they have stuff like lenticular slipcovers with no shrinkwrap so they usually put a big-ass price tag over part of it, or a few titles (like Freaked, IRobot and Napoleon Dynamite) where the keepcase art doesn't make much sense on its own.

I'm an obsessive collector so I save everything that comes with a DVD anyways, and I never buy anything used when it's still available new so putting out brand-new merchandise with no shrinkwrap over it and price tags stuck on kind of defeats that.

KingSmoth 10-09-08 10:51 AM

Im in the minority, because I really like the packaging. The fold-out is quite nice. Unfortunately, I didn't get the version with tiny metal KrustyO's inside that gash every disc. :(
Now I have Seasons 6, 7 and 11 "head" packaging, and 8-10 regular(which were gifts). If I could trade my 8-10 for the head packaging that would be sweet.

PixarFan1988 10-09-08 11:59 AM

I bought The Simpsons: Season 11 on Tuesday and I too hate the way they packaged the dvd. I put the discs in seperate CD cases so they won't get scratched.

SexualPudding 10-09-08 05:41 PM


Originally Posted by Alan Smithee (Post 8993324)
It has the title on the front- the ones for the previous 5 heads are needed more so because they have titles on the spines. This might not be such a big deal, but it REALLY pisses me off when they have stuff like lenticular slipcovers with no shrinkwrap so they usually put a big-ass price tag over part of it, or a few titles (like Freaked, IRobot and Napoleon Dynamite) where the keepcase art doesn't make much sense on its own.

I'm an obsessive collector so I save everything that comes with a DVD anyways, and I never buy anything used when it's still available new so putting out brand-new merchandise with no shrinkwrap over it and price tags stuck on kind of defeats that.

Can't you just put a little goo-gone or lighter fluid on the price sticker and easily remove it? Jesus. It really isn't that big of a deal.

My Other Self 10-09-08 05:50 PM

Meh, all of my stuff was fine with no price tags.

Buy it at Target, they don't put tags on their stuff.

Swahili 10-09-08 09:40 PM

Yeah my buddy bought this the other day. Ridiculous cardboard sleeves to hold the discs, and his first disc was scratched so badly that it wouldn't even play in my DVD player.

erlong 10-22-08 08:55 PM

The guys over at tvshowsondvd.com think the packaging is crap also: http://www.tvshowsondvd.com/news/Sim...-Box-Art/10740

Upper pylon 3 10-23-08 07:40 AM

I read the ^ article. I don't care for the "head" packaging and always order the regular. As I understand it, unlike the previous Simpsons releases, the Krusty head release is basically the regular release with a Krusty head attached and can be removed. Is that correct? Do I not have to worry about which version to order? Last time I checked dd.com does not have a listing for the regular packaging and I want to order it from them during the Nov. sale.

KLZ 10-23-08 10:28 AM


Originally Posted by Upper pylon 3 (Post 9023254)
I read the ^ article. I don't care for the "head" packaging and always order the regular. As I understand it, unlike the previous Simpsons releases, the Krusty head release is basically the regular release with a Krusty head attached and can be removed. Is that correct? Do I not have to worry about which version to order? Last time I checked dd.com does not have a listing for the regular packaging and I want to order it from them during the Nov. sale.

Yes.

Upper pylon 3 10-23-08 10:45 AM

Cool. Thanks! :thumbsup:

dx23 10-23-08 12:06 PM

FOX should offer a packaging replacement. The disc sooner or later are going to be damaged either by smudge or scratches, all because of the crappy packaging. Is the a customer service email where people who bought this set can voice their opinion about this issue?

dsa_shea 12-29-08 06:42 PM

I picked up the head set today price matching at Best Buy for 14.99+tax. I agree that the packaging should have been better though. Why does packaging have to regress?

DerangedHermit 12-29-08 07:10 PM


Originally Posted by dsa_shea (Post 9162300)
Why does packaging have to regress?

the alighty ollar?

acdcrocks1980 12-29-08 10:15 PM

I got all my discs out, and I can tell you now, they aren't going back in until i get some cd sleeves.

Abob Teff 12-31-08 11:23 PM

I like the "head concept" but when they kept bouncing back and forth, I gave up. Sometimes you could only get the head; sometimes you could get either; sometimes you could get the head and buy the box; sometimes the heads were limited and you couldn't find them if you bought late ... to hell with it. I'm waiting for the complete series.

Cameron 01-01-09 01:18 AM


Originally Posted by dsa_shea (Post 9162300)
I picked up the head set today price matching at Best Buy for 14.99+tax. I agree that the packaging should have been better though. Why does packaging have to regress?

who had it for 14.99 in the first place?


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:43 PM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.